2 ms·
The data in the "Lost in Place" report that the first point references seems questionable. I spot-checked a couple municipalities I had firsthand experience wi
by nostrademons 8y ago
The data in the "Lost in Place" report that the first point references seems questionable. I spot-checked a couple municipalities I had firsthand experience with (Boston, San Francisco, and San Jose). The worst "fallen star" census tract was the Boston Harbor Islands, which ostensibly has gone from 9% poverty to 82% poverty over the last 40 years. However, this is largely because most existing private uses for the islands have been discontinued, such that the largest complex on them is a sewage treatment plant on Deer Island and a homeless shelter & public services complex on Long Island. When most of a census tract of 1500 becomes a national park and the only thing left is public housing for the homeless, of course the poverty rate is going up.
Similarly, the only "fallen star" in San Francisco was the area around SFSU. If most of the population in a census tract consists of college students without an income, of course the poverty rate is going up. That isn't actually reflective of poverty as we know it, though, because it just so happens those districts include people who are spending hundreds of thousands for a credential that will hopefully let them earn more in the future, and isn't reflective of their lifetime earning potential.
Makes me wonder how many of the other "fallen star" neighborhoods the report references consists of colleges, prisons, or other social services.