10 ms·
Breaking bad news
- leowoo91 8y agoOh, burying the lead has never been easier by closing an entire department than terminating few employees one by one.
- scrollaway 8y agoI'm amused by the title which can be read several different ways: Breaking Bad news: News about the TV series Breaking Bad (Breaking) Bad news: Bad news, hot off the press Breaking bad news: how to break (announce) bad news Breaking bad news: Breaking (disrupting) bad news Intended meaning is the third, btw.
- aogl 8y agoI too initially perceived it as being Breaking Bad news. Tv show..
- Walkman 8y agome too! :D
- quickthrower2 8y agoI'm watching Breaking Bad while reading this. Better Cool Sole.
- ekianjo 8y agoThats where machine learning algorithms will lose every single time vs a human. They cant grasp the context in NLP.
- adrianN 8y ago...yet
- titzer 8y agoThe context might be the entirety of living as a human for 40+ years. When one of these computer zombies can ape this, let me know.
- ekianjo 8y agoAnd the context will vary from generation to generation so it's virtually an impossible problem to solve as well. It's even hard for humans to truly understand texts written from another era...
- dotancohen 8y agoHow about sabotaging the delivery of bad news?
- gumby 8y agoSTOP CASTING POROSITY (of the many links, here is one from a newspaper: https://www.eastbaytimes.com/2005/09/16/stop-casting-porosity-sign-awakens-nostalgia/ https://www.eastbaytimes.com/2005/09/16/stop-casting-porosit...)
- andyn 8y agohttps://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ https://ourincrediblejourney.tumblr.com/ is a goldmine of bad examples.
- pixelcort 8y agoI'm confused. Is this article announcing bad news or is it just describing how others announce bad news?
- leowoo91 8y agoSuggesting different ways to announce bad news, and pinpointing some cautions. Maybe title of HN post should be "How to break bad news"
- baxtr 8y agoReading the article actually helps sometimes...
- close04 8y agoIt's obviously news about Breaking Bad. Probably a sequel... :D
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- HHalvi 8y agoMinor rant: Boz's site still doesn't have an SSL.
- msmith10101 8y agoSorry to break the news to you, boz, but FB is a toxic waste of X. Fire yourself, pls.
- dang 8y agoCould you please stop posting uncivil and/or unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?
- leoedin 8y agoI was once faced with the prospect of losing my job. The company wasn't in a good place financially and they didn't have any projects for me at that moment. Far worse than the prospect of losing my job was my boss. If there was bad news to be given, he'd just melt into the background and let someone else do it, even though he'd hired me. (It was a rather dysfunctional company in general). That really stuck with me, far more than facing losing my job did. It's hard to be honest and direct about bad news, but it's the only way you should do it. Anything else is putting your own desire to not face fear above the needs of the person who is going to have to deal with the news. That's a really selfish thing to do.
- scarface74 8y agoIf there was bad news to be given, he'd just melt into the background and let someone else do it, even though he'd hired me. (It was a rather dysfunctional company in general). At the level I’m at now, I always ask the hiring manager how do they deliver bad news and what is their theory on feedback. I’m usually responsible for major initiatives even if I am 70% a heads down coder. I actually found it refreshing when a senior manager told me straight up that I missed a requirement and that it was a “big f-up”, after dealing with managers that beat around the bush. I’ve got work to do, initiatives to lead, etc. I don’t have time to be reading between the lines. I want a manager who lays it on the line so I can course correct. Working at a small company, major mistakes mean a lot.
- endymi0n 8y agoThis hits it right home. The other piece of advice I've learned about breaking bad news, especially in the light of the excellent management tips here I always refer junior leaders to: http://www.defmacro.org/2014/10/03/engman.html http://www.defmacro.org/2014/10/03/engman.html > 32. Have difficult conversations as soon as possible. Waiting will only make a bad situation worse. > 42. Unless you’re a sociopath, firing people is so hard you’ll invent excuses not to do it. If you’re consistently wondering if someone’s a good fit for too long, have the courage to do what you know is right. And specifically about this: It's really best to deliver bad news like this not just as clearly as possible, but also as early. If I'm in the dire situation of having to fire someone, I'm starting with that news right away in the clearest words possible that are not hurtful. The most important thing about it is to leave zero ambiguity. It will hurt anyway, but it leaves the rest of the conversation to recovery and solution-focus. Maybe it's possible to do a referral or an intro or just giving some space and time to listen. But if you have bad news, take the OPs advice to heart — and do it as fast as possible.
- ghaff 8y agoAnd be prepared for complete surprise. I've been involved in situations where one would have thought it was incredibly and abundantly clear to everyone involved that things were absolutely not working out. (Without going into a lot of details, heavy and extensive rework in multiple passes of projects they were working on over months.) Yet, getting fired was apparently a complete bolt out of the blue.
- maxerickson 8y agoThis is what the Dunning-Kruger paper is about, that the mental tools of work and self evaluation are interconnected.
- ghaff 8y agoI don't think it's so much Dunning-Kruger as just being being almost willfully oblivious to signals that are trying to tell you things that you really don't want to realize. (As opposed to simply choosing to ignore what you know in your heart is really going on.)
- ordinaryperson 8y agoThis applies to almost every situation where you have to break bad news, like being a manager or a parent. When you want to provide negative performance feedback at work, be direct and professional, Don't bury it in a "compliment sandwich" ('You're doing a great job, except when you're not, but don't worry'). It's a hard skill to master (unless you're a non-feeling sociopath) because it means accepting that you will (possibly) be disliked, maybe even hated. Same for children. They are going to hate you (at least temporarily) for criticism or punishment, but if you try to be fair, fact-based and direct hopefully they will appreciate it down the road when they have more context.
- hguhghuff 8y agoMost people lack the courage to honestly deliver bad news.
- jeroen94704 8y agoAs an addition to this, if the bad news will have a big impact on whoever you are delivering it to, just tell them the bad news and then sit back and wait for them to start talking. Reason: If you tell someone they are being let go, whatever you say immediately after that won't get processed. Give them time to let it sink in and get over the first shock. They'll start talking/asking questions when they're able to.
- sorokod 8y agoWith some slight changes this can be a guide for receiving bad news.
- flaviocopes 8y agoSide note: using Safari, with Ghostery enabled (which blocks the Twitter widget), the homepage links do not work. The URL changes, but the content does not. In the console I get > TypeError: undefined is not an object (evaluating 'twttr.widgets.load')
- DoreenMichele 8y agoThe advice about how to handle it is spot on, but I feel like it is missing something. That's not a harsh criticism because I'm struggling to articulate it myself. Two things come to mind. The first is "Don't kill the messenger." This is now metaphorical, but was originally literal. The reason you don't kill the bearer of bad tidings is because if communication breaks down, you have lost all hope of a diplomatic solution. Now the war has to be fought to the very bitter end of last man standing. The second thing that comes to mind is an anecdote from raising my children. My oldest had sleep issues from birth. When he was two, he often stayed up later than me. I would give him a drink, a snack and put a video tape in the VCR. He could come get me if he really needed me, but if it wasn't an emergency, I encouraged him to let me sleep. More snacks and drinks were physically accessible to him. He was both allowed to get them and physically able to do so. Inevitably, he sometimes spilled stuff. My policy was that he wasn't going to get in trouble for spilling stuff. Spills happen. But I needed to know when he spilled things. I also needed to know where it got spilled and what he had spilled so I could clean it up properly. Some juices are the same color, but have very different chemical properties. Some can be easily wiped up. Others need special treatment. Also, if you don't clean it up, it's going to mold or attract insects, etc. Nothing good will come of it. It is all down side to make your kid scared to tell you they spilled something. He was a bit weirded out the first time because he was a little hellion who got yelled at out of concern for his safety so much that when he first began using the word no, he said it at full volume because he thought that's how it was pronounced. So he basically figured I would yell at him. But he told me he spilled something and all I asked was where he spilled it and what was it. He showed me and told me and I cleaned it up and didn't punish him. After that, he was good. He trusted me. I wasn't going to yell at him over it. Keeping the lines of communication open is critical. If your people are scared to tell you what's going on, then problems are being swept under the rug and left to fester and grow worse. It's vastly worse to make it a problem to share bad news.
- MrGilbert 8y ago> My policy was that he wasn't going to get in trouble for spilling stuff. Spills happen. That was basically the first thing I told my sister when she moved in after our mum passed away a few months ago: "No matter which mistake you make, tell us. We won't punish you for that. However, if you lie to us, there will be some sort of punishment." So far, it seems to work out, as she's getting more and more open, and talks to us about her feelings, her day, etc. Something that wasn't possible in the very first beginning. She also admits mistakes she does, and starts to ask for help more often - not as much as we'd like, but... yeah. Hopefully, that will be better over the next months.
- alias_neo 8y agoI recall an example from earlier in my career where an employer was looking to prune bad apples in the company. They failed to deliver the news correctly, and although many knew in their hearts it wouldn't affect them, we were all professionals, majority engineers, and used a logical thought process to resolve it internally; The news didn't specify who wouldn't be affected, and although the intended number was meant to be rather low (half a dozen people) in a ~100 person company, everyone started looking for other jobs to cover themselves. Everyone has bills to pay etc and it's unwise not to plan ahead. Logically thinking, there was no harm in having a backup plan. Well, come time to prune, the expected numbers are pruned, and then, the unexpected (to the employer) happened, tens more people left. The bad news had given everyone with the "get-up-and-go" a kick to look elsewhere and realise actually we were all being mistreated. The company quickly lost some of their best talent.
- lysp 8y agoAnd ironically some of the good staff probably left, leaving the company remaining with some of the bad apples.
- pc86 8y agoWell as they said the folks who needed to be terminated were terminated, they just lost more in the process. Presumably the folks who left voluntarily after this would be on the higher end of skills as they were able to quickly find another position. So the worst performers are terminated, the best performers leave voluntarily, and the company is left with all the mediocre folks and an overall decrease is skills and abilities.
- gvb 8y agoThat is a good point that I didn't see in my quick scan of the 44 rules... If you have a target audience, give a specific message to only that target audience. Do not give the message to a larger group than the target audience. I've seen (and been guilty of) giving a vague, non-specific message to "everybody" when only one or two people were the actual target of the message. This causes incredible problems with those in the audience that are not the target of the message. Ironically, the one or two people that are the problem typically remain oblivious to the fact that they were the target of the message.
- davidlartey 8y agoGreat advice. I also think it will work in every situation - from leaders and to leadership.
- teekert 8y agoOk, good advice, but what if someone is just not good enough? Firing someone, stopping a project, it is not the fault of the employee (not always at least). But I'm currently in a situation where I (for my first time) have to tell someone they work too slow and seem to never finish stuff properly. The guy is just not good enough and it start to annoy me because he is not taking steps to improve. I find it very difficult, it concerns an otherwise nice guy that I have coffee or beers with from time to time. I know it's best to just say: Hey this isn't working. But I want to find a job better suited to him, I don't want him wasting my time anymore when I ask him how he did something and it seems he never put it in our git repo.
- sundvor 8y agoHave you tried communicating these concerns to him? Break down the expectations, e.g. that everything must be committed in the repo, with covering tests etc? If he takes it on board, win! If he ignores it and takes offense, well at least you tried?
- teekert 8y agoI tried setting dead lines "Ok, lets make sure this is finished next week". But there is always an excuse, but it boils down to him being a poor programmer, he gets stuck and then he works on the other project he is employed in. The poorness is understandable in our circumstance and sort of ok (we were driven into this kind of work and I happen to love it, he happens to have no talent for it what so ever). I did offer other work (back to the lab in stead of doing the bioinformatics) but he does somehow seem to enjoy it. I know, time to be hard and honest indeed.
- jrockway 8y agoArbitrary deadlines rarely work. Psychologically they just encourage "student syndrome" where people feel like they can slack off until the deadline actually seems threatening. Then the deadline is missed. That is the nature of human psychology, not your particular employee. Avery talks it about a bit here (read the section where "student syndrome" starts showing up): https://apenwarr.ca/log/?m=201712#13 https://apenwarr.ca/log/?m=201712#13 Ultimately, your job as a manager is to keep your team unstuck. People get fired all the time because their manager is bad at management, as it's certainly a supervisor's privilege to fire people they don't like. But always remember that your assessment "this guy is lazy and doesn't like the field" could be completely wrong and you're just bad at management.
- codingdave 8y agoOne of the keys to breaking any news is that whether it is good or bad, most people immediately translate it internally into how it impacts them. Bad news makes that translation come out as "Here is what I just lost." The loss of leadership credibility comes when you are dismissive of that loss as part of the announcement, or you pre-emptively tell people they should be feeling another way. Most change management education will tell you that whether you like it or not, the process will happen the same way as any personal loss - denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance. The trick in business is to speed the process to acceptance without being dismissive of the people going through the change. The tools to do so normally are all about communication: Listening, answering questions, replying with clarity so everyone knows the path forward. In fast-changing organizations, such as startups, there is also a question of how often you change things. If you send your teams reeling with bad news and changes before they have accepted the last round of it, you will trash morale. One school of thought is not to make small changes, but instead to think out bigger solutions to your problems, and lay out changes all at once. Trying to fix one piece at a time, then rolling changes to smaller parts of the organization every few weeks may feel easier to manage, but it comes at a higher personal cost to the teams, and frequently saps productivity and morale for a longer term.
- dswalter 8y agoPSA for anyone reading this, the phrase is colloquially "burying the lede." "The lede" is a journalistic term roughly meaning the gist of the story. http://grammarist.com/usage/lead-lede/ http://grammarist.com/usage/lead-lede/
- ghaff 8y agoI'd argue this is a bit different. (Though one or two of the examples are close.) We're talking here about sugar-coating, spinning, etc. Burying the lede tends to apply more to writing a story that goes into a bunch of routine story details or a story that's only peripherally related entirely. And then, after some time, a paragraph about news that's genuinely novel, interesting, etc. For example, writing about a bunch of routine speech contents and then 6 paragraphs down mentioning some major revelation.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- combatentropy 8y agoBut the commenter is right. The saying is "burying the lede." There is no such thing as "burying the lead." The author of the article meant to borrow the jargon of reporters, to add color. Your comment is like this more extreme example: ARTICLE: I thumbled the plate and it shattered on the floor. COMMENTER: The word is fumbled. YOU: I would argue this is different because fumbling tends to apply to football.
- timcederman 8y agoBoth versions are acceptable, particularly outside the US. It is a deliberate misspelling of "lead". https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/bury-the-lede-versus-lead https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/bury-the-lede-...
- quirkot 8y agoI have read some accounts of "burying the lead" but they were all about Flint, Michigan.
- JshWright 8y agoI think one important item missing from that list is "Use clear language" (it's hinted at by a number of other items in the list, but that's exactly the problem...). People tend to use gentler sounding euphemisms instead of stating the situation plainly.
- dibstern 8y agoGreat article! Loved it. Not sure if the author is posting this, but if you are, one small thing - it’s burying the ‘lede’, not ‘lead’. Thought you’d want to know :)
- quirkot 8y agoA practical and high stakes application of these same points: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/04/opinion/sunday/how-to-tell-a-mother-her-child-is-dead.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/04/opinion/sunday/how-to-tel... Reading that NYT piece sharply impacted how I communicate undesirable information
- jamiek88 8y agoWow. My wife often has to deliver the news that someone’s baby has died or pregnancy has failed, she always has a bad time afterward particularly as it happened to us twice too. Reading this article really helped me appreciate more how much it takes out of the person delivering the news. I mean I have had conversations with her about it but she often can’t talk about it in detail. Thank goodness her work is progressive enough to pay for monthly counseling so she has someone to really open up to about this stuff.
- makmanalp 8y agoEven the name "bad news", depending on the situation, can come off as a bit of a deflection - if you're causing the bad news (e.g. firing someone), then it's not bad news, it's just you! Not to say that that it's your fault per se, but the wording is a bit weaselly, which often doesn't do much more than add to the frustration.
- sleepychu 8y agoOne of my first ever jobs they announced minor redundancies on, say Tuesday afternoon, 1M$ in EMEA (maybe 5000 people). Not too concerning. On Wednesday afternoon the same person "corrected" themselves, 2M$ in this office (200 people). The environment after that was... frenetic. Also enjoyed the same person later responding to suggestions that we could save money across the board by some sort of pay reduction (so that we would lose fewer jobs) "ah, well we already pay significantly under market rate so if we do that then we're likely to lose our best talent"
- gist 8y agoI am always amazed at how HN takes little morsels like this and votes them up. The information presented is no more insightful or valuable than info found in comments or from the views of less well known or important people. Yet everyone seems to think that it deserves attention and some kind of added respect (which is all based upon what the person has 'achieved' if you want to call it that.) It's as if people seem to think that the knowledge is so significant that the halo will rub off. So the question is to what extent does it matter what someone says if it's not their a) area of expertise or b) there is nothing truly remarkable about it in other words they are not backing it up with really solid examples based on long term experience? Would love to be able to do a test. Take the exact same thoughts and unlink them from the halo and see what happens. Would expect exactly the predictable results. I guess my point is also whether someone who is smart and has enough luck to be able to become wealthy deserves more respect than someone who is just smart and did not have the luck to have that success?
- debt 8y agoHe should try replacing all the "we"'s and "you"'s with "I"'s and "me"'s as as far as I can tell, he's the only one that had to really be dealing with bad news recently. Also, would drive his point home further as he'd be speaking from personal experience of using those very techniques during the whole Cambridge Analytic scandal.
- qubax 8y agoAnyone else thought this was going to be news about the tv series Breaking Bad?
- Spectral 8y agoYou say "Speaking simply, it just doesn’t work." But from an everyday perspective, it works all the time? In recent light companies like Uber, Riot Games, Equifax, etc. have come under huge criticism but what do they do? They do "accept" responsibility in corporate speak but just make bs promises and stay quiet and wait for the PR shitstorm to calm down. Then to a good extent the people/the public forget about it and move on. Obviously this is a really bad thing, but they know it's human nature that you can only keep your attention on something (whether good or bad) for so long until you have to move your resources on to something else.