3 ms·
I think the problem with Lean today is that everybody knows about it. Starting a startup in 2002-2005 was hard, just the mechanics of it. Incorporating took s
by nostrademons 8y ago
I think the problem with Lean today is that everybody knows about it.
Starting a startup in 2002-2005 was hard, just the mechanics of it. Incorporating took several thousand dollars of lawyer time; there was no Clerky, and online LLC-generators were largely unknown. Accepting payments meant getting a merchant account with a CC; no Stripe, Square, or other payment processors. Payroll meant dealing with ADP or PayChex; benefits meant hiring a person to manage those relationships. There was no YC, generally no seed funding ecosystem other than angels, no AngelList, no gigantic startup blogging scene where everybody gives advice on everything.
As a result, there were plenty of unfilled pain points, and potential customers were overjoyed when someone would actually come talk to them about it rather than assuming they knew what was best, a la big companies or massively VC-funded startups.
Now, everybody and their brother is founding startups, which means that if you do happen across a genuine pain point, there are already 2 dozen startups working on it. Customers get weary of even talking to prospective entrepreneurs because they've had that conversation so many times before. I've done the Lean Startup methodology, and have several friends that have tried it; the most likely outcome today is that you'll talk to a 100 customers (after trying to talk to several hundred more who don't respond), and then discover that there's no actual market need addressable with current technology and you should keep your day job.
Like most knowledge related to markets, once everyone believes it's true, it ceases to be true.
- abraham_lincoln 8y agoSo, it seems the methodolgy worked, right? It prevented you from wasting time on a product that has no market.
- nostrademons 8y agoYep, you could argue that finding out after 2 months that an idea won't work is preferable to wasting 2 years on it. 'Course, then I went and repeated the process 8 more times, then decided that if there are no untapped market areas that can be filled by existing technology, it's time to spend 2 years inventing new technology. It remains to be seen whether that's a waste or not. At some point you also have to apply the same logic to methodologies that you apply to ideas, though. The point of the Lean Startup methodology is to avoid wasting time implementing ideas that won't work so you can find a scalable, sustainable business model quicker. If your goal is to found a startup and all experience is that the Lean Startup methodology, in 2018, does not provide a scalable, sustainable way to do that, then you should ditch the methodology. Chances are you'll have to do your own methodology invention, though, because once a scalable, sustainable way to get rich becomes commonly known, it ceases to be sustainable. (See also Bitcoin, which was a great way to get rich when nobody considered it a way to get rich, and then became a great way to become poor when everybody was certain it would make them rich.)
- jjeaff 8y agoYou are thinking to big. Look for a niche. If there are 2 dozen startups already competing in that space, it's not very niche. There are plenty of opportunities out there big enough to make a founder very wealthy, but not big enough to attract the least bit of interest from a VC.
- nostrademons 8y agoCare to share?
- nazgulnarsil 8y agoConsumables. The big players are brain dead in terms of product innovation which means you get successful small companies entering all the time. Greek yogurt, deodorant, energy bars (Hi! I'm the cofounder of Mealsquares!), coffee, you name it. Tech founders don't want to touch this stuff.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cellis 8y agoThat's because those things are flooded with competitors and margins don't scale nearly as well as pure tech. Every time I walk through my local farmers market I see a new brand of Kumbucha or Flat Tummy Tea. But, there is competition everywhere, and it gets fiercer by the day. So pick something you're truly interested in and roll with it until the wheels fall off. That's really your only chance ( if you have one at all ).
- tmountain 8y agoJust OOC, what do you recommend as an alternative to ADP for payroll? Didn't know about Clerky. Very cool.
- nostrademons 8y agoGusto is excellent these days. There are a few other entrants that I'm not terribly familiar with; the market opened up a lot around 2012 or so.