3 ms·
Shut down FCC. That's all it would take. Sure, your FM radio would stop working, but that's a small sacrifice to make, to get actual competition in something a
by jessaustin 8y ago
Shut down FCC. That's all it would take.
Sure, your FM radio would stop working, but that's a small sacrifice to make, to get actual competition in something as important as telecommunications.
- eigenloss 8y agoThis is the worst solution posed here. If we had no FCC, large companies would be thrown into an arms race to pump as much RF as possible into the air while smaller ones (radio stations, anybody?) would simply be drowned out and crushed.
- jessaustin 8y agoJust like in the wifi band... oh, wait. I'm not saying that radio use can't be regulated. I'm saying that FCC is the worst possible organization that could be imagined to do that regulation. To understand that, simply compare Europe to USA.
- GW150914 8y agoShut down FCC. That's all it would take. Sure, your FM radio would stop working, but that's a small sacrifice to make, to get actual competition in something as important as telecommunications. Good idea, I was just thinking that I hate how emergency services can talk to each other, and my cellphone works. People are so damned soft, they should have to release a homing pigeon if they want to call 911! Sure, a few people might die and life will be a dark and terrible nightmare of RF interference, radio astronomy will end, and modern civilization will grind to a halt, but that’s a small price to pay for my libertarian wet dream.
- jessaustin 8y agoFCC is uniquely bad among USA government regulatory agencies. I'm fine with EPA, FTC, OSHA, FAA, etc. All of those place reasonable limits on human action. They don't say, "this market will be 40% VZN and 45% ATT!" Any number of other agencies could keep the emergency services bands online. Most of the actual regulation of how devices radiate signals is already controlled by voluntary associations of manufacturers. Please don't discuss your wet dreams in this forum.
- jsgo 8y agoDunno, having an actor to oversee the behavior of telecoms would be an advantage, not the opposite. In our neighborhood, we're waiting on Spectrum to finish their infrastructure install. We were initially in talks with AT&T to come in too, but they backed out when we couldn't do community agreements (beyond easement) again and we wouldn't agree to them using the existing infrastructure (which was terrible) from the previous provider below. No other provider, asides from HughesNet, is willing to come in now that there is a non-exclusive agreement with Spectrum for easement access. Moral of the story, companies aren't going to act with consumers' interests at heart. Didn't Charter or someone have some agreement where part of some merger approval required that they built out into rural areas? A requirement they didn't comply with? The provider we had before was absolutely terrible with $90/month spent on a basic DishTV package + 3Mbps internet. They had an exclusive easement, but due to constant outages because the infrastructure couldn't support the community, we were able to finally get out of it after 6 years and lots of lawyer involvement. FCC wouldn't get involved, but having the government take a more active oversight role would be a good thing, in my experience.
- jessaustin 8y agoThe fact that no provider will serve this neighborhood without exclusivity is contingent upon the woeful state of telecom competition in USA. If it were regulated like e.g. automobiles (basic requirements, but nothing about a particular vendor "owning" some portion of the market or the road), then you'd have a choice of WISPs. You might not get a wired connection, depending on density etc. As you can see from the European contributions to this thread, wireless can actually be very good. If the neighbors wanted to go in together for a really big fat wireless connection in higher portions of the spectrum, the "last block" could still be wired. That would be an easy upgrade to fiber once that made sense. Market forces would still govern that deal, because of those WISPs.