3 ms·

When are containers going to graduate to a built-in feature rather than an extension?

by bhauer 8y ago

Iem3ohvi 8y ago
All the heavy lifting for containers is built-in. It's just the mapping of tabs to containers, the creation/disposal of containers and UI parts that's managed through the extensions because users do have different preferences and use-cases in that area. E.g. they may want automatic rule-driven assignment of domains to containers except when either blah blah holds or when manually overridden. The built-in minimal and completely manual UI can be enabled with privacy.userContext.enabled = true
gsa 8y ago
Containers used to be the other way around, baked into Firefox and then moved to an extension last year. It's better that a power user feature is not a part of the default installation.
- davnicwil 8y ago
  Containers are the killer feature of Firefox over Chrome and the reason I recommend it to family and friends. In my opinion they're not a power user feature at all, everyone and anyone can get instant obvious benefit from them. Multiple logins on the same service, controlling how you are tracked, just to name a couple. Attention and effort are expensive and 'install and just use' gets you a material percentage more users than 'install and then click through this menu system and install something else'. Containers should absolutely work out the box.
billysielu 8y ago
You can turn it on, it's called First Party Isolation.
briffle 8y ago
I would love a way to sync my sites defined in containers, so that site A opens in the correct container on all my computers running firefox. I would really love tabgroups to magically start working again, but I have been making due with containers. (and it does have some nice features)
TheWiseOne 8y ago
I am not sure if that'll be the case. The Multi Account Container (https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers) seems like it's dead. No new commits since end of March and according to https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/339#issuecomment-414716459 https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/3..., it's only going to get bug fixes and maintenance patches. No new development. I have a feeling that they are relying on extension developers to add features/functionality.

When are containers going to graduate to a built-in feature rather than an extension?

by bhauer 8y ago

When are containers going to graduate to a built-in feature rather than an extension?

All the heavy lifting for containers is built-in. It's just the mapping of tabs to containers, the creation/disposal of containers and UI parts that's managed through the extensions because users do have different preferences and use-cases in that area. E.g. they may want automatic rule-driven assignment of domains to containers except when either blah blah holds or when manually overridden. The built-in minimal and completely manual UI can be enabled with privacy.userContext.enabled = true

gsa 8y ago

Containers used to be the other way around, baked into Firefox and then moved to an extension last year. It's better that a power user feature is not a part of the default installation.

davnicwil 8y ago
Containers are the killer feature of Firefox over Chrome and the reason I recommend it to family and friends. In my opinion they're not a power user feature at all, everyone and anyone can get instant obvious benefit from them. Multiple logins on the same service, controlling how you are tracked, just to name a couple. Attention and effort are expensive and 'install and just use' gets you a material percentage more users than 'install and then click through this menu system and install something else'. Containers should absolutely work out the box.

billysielu 8y ago

You can turn it on, it's called First Party Isolation.

briffle 8y ago

I would love a way to sync my sites defined in containers, so that site A opens in the correct container on all my computers running firefox. I would really love tabgroups to magically start working again, but I have been making due with containers. (and it does have some nice features)

TheWiseOne 8y ago

I am not sure if that'll be the case. The Multi Account Container (https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers) seems like it's dead. No new commits since end of March and according to https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/339#issuecomment-414716459 https://github.com/mozilla/multi-account-containers/issues/3..., it's only going to get bug fixes and maintenance patches. No new development. I have a feeling that they are relying on extension developers to add features/functionality.