3 ms·
I'm not seeing how crank and cam specs significantly affect cooling at idle all else being equal. Any cooling system that can work under load will be fine at i
by dsfyu404ed 8y ago
I'm not seeing how crank and cam specs significantly affect cooling at idle all else being equal. Any cooling system that can work under load will be fine at idle.
Edit:
For something like a race-car that's trying to minimize weight/power loss by running the minimum radiator/fan necessary and depending on airflow from movement (or rely on the fact that you're only running 1/4mi at a time) I can understand. Still, that's a cooling system sizing issue, not a cam or crank issue. A street going vehicle isn't going to have a cooling system that's sized within a hair of inadequate like that. Power output (and heat generated) at/near idle should be fairly constant regardless of cam and if it's not the higher power output cam profiles will probably have lower power output at/near idle (this depends a lot on the engine, some engines force you to choose where you want your power, some are hard to throw "too much cam" at). No matter how you cut it only so much air can get passed a closed throttle and that amount of air only corresponds to a certain amount of fuel, that puts an upper bound on heat generated at idle. I can see how adding forced induction could significantly affect heat generated at idle but even then, if everything is sized properly it shouldn't be much of an issue.
This place is really turning into Reddit where you get down-voted for questioning anyone who sounds knowledgeable.
- maxxxxx 8y agoCars depend on air moving through the cooling system under load which means it's at speed. Cooling at idle can be a big problem for high performance cars. Going to the extreme, F1 cars have to be super careful not to overheat when stopped.
- justin66 8y ago> Cooling at idle can be a big problem for high performance cars. Or any air cooled car ever made. But the reality is that in a lot of designs, idling will test the effectiveness of the cooling system more than driving the car at speed. (Adding power only exacerbates such a problem. The OP completely fails to understand this) It's much less of a problem than it used to be, with lots of cars including electric fans to help out the radiator, but it used to be standard to see a warning in the owner's manual about temperatures increasing in slow traffic or at idle.
- maxxxxx 8y ago"Or any air cooled car ever made." Are there still any being built? I thought the 911 was the last holdout until they also switched to water cooling. "with lots of cars including electric fans to help out the radiator," I had that fan breaking once in my Miata and temperatures went into the red really quickly in LA rush hour.
- justin66 8y agoThey switched the 911 over to water-cooled in the late nineties, yes. Prior to that, Porsche got the idle temp problem somewhat under control using powerful electric fans positioned in front of some of the oil coolers, but there's essentially no reliable way to cool four-valve cylinder heads with a purely air-cooled engine (the 959 used separate water cooling just for the heads), so they decided the whole thing was a performance dead end. The air-cooled 911 Turbo did get up above 400hp with two-valve heads before the change, though. > I had that fan breaking once in my Miata and temperatures went into the red really quickly in LA rush hour. No doubt. Once you train yourself to hear that fan, you realize how much the car depends on it.
- maxxxxx 8y agoThe problem is that they lost the air cooler sound. A long time ago I drove an air cooled 911 on track. It wasn't that crazy powerful (300hp) but the sound was just fantastic.
- justin66 8y agoThey got big and fat, too. The air-cooled cars had wheelbases similar to your Miata, but they were really pretty small compared to the modern Porsche stuff. The new stuff is technologically stunning, of course.
- maxxxxx 8y agoTrue. The old 911s were really small. Now everything is way too big, including the Miata. Mine was a 2000 which was already much bigger than the original but the current ones are just way too big. That's not the point of a Miata.
- justin66 8y agoAirflow. Powerful motors will sometimes run well enough at speed but overheat at idle. For example, after receiving an upgrade like a camshaft with more radical timings. One key point: you can increase the size of a radiator or oil cooler but that helps a lot more when the vehicle is actually moving.
- mikestew 8y agoNot cooling, but heat output, which the cooling system at idle cannot keep up with. As a simple example, you can retard the ignition timing enough on an otherwise sound car that the coolant will boil just sitting there idling (DAMHIK). The moral is, where the piston is at when the spark goes off makes a difference, as well which valves are opening when. Crank those knobs far enough toward the extremes, and you'll blow past the design limits of the cooling system. Yeah, your system used to be fine at idle, but now you fiddled with things. It's like the kids that throw a K&N air filter in their Civic and call it a day. No, ya idjit, you changed one thing and now you have to go change some other things to compensate. In this case, get a bigger radiator or a bigger fan. Put another way, one does those mods to increase power output. Not all of the increased power is used to turn the wheels, a lot of it is turned to heat (just like a stock engine). More power, more heat, more cooling is required.
- quintiles 8y agoRE: Downvoting. Just give up. There is no correlatiing reason for downvoting. Don't even think about keeping a user name for more than a day. It's not worth trying to please anyone around here anymore. Just cut a fresh user name, dump your honest opinion into it once, and then walk away from that user name. The amazing part is that HN tends to auto-hellban new users, if two are created by at the same IP address, inside of 24 hours. HN also auto-hallbans for other reasons. Because of this, there is also a semi-random attrition rate, for new accounts. In summation, HN doesn't accurately downvote, and HN doesn't accurately ban or hellban. Karma is meaningless, and users are frequently silenced without cause.
- statutory 8y agoRE: Downvoting. Just give up. There is no correlatiing reason for downvoting. Don't even think about keeping a user name for more than a day. It's not worth trying to please anyone around here anymore. Just cut a fresh user name, dump your honest opinion into it once, and then walk away from that user name. The amazing part is that HN tends to auto-hellban new users, if two are created by at the same IP address, inside of 24 hours. HN also auto-hallbans for other reasons. Because of this, there is also a semi-random attrition rate, for new accounts. In summation, HN doesn't accurately downvote, and HN doesn't accurately ban or hellban. Karma is meaningless, and users are frequently silenced without cause.
- ENZ0 8y agoRE: Downvoting. Just give up. There is no correlating reason for downvoting. Don't even think about keeping a user name for more than a day. It's not worth trying to please anyone around here anymore. Just cut a fresh user name, dump your honest opinion into it once, and then walk away from that user name. The amazing part is that HN tends to auto-hellban new users, if two are created by at the same IP address, inside of 24 hours. HN also auto-hellbans for seemingly other reasons. HN doesn't really seem to know why it hellbans. Because of this, there is also a semi-random attrition rate, for new accounts. In summation, HN doesn't accurately downvote, and HN doesn't accurately ban or hellban. Karma is meaningless, and users are frequently silenced without cause.