4 ms·
> fail to see how my basic health data like HR, weight etc is going to be used against me except for bad marketing practices. I actually looked into this in so
by Engineering-MD 8y ago
> fail to see how my basic health data like HR, weight etc is going to be used against me except for bad marketing practices.
I actually looked into this in some (limited) detail, although for a slightly expanded definition of all data a Fitbit (and the near future similar devices) could collect.
Heart rate data has been used in legal cases in the past. In an insurance fraud case, heart rate data from a pacemaker was used to provide evidence the events could not have occurred as described [1]. Similarly activity data has been used to defend against a false rape claim [2]. There is no reason such data could not be used in any other legal case.
The data collected by such devices can also reveal much more information about yourself than most think. By watching hand movements via accelerometer, smokers can be identified with 95% accuracy [3]. Users can be tracked via Bluetooth identifiers, or via the unique walking pattern of each individual [4]. Even when encrypted, users can be identified by the frequency of communication to the smartphone. Furthermore, pins can be identified by monitoring users hand motion via accelerometer [5]. For more advanced next generation fitness trackers tracking your ECG, this has been shown to be as unique as a fingerprint, allowing individuals to be uniquely identified across devices [6].
There is no reason that this data could not be used against you via insurance companies to change insurance costs (smoker, type of transport, heart health, activity) or even force you to wear one much like some car insurance requires black box monitoring. You could be taken in for insurance fraud by saying you are not a smoker, or it could potentially be used against you in court. This data can also be falsified, meaning fake data could potentially be used against you.
In summary, there are many other privacy problems with fitness trackers.
[1] https://apnews.com/c55eac83846f42e19fb924e57917001b https://apnews.com/c55eac83846f42e19fb924e57917001b
[2]
https://blogs.findlaw.com/blotter/2015/07/can-your-fitbit-data- https://blogs.findlaw.com/blotter/2015/07/can-your-fitbit-da...
be-used-against-you-in-court.html
[3]
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ilaria_Torre/publication/316925412_Fitness_Trackers_and_Wearable_Devices_How_to_Prevent_Inference_Risks/links/5a98a064aca27214056d5641/Fitness-Trackers-and-Wearable-Devices-How-to-Prevent-Inference-Risks.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ilaria_Torre/publicatio...
[4] https://www.dailydot.com/layer8/fitness-trackers-open-effect-citizen-lab-report/ https://www.dailydot.com/layer8/fitness-trackers-open-effect...
[5] https://www.stevens.edu/sites/stevens_edu/files/ChenWearablesPaper.pdf https://www.stevens.edu/sites/stevens_edu/files/ChenWearable...
[6] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0031320304002419 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S003132030...
- mscasts 8y agoFirst of all, thanks for the thorough post! [1] and [2] sounds kind of positive rather than negative though. Maybe smokers ought to pay more for their insurance? I'm not saying it's great that they can track people who smoke but the data could as well be used to strengthen your case, isn't that right? I get it if you are an US-citizen and don't want to use fitness tracker that sends data to their servers but I am a Swedish citizen. I don't have a health insurance so I don't have to worry about any insurance company finding out anything about my health. Maybe there are privacy concerns and maybe they should be addressed, but there is also most likely a lot of benefit to be gained from these systems. Just because the US has a crappy health system that exploits tech like health trackers doesn't mean that the health tracker stuff is inherently bad. Since I live in EU, I can also require them to delete the data thanks to GDPR. TL;DR: I get the worry you may have as an US citizen, but basically none of these concerns seem to apply to a EU citizen that have universal health care.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoAnd let's not forget what happens when a fitness tracking company has a data leak, someone plots it on a map, and suddenly military bases pop up like sore thumbs...