3 ms·
Imagine if these kids had to submit a 10-20 year plan before they could take a out a student loan? Imagine if you had to pick a major when you were 6 years old
by wahern 8y ago
Imagine if these kids had to submit a 10-20 year plan before they could take a out a student loan?
Imagine if you had to pick a major when you were 6 years old. That would be insane. (Insane is a poor choice of words because this is effectively the case in many countries for cultural reasons, but in the context of U.S. culture would be considered imprudent and impractical.)
In a society like the United States where employees are expendable and life-time employment will involve numerous different companies and positions, there's something to be said for a generalist education. If the U.S. had an industrial policy like Germany than a German-style educational model would make much more sense. But the U.S. has consistently rejected those policies, despite decades of economists of all stripes advising politicians to do so. (The same is true to a lesser extent in the rest of the Anglosphere, which not coincidentally also have higher education models more similar to the U.S. than continental Europe and much of the rest of the world.) Therefore, employers will value the more generalist approach. In the U.S. a 4-year biology degree matters not because of what it says about your knowledge in biology, but largely because it shows you persevered through 2+ years of writing, history, etc. In other words, you had the discipline to take up other subjects you didn't explicitly choose; not only pass their exams but to go to the classes (i.e. show-up!) and do the coursework (obey orders). And, ideally, it would show that you can integrate and apply those disciplines and methodologies to various tasks. (This is more aspirational.)