4 ms·
However, few of the predictions about the electric car market from this perspective have held up Clayton Christensen making predictions throws me through a loo
by wahern 8y ago
However, few of the predictions about the electric car market from this perspective have held up
Clayton Christensen making predictions throws me through a loop. I feel like he misunderstood his own thesis. My take away from Innovator's Dilemma was that (1) at every step of the game the most economically rational, profit maximizing strategy is to ride your successful business model all the way to the cliff and (2) you cannot predict what will become disruptive because success is context dependent, path dependent, and highly dynamic. If you could foresee all those interdependencies you could make a fortune in the stock market over night; but you can't. Something appears disruptive only in retrospect; beforehand it's just one among several competing alternatives, most or all of which will be forgotten.
His big solution at the end of the Innovator's Dilemma was GE-style conglomerates that spun off small ventures to test new ideas free from parent companies' economic calculus. But look at where GE and similar corporations mentioned in the book are now. That strategy does nothing to overcome the fundamental impediments to perpetual business success. Failure is inevitable, period. The only real "solution" is a financial market that can quickly reallocate capital to the manifest winners. The more efficient that capital and labor markets become, the less of an advantage large conglomerates will enjoy. But it all comes down to allocation of resources subsequent to the emergence of identifiable market trends.
I never bothered to read his other books because what was the point? He was right in the first-half of the Innovator's Dilemma; everything he wrote after that was a contradiction.