3 ms·
I like your approach but I disagree with your conclusion. Just recently Pepsi Co bought SodaStream for $3.2B. AFAIK, SodaStream is essentially a company that i
by mrtksn 8y ago
I like your approach but I disagree with your conclusion. Just recently Pepsi Co bought SodaStream for $3.2B. AFAIK, SodaStream is essentially a company that innovated with the UX outside the Internet-based technologies, not solving some hard problems.
Theranos claimed to have been doing something similar but failed due to their choice of UX improvement approach being based on technology that does not work.
An analogy in the internet-based business would be promising to improve the UX of customer support using AI and then not delivering on the AI part.
I think that your "Outsized impact" concept is interesting but I think that there is no such thing, it's just an illusion due to the speed differences of the delivery of the impact. Should Theranos was not based on pseudo-science, the eventual impact could have been no smaller than your average internet unicorn.
- a-dub 8y agotldr; internet/smartphone success comes from low hanging fruit made possible by revolutions in communication technology. it does not translate to hard domains like biomedical science. these problems are legitimately hard. and quite orthogonal to soda and chatbots.
- mrtksn 8y agoTheranos' was not about making something previously impossible, possible. Theranos doesn't have anything to do with biomedical science, they were supposed to improve the experience of blood testing both for the patient and for the medical professionals. Their problem was that they choose to try to do it by a method that was not technically possible at this time. Another company might try to improve the experience by improving the needles and redesign the machine to look like less offensive and scary and they might succeed in it. It's exactly like the difference between SodaStream's success and chatbots failure, that is, betting on UX improvement using a tech that's not there. Chatbots, SodaStream. Theranos - they don't do anything new that wasn't done before. Chatting with customer support was around since a while, Carbonating water to make soda was around since probably the industrial revolution and testing blood samples were around since modern medicine. All these companies tried to improve the experience and reduce costs, regardless of the nature of the business being internet or manufacturing based. It's not about the domain. EDIT: I'm not defending Theanos and I'm not going to comment about the motive of the people involved as I don't know them and I was not involved with Theanos at any time.
- vkou 8y agoThat's like saying that a scam company that claims to sell a widget that makes your car go at 500 mph, with a mileage of 1000 mpg is not 'claiming something previously thought impossible to be possible.' Cars exist, and fast cars exist, and people mod cars, so obviously, it should be possible to soup up my Honda Civic with their amazing invention. Theranos claimed that they had technology that could perform accurate blood tests on tiny samples of blood, drawn from a finger. For many tests, this is currently believed to be impossible (with sufficient accuracy.)
- mrtksn 8y agoMore like aiming to improve the safety of the cars. One company can try to do it by putting sensors to improve the driver's situation awareness and another company can try to make the cars driverless. Driverless cars also don't exist but apparently, enough people believe that it could be done and the research is going on. Maybe at Theanos they never intended to make the promised machine but I don't want to join the lynch as I don't know the people involved and I can't read peoples minds.
- tralarpa 8y ago> Theranos doesn't have anything to do with biomedical science Doesn't it? Wasn't that the main claim of the company? To have the technology that allows to do a lot of tests with very small amounts of blood? In your description it sounds like "Theranos had a great idea, unfortunately the technology was not read", like some kind of mild inconvenience that stopped something brilliant. Like "My company wants to build flying cars based on anti-matter reactors. The technology doesn't exist but, apart from that, isn't my idea brilliant?"
- mrtksn 8y agoI think their main claim was to improve the experience and reduce the costs for the users and the medical professionals. The rest of your comment is a straw-man argument as it misrepresents my words as I never even implied that they had a great idea or tech or anything like that. Sorry I cannot defend words that are not my own.
- akiselev 8y agoThat may be true in a literal sense but misses the far more important corollary: low hanging fruit in consumer technology often drives progress in harder domains. Military and academic investment in telecommunications and transistors may have given birth to Silicon Valley and IT as we know it today, but it was massive investment to feed consumer demand that really made harder scientific and engineering problems tractable. The drive for better graphics in gaming fundamentally changed the face of bioinformatics and genetics, finite element analysis and by extension, almost every subfield of mechanical and civil engineering, and many others. The logistics and transportation industries have gone through a quiet technological revolution every decade as economies of scale drove the cost of computers, GPS, and other embedded electronics to the floor. The demand for laptops, mobile phones, and tablets with ever more complex apps and games is responsible for at least a 5-10x change in productivity for my EE and firmware work over the last decade as the sheer scale of work on consumer electronics around the globe drives down the cost of parts and services right as the hardware world is beginning to learn about the benefits of open source.