6 ms·
As I see it, any system that can be compromised to pwn malefactors - even the most conceivably horrible terrorists and criminals - cannot be trusted. And notwit
by mirimir 8y ago
As I see it, any system that can be compromised to pwn malefactors - even the most conceivably horrible terrorists and criminals - cannot be trusted. And notwithstanding all the slander and conspiracy theory, Tor is perhaps the only working example of a compromise-resistant system. Unless it actually is backdoored, anyway.
Obviously, the Five Eyes don't see it that way. But I gotta wonder how commonly Tor is used among TLAs, and how the debate goes, if it is. Because this would destroy Tor. Unless operators were totally anonymous, and relays only stayed up until targeted.
- jedberg 8y agoI thought it was decided that tor was already compromised, because the five eyes intelligence apparatus already controls more than 50% of the exit nodes, giving them almost complete insight into where all the traffic originates?
- mirimir 8y agoGotta cite for that? And actually, your comment makes no sense. Controlling exits shows where traffic goes. Exits don't connect directly with users, but rather through middle relays, and either entry guards or bridges. So adversaries either need data from all three relays in circuits, or they must control both ends, and be able to signal through circuits. That's how CMU researchers pwned users and .onion sites, using the relay-early bug, which allowed intra-circuit signaling.
- TrueDuality 8y agoI believe they're referring to the traffic analysis style attacks. You don't have to know the content of the traffic if you control the entry node and exit node, either the guard relay, or the hidden service by monitoring the size and timing of individual packets. This doesn't deanonymize on its own unless you control the hidden service, but can be used with other data to link anonymous identities to the IP connecting to the entry node. That being said, what they're referring to is pretty old research and I haven't heard about any evidence proving any agency controls a large amount of the network. For a more current account of modern attack methods against Tor this paper[1] is a pretty recent compilation of researched attacks. The Tor developers actively try to defend against these but you should still be careful, it isn't researched enough yet (read: Tor isn't that old) to defend against resource rich attackers. [1]: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.02816.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1803.02816.pdf
- mirimir 8y agoI hadn't seen that. Thanks. It's a great review. But I've read much of the covered literature. And I'm not aware of anything published which shows traffic analysis being effective in practice. On the actual Tor network. If there is, I'd love to see it. Also, as I've said, it's dangerous to rely solely on Tor. It's trivial to identify all Tor users, from ISP data. And with a honeypot website or .onion site, an adversary can modulate to help with traffic analysis. But if users are hitting Tor through nested VPN chains, the universe of traffic to analyze becomes much larger. And so false positives interfere with correlation.
- DownGoat 8y agoThey rely on Tor themselves, they have a strong incentive to disclose/patch any major flaws in the protocol. They might exploit smaller flaws for a single operation, but they probably have more to earn from a healthy Tor network.
- mirimir 8y agoThat's the dogma. But do we really know that?
- DownGoat 8y agoWe as in the public can probably never be 100% sure of that, but looking at where the project started, and the current state of anonymous networks there is no real alternative. They are definitely using Tor to make attribution harder when running operations, there are no real alternatives. They benefit from Tor being open and used by everyone else, it is much easier for them to hide in the noise of all other traffic then.
- mirimir 8y agoYes, I do agree. However, some say that's just the cover story, and that Tor overall is a honeypot. Or at least, that Tor is a honeypot for all users except US government operatives. There's no way to be sure, right? As far as alternatives go, maybe they have something like Tor (onion routing) or I2P (mix networking) that user covert channels. It could even be running on government-controlled Tor relays. Or maybe installed as hidden malware. That seems unlikely, of course. But remember when allegations about ENIGMA were totally conspiracy theory.
- snowwrestler 8y agoIf Tor is just a honeypot, then when does it pay off? There are tons of illegal activities going over Tor right now, including truly awful stuff like terrorist attack plotting and recent pictures of child abuse. If Tor is surveillable, why isn't that surveillance being used to catch and prosecute those people? What are they waiting for? I will say (while acknowledging that I can't prove this) that I have friends who work in national defense and law enforcement, for whom Tor is an impediment. I've never heard them talk about a magic decrypt button; quite the opposite. So if Tor can be decrypted, it is a capability that is closely held and rarely used.
- jstanley 8y agoEven if that is true, what's your alternative? Don't use tor? It's dangerous to scare people away from tor on the basis that it might have vulnerabilities, because anything else is certainly worse.
- mirimir 8y agoYeah, that's another key point. What is the alternative?
- ionised 8y agoI2P maybe?
- mirimir 8y agoIt's still too small.
- apeace 8y agoTor has less than 7k relays[1]. Last time I checked[2], I2P had over 20k. I2P has far fewer users, but every user is a router by default. Tor users have to opt-in to be a relay. [1] https://metrics.torproject.org/networksize.html https://metrics.torproject.org/networksize.html [2] http://stats.i2p http://stats.i2p
- mirimir 8y agoMaybe I ought to take another look at I2P. One thing that I don't like about it is how every user is a router. And every router is typically discoverable by every other router. That makes users stand out a lot more than Tor users do. Basically as much as Tor relays do. And then there's the scarcity of clearnet exits. And indeed, discrimination against them as bandwidth stealers.
- mirimir 8y agoA couple other points. So the Five Eyes certainly have an incentive for dominating the Tor network. But if they actually use it, they also have an incentive for not dominating it too heavily. I mean, that was the whole point of releasing Tor as open-source. Also, don't the Russians and the Chinese also have an incentive for running Tor relays, in order to compromise their adversaries' users?
- pvg 8y agoany system that can be compromised to pwn malefactor That's kind of the system we have for everything else that isn't digital communication. I don't support backdooring but this line of argument, in itself, is not likely going to convince policymakers.
- mirimir 8y agoAt some point, we can forget about convincing policymakers, and just build stuff that works.
- pvg 8y agoWell, there is the little detail that we greatly rely on, benefit from and live in a society of laws.
- pizzazzaro 8y agoExactly. But good luck convincing policymakers to be beholden to such plebian concerns. Does nobody remember any time that such blanket surveillance was abused?
- mirimir 8y agoIn my considered opinion, "society of laws" is generally just a fantasy. Maybe it works well enough if you're privileged and/or keep your head down. But generally, laws are whatever the powerful say they are. Edit: Also, it's arguably moral to violate obviously unjust laws. I mean, that's how the US was founded.