3 ms·
Could it have worked with standalone systems, running in hospitals, doctors' offices, etc? That would be impossible with current (or vaguely conceivable) techno
by mirimir 8y ago
Could it have worked with standalone systems, running in hospitals, doctors' offices, etc? That would be impossible with current (or vaguely conceivable) technology, of course. Some years ago, I was seeing a doctor who did urinalysis in house. I figured that he was money grubbing, and maybe insurance companies eventually decided the same.
- CptFribble 8y agoIt depends. There are Point-Of-Care systems already, usually for things like urinalysis as you mentioned. If they did have a small, accurate, fast (~10 minutes or less per test, definitely not 4 hours) new system that could do multiple tests on a single drop, then yes, putting those directly in doctor's offices and hospitals would be the right idea, as long as you can make the financials make sense for the doctors. Really, there are already small systems for just about any test you might want to do, it's just that economies of scale for a big lab like LabCorp usually make it too comparatively expensive to run your own system, because you need to pay for the system and hire a licensed technologist to operate it. That's not just bureaucracy, either. Most current systems can have lots of weird problems that affect the results, and you need someone who understands both the medical relevance of the test (and normal/abnormal results), as well as some statistics, in order to know when the machine is operating correctly and when it's giving you subtly biased results and might need re-calibration or something. In big cities like NYC, it's more expensive to ship the blood out of the city to LabCorp/Quest's big regional facilities, and the "big" labs inside the city are way smaller (so they cost more). So doctors are more likely to be able to swing operating their own system. Also, some doctors charge way more than normal for their services, particularly IVF/fertility clinics. Those places always have their own machines (their clientele are also more demanding, and would expect results faster than you can get by sending out to LC/Quest).
- thaumasiotes 8y agoNo, it could not have worked as desired with any system, because it is fundamentally impossible to use a drop of blood to detect chemicals which are present in the circulatory system from which it was drawn, but are not present in the specific drop being tested. Blood is not a homogeneous substance. In order to be satisfied that you can detect substances that are present in the person, you need to extract more than a drop of blood.
- hcknwscommenter 8y agoBINGO. That really is the elephant in the room. Everyone skilled in the field knew it shouldn't work. Not because of limits of detection or micro-fluidics (engineering problems that could be improved/mitigated/worked-around, eliminated), but because of fundamental biological principles that cannot be changed.
- URSpider94 8y agoTo be more specific, most tests are designed around venous blood samples. Theranos' finger-prick would gather blood from capillaries in the finger, where the vessels are very narrow (changing the balance between blood cells and plasma) and also where diffusive processes into and out of cells are extremely active - and so assays like blood glucose level may be significantly off from what you would see in a venous draw, if for example your finger is curently burning a lot of energy ...