5 ms·
The homeless aren't prosecuted for sleeping outside. They're prosecuted for public indecency (i.e., exposing their privates to passersby and children), drug use
by gamblor956 8y ago
The homeless aren't prosecuted for sleeping outside. They're prosecuted for public indecency (i.e., exposing their privates to passersby and children), drug use, threats, physical violence, public intoxication.
The homeless advocates behind this lawsuit also assume that street life is somehow preferable to jail or prison, where occupants are provided 3 square meals a day, warm and clean clothing, a clean dedicated space to sleep, and all the free health services you need.
EDIT: Former public defender here. People have this bizarre, media-fueled image of jail and prison as horrible places to live. However, Oz is the minority of facilities--Orange is the New Black is far more representative of your typical incarceration facility. In many states, and especially on the West Coast, prison and jail facilities are nicer than the local schools. The only long-term homeless I've met that didn't want to go to jail--and in LA, I've encountered thousands of homeless individuals--were the drug addicts and drunks, because behind bars you're not allowed to drink or do drugs and they might give you medication that triggers withdrawal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GW150914 8y agoThe homeless advocates behind this lawsuit also assume that street life is somehow preferable to jail or prison, where occupants are provided 3 square meals a day, warm and clean clothing, a clean dedicated space to sleep, and all the free health services you need. In Norway or Sweden maybe, not in the US. 3 Square meals a day?! Forget the piss poor quality and lousy portions, they’re not serving three of anything https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/07/07/what-s-in-a-prison-meal https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/07/07/what-s-in-a-pr... Inmates at the Gordon County Jail in Calhoun, Ga. — according to a preliminary investigation by human rights attorneys last fall — are starving. The two meals a day weren't enough to sustain them, and some reportedly resorted to eating toothpaste and toilet paper. Inmates at the Montgomery County Jail in New York alleged that meager portions led to increased violence among the inmates; one inmate lost 90 pounds in less than six months. And a group of prisoners at the Schuylkill County Prison in Pennsylvania filed a federal civil rights lawsuit claiming the portions they received are “not even enough to fill a 5-year-old child.” https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2017/12/prison-food-sickness-america/549179/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2017/12/prison-fo... Then again maybe less food is better than... In August, the Detroit Free Press reported that a prison kitchen worker was fired for refusing to serve rotten potatoes. You can find nightmarish stories about maggots in national outlets like U.S.A. Today. They do get clothes, of course they tend to already have clothes, but “clean dedicated place to sleep” is just... what year do you think it is? The prison system is very overcrowded, and regional jails are the worst. Getting banged up for a few days on a misdemeanor isn’t putting you in a prison, but a shared cell in a local jail. Plus, a huge number of homeless people are memtallly ill, and being thrown into a chaotic situation with a bunch of offenders of varying severity is not the best outcome. You may not give a toss about homeless people, you may want them in prison, but stop pretending that it’s good for them. Plus it’s wasteful and expensive, a burden of non-violent people in an already overcrowded system, and does nothing to solve the underlying problems. The last thing we need is to further bloat our correctional system.
- gamblor956 8y agoWe're not talking about the Deep South, which doesn't have a homeless problem. We're talking about the West Coast, which has good weather year round and clean prison facilities. Unlike 99.999% of HN, I've actually visited every jail, prison, and mental hospital in CA. I've seen the conditions first hand. They're not what you see in movies--they're what you see in Orange is the New Black, i.e., clean and relatively comfortable. Also, mentally ill prisoners get transferred--almost immediately--to state mental hospitals. I agree that bloating the correctional system is a problem--but I would rather use prisons to house the homeless than to house otherwise employed and housed nonviolent offenders.
- maxxxxx 8y agoWouldn't providing shelters be cheaper than prison? Prison adds a lot of security overhead you don't need for homeless people.
- geggam 8y agoNIMBY attacks those ideas pretty quick. I have seen tiny home homeless projects get killed because no one wants that around them.
- rndgermandude 8y agoNo, we're talking about Boise, Idaho. Also, suggesting it's fine to just imprison people because they'd have it better in prison anyway... I'm speechless.
- gamblor956 8y agoI'm not arguing that it's fine to imprison people just because they'd be better off-you're the one saying that. I'm saying that it's not cruel or unusual to send someone to jail as a punishment for committing a crime if they were living on the streets. It is by definition not cruel because they're living situation would be better locked up than free. It is by definition not unusual because incarceration is the standard punishment for most crimes.
- robbyking 8y ago> The homeless aren't prosecuted for sleeping outside. They most certainly are [1]. The people suffering from homelessness that you see in places like the Tenderloin or the Mission in San Francisco only make up a small percentage of the total number of people on the streets; what you see there are the worst cases of addiction and chronic homelessness, not the total picture. In fact, the largest percentage of homeless people are households [2]. [1] https://sanfranciscopolice.org/civil-sidewalks-ordinance https://sanfranciscopolice.org/civil-sidewalks-ordinance [2] https://endhomelessness.org/homelessness-in-america/homelessness-statistics/state-of-homelessness-report/ https://endhomelessness.org/homelessness-in-america/homeless...
- gamblor956 8y agoSF does not actually enforce these ordinances. The individuals must be committing a separate crime (like drug use, or public indecency). This charge, in the rare instances when it is imposed, is a tag-along charge which is frequently used to bump a crime up to a felony so that they can send the individual to a mental health facility.
- chris_wot 8y agoAn law that is not enforced because it is unreasonable or unjust should be a law that is taken off the books.
- tedajax 8y agoThis reads like some Orwellian doublespeak. INCARCERATION IS GOOD OK!
- newnewpdro 8y agoThe City of Santa Cruz has banned sleeping in public, and actively enforced it when I was last regularly there a few years ago. Enforcement has gotten much more agressive over the last decade, as Santa Cruz became more affluent.
- tyingq 8y ago>Orange is the New Black is far more representative of your typical incarceration facility. Ugh, maybe for a Federal facility. City and county jails are dangerous shitholes in many (most?) places in the US.
- carapace 8y agoI'm sorry, I don't mean to be uncivil but I just straight up do not believe you (about people wanting to go to jail.) I was homeless for nearly five years, I've met a lot of homeless people, I've never ever encountered anyone who wanted to go to jail, "nice" or otherwise. Even the crazy folks would rather be crazy free. I guess it's possible that everybody who really wanted to be in jail found a way to get there leaving only the really committed "drug addicts and drunks" out on the street? In any event, you are right about one thing: > The homeless aren't prosecuted for sleeping outside. They're prosecuted for public indecency (i.e., exposing their privates to passersby and children), drug use, threats, physical violence, public intoxication. If you're not a mess most folks are actually pretty decent about cutting you some slack, I can tell you that from personal experience. Also, if you do encounter Mrs. Grundy, imagine that call to the police, "He's sleeping!" It lacks urgency. (Unless you're sleeping in a stupid place, like an upscale neighborhood.) It's like you say. There's a place a few blocks from my house where some people have been sleeping occasionally, and it would be fine but they are starting to leave trash and stuff. That's what's going to cause problems, not the actual camping.
- matt4077 8y agoIf you really used to be a public defender, the sorry state of our justice system makes a tiny bit more sense now. I mean... Just the claim that, quote: > The homeless aren't prosecuted for sleeping outside On an article titled: > Prosecuting homeless for sleeping outside may violate U.S. Constitution is quite a feat!