10 ms·
Prosecuting homeless for sleeping outside may violate U.S. Constitution: ruling
- geggam 8y agoPerhaps we will quit criminalizing the poor. My hopes aren't too high though.
- TremendousJudge 8y ago"In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread." - Anatole France
- jquery 8y ago“In its majestic equality, the law forbids men and women alike from rape.” - Anatole France, paraphrased. Should we do away with laws that have unfair application? Or is that quote coming from a place of disingenuousness merely to shut down alternative opinions on the matter of public health?
- yourbandsucks 8y agoI mean.. if you're gonna go there then we need to either provide homes for every homeless person or execute every last one of them. The only alternatives to rampant lawlessness.
- modells 8y agoThe rich corrupt government and steal from medicaid, literally killing people for another yacht... so don't give us that pseudo-mertiocratic tripe.
- badcede 8y agoI believe that was Anatole's point.
- barrow-rider 8y agothatsthejoke.jpg
- supernova87a 8y agoWhy do you make excuses for poverty being a reason to break society's rules? You suggest people who are poor get a more permissive set of rules? How about rich people? Your individual inclination of being charitable isn't a policy for regulating or governing a society successfully. I remember a Facebook acquaintance who decried someone charged with fare evasion on the subway, "because we're criminalizing being poor". What about the poor people who are paying their fare, obeying the law? Why are you forgiving the law breaker, and doing nothing for the law abider? Or actively showing them why following the rules is pointless? Consistently enforcing rules benefits the least advantaged people in society the most. And I agree with the commenter below that the reasoning on display in the court's opinion is really shady. You can be exempt from obeying law because of your circumstances or status? That's really workable? Who decides? What level of criminal act is justifiable for homeless people then? How about using the street as a public toilet? Are they exempt from that too because it's a biological imperative? This is full of holes.
- supernova87a 8y agoAnd by the way, congratulations to the commenters voting down my opinion above because it expresses conservative views. You really are living up to the liberal ideal of censorship when you disagree with an opinion.
- dang 8y agoWould you please stop breaking the site guidelines by going on about downvotes like this? It's off topic, and in the rules for good reason: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sidlls 8y agoThis is full of holes. Self-reference? If so, agreed. The biggest hole in your comment is that in America, at least, it's possible for a law to be declared invalid in some contexts (e.g. sleeping on the street) but not others (e.g. urinating on it). You dance around this somewhat in your comment, so it's curious you take such a binary view.
- rayiner 8y agoI hope so too. But there is policy, and there is democracy, and democracy is more important than policy. The people of Boise decided how to govern their community. That decision should not be overturned without a compelling constitutional basis.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>The people of Boise decided how to govern their community. Overturn Citizens United and you may see the people start deciding in other directions that actually benefit the homeless & poor.
- pcwalton 8y agoThe entire idea of a constitution is that policy is sometimes more important than democracy. The people of the city of Boise decided to discriminate against the most vulnerable members of society. That is a failure of democracy, and it's why we have things like the constitutional prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 8y agoThe Constitution says nothing about how to treat the “most vulnerable.” Voters get to decide how nicely or badly to treat people on the basis of their circumstances. The prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment sets certain narrow limits (can’t flay people alive), but those apply to everyone equally. When you strip away the judicial smoke screen, what the ninth circuit really decided is that the lack of available shelter spots should be a defense to liability under vagrancy laws. That’s a great policy. But it has nothing to do with whether the punishment is cruel or unusual. Constitutionally, the people of Boise don’t even have to have any homeless shelters. Whether they do or not is a matter of their on conscience. And whether they do or not, they can still enforce vagrancy laws (which date to the 16th century).
- deleted 8y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoI don't have much hopes that this ruling will survive an appeal to the US Supreme Court. The Ninth Circuit is one of the most overturned circuits by the Supreme Court.
- ajross 8y agoThe overwhelming majority of appellate decisions never reach the supreme court (because if they did, there'd be no point to having an appellate level at all if the high court needed to review everything). It's true that the 9th circuit is the most reversed. It's not true that any given decision is likely to be overturned.
- eric_b 8y agoThe Ninth Circuit has a fairly obvious agenda. They are activist judges - using the bench to push policy. Whether you agree with them or not, there is nothing impartial about the way they conduct their work.
- kevinh 8y agoCan you point out some examples of the ninth circuit bypassing proper procedure and jurisprudence to push their own policy?
- eric_b 8y agoStephen Reinhardt was a self proclaimed activist judge. Wikipedia has decent info on how he conducted himself: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Reinhardt#Judicial_philosophy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Reinhardt#Judicial_phi... The very makeup of the court is unusual, and results in issues. Even SCOTUS thinks it should be changed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Court_of_Appeals_for_the_Ninth_Circuit#Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Court_of_Appeals... The fact that they are reversed so often, have firebrand partisans on the bench (Reinhard recently died, but there are others carrying his ideology), and don't even come to a complete consensus between all the judges is enough for me to conclude it's not the most impartial court around. (I wager other apellate courts suffer from similar issues, but I'd prefer my judges to be as unbiased as possible, even if I mostly agree with their agenda)
- swebs 8y agoHow does this relate in any way to cruel and unusual punishment?
- ajross 8y agoWhy not just read the opinion? The case name is in the article, this is the very first link when you google it: http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2018/09/04/15-35845.pdf http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2018/09/04/15... I don't see it as so illogical. Judicial ideas of what constitutes "cruel" have for obvious reasons changed a lot over the centuries.
- swebs 8y agoNeat thanks. >We consider whether the eighth Ammendment's prohibition on cruel and unusual punishment bars a city from prosecuting people criminally for sleeping outside on public property when those people have no home or other shelter to go to. We conclude that it does. Still, it seems unrelated to cruel and unusual punishment. Putting people in jail is standard punishment for many crimes. It seems like the problem is in the prosecution itself before any sort of punishment is decided.
- mikeash 8y agoThey’re linked. Punishment which doesn’t fit the crime can be cruel and unusual even if it’s not for a crime where it does fit. For example, executing someone for petty theft would likely be held unconstitutional, even though it’s an allowable punishment for first degree murder.
- chris_wot 8y agoIt is rather unusual to put someone in jail because that person doesn’t have a home. And it’s cruel to make someone a criminal because they don’t have a home.
- jquery 8y agoI'm willing to bet these judges live in a nice gated community where the prospect of them and/or their children stepping in excrement or needles is zero. While in a utopia I'd agree, nobody should be arrested for just existing in the wrong place, "criminalizing" this behavior is the only way to force these people into a fully-functioning shelter where they cannot spread disease and filth to the rest of the population. For someone who's best option for sleep is a sidewalk, how is jail some sort of cruel and inhumane treatment?
- friedman23 8y ago> The U.S. Constitution’s prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment bars cities from prosecuting the homeless for sleeping outside on public property when they cannot obtain shelter, a federal appeals court ruled on Tuesday This will get overturned.
- gamblor956 8y agoThe homeless aren't prosecuted for sleeping outside. They're prosecuted for public indecency (i.e., exposing their privates to passersby and children), drug use, threats, physical violence, public intoxication. The homeless advocates behind this lawsuit also assume that street life is somehow preferable to jail or prison, where occupants are provided 3 square meals a day, warm and clean clothing, a clean dedicated space to sleep, and all the free health services you need. EDIT: Former public defender here. People have this bizarre, media-fueled image of jail and prison as horrible places to live. However, Oz is the minority of facilities--Orange is the New Black is far more representative of your typical incarceration facility. In many states, and especially on the West Coast, prison and jail facilities are nicer than the local schools. The only long-term homeless I've met that didn't want to go to jail--and in LA, I've encountered thousands of homeless individuals--were the drug addicts and drunks, because behind bars you're not allowed to drink or do drugs and they might give you medication that triggers withdrawal.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- GW150914 8y agoThe homeless advocates behind this lawsuit also assume that street life is somehow preferable to jail or prison, where occupants are provided 3 square meals a day, warm and clean clothing, a clean dedicated space to sleep, and all the free health services you need. In Norway or Sweden maybe, not in the US. 3 Square meals a day?! Forget the piss poor quality and lousy portions, they’re not serving three of anything https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/07/07/what-s-in-a-prison-meal https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/07/07/what-s-in-a-pr... Inmates at the Gordon County Jail in Calhoun, Ga. — according to a preliminary investigation by human rights attorneys last fall — are starving. The two meals a day weren't enough to sustain them, and some reportedly resorted to eating toothpaste and toilet paper. Inmates at the Montgomery County Jail in New York alleged that meager portions led to increased violence among the inmates; one inmate lost 90 pounds in less than six months. And a group of prisoners at the Schuylkill County Prison in Pennsylvania filed a federal civil rights lawsuit claiming the portions they received are “not even enough to fill a 5-year-old child.” https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2017/12/prison-food-sickness-america/549179/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2017/12/prison-fo... Then again maybe less food is better than... In August, the Detroit Free Press reported that a prison kitchen worker was fired for refusing to serve rotten potatoes. You can find nightmarish stories about maggots in national outlets like U.S.A. Today. They do get clothes, of course they tend to already have clothes, but “clean dedicated place to sleep” is just... what year do you think it is? The prison system is very overcrowded, and regional jails are the worst. Getting banged up for a few days on a misdemeanor isn’t putting you in a prison, but a shared cell in a local jail. Plus, a huge number of homeless people are memtallly ill, and being thrown into a chaotic situation with a bunch of offenders of varying severity is not the best outcome. You may not give a toss about homeless people, you may want them in prison, but stop pretending that it’s good for them. Plus it’s wasteful and expensive, a burden of non-violent people in an already overcrowded system, and does nothing to solve the underlying problems. The last thing we need is to further bloat our correctional system.
- malvosenior 8y agoThis is a tough one because as a homeowner I really don't like that an army of homeless people can setup encampment by my home on public property (in part maintained by my tax dollars) and then bring crime, aggressive panhandling, trash (lots of it) and lowered property values to my neighborhood. I'd really not like to see that expanded and we should be in search of better alternatives that don't punish productive members of society.
- skywhopper 8y agoThe reasonable solution from a practical point of view, then, is to use your political power as a homeowner to push your municipality to provide sufficient services to the homeless population to provide them with shelter and to help them find more permanent places to live. Criminalizing this stuff is very likely a lot more expensive than just providing enough beds and shelter and basic for everyone who needs one, anyway.
- DuskStar 8y ago> is to use your political power as a homeowner to push your municipality to provide sufficient services to the homeless population to provide them with shelter and to help them find more permanent places to live. And what if it turns out that homelessness, on a local scale, is like traffic - and providing more services (building more/bigger roads) just creates more homeless in the area (induces more people to drive)? Now you've spent what's likely to be a significant amount of money, and made no progress on his problem.
- jquery 8y agoCongratulations, you just described San Francisco. I strongly disagree with this ruling and I hope it's overturned. Sleeping on the street is never just sleeping on the street, it's almost always accompanied by drug use, needles left on the ground, and feces on the sidewalk, major health hazards and quality of life issues for city dwellers. We should provide more solutions to these homeless but jail needs to exist as a method of last resort. EDIT: careful, looks like a partisan brigade is trying manipulate the comment section regardless of comment quality. (violating HN rules)
- Nomentatus 8y agoDavid Johnston's stubborness continues to change the world (and the de facto law.) A homeless guy who changed the world far more than most of us ever will, for the better.https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/court-strikes-down-victoria-bylaw-against-homeless-camping-1.750534 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/court-strike...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tmaly 8y agoTalk to anyone in law school, interpretation of the constitution seems far more flexible than it should be. Look at how many amendments we have, yet many are not even considered. They play twister with a few to meet some end
- codeplea 8y agoI agree that it seems some amendments are ignored, but also there is no one "right" interpretation of any amendment. I found this article, The Myth of the Rule of Law [1], to be very enlightening. [1] http://faculty.msb.edu/hasnasj/GTWebSite/MythWeb.htm http://faculty.msb.edu/hasnasj/GTWebSite/MythWeb.htm
- ashildr 8y agoLand of the free. Christians.