36 ms·
> On the other hand, I hate the demonization of “other” and immigration enforcement has turned into being more openly racially motivated than it ever has been b
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> On the other hand, I hate the demonization of “other” and immigration enforcement has turned into being more openly racially motivated than it ever has been before and this isn’t a Democrat vs Republican thing. None of the other Republican administrations have been like this one.
"Racially motivated" is a misnomer. Trump uses "Muslim" and "Mexican" not in the way that Confederate politicians used "Negros" (or worse), but in the way that older Republicans used "Russian" or "Communist".
It's obviously not used in a sympathetic way but it's not about racism any more than Nixon was racist against Russians. Trump isn't threatening to expel the ethnic Mexican with US citizenship operating an auto repair shop in Alabama, but he's also not offering citizenship to low-income people from neighboring socialist-leaning countries who would probably vote for Democrats.
Democrats hate this with a burning fire because it's the exact opposite of what they want. But it's not actually about race, it's all politics and the culture war.
- scarface74 8y agoTrump isn't threatening to expel the ethnic Mexican with US citizenship operating an auto repair shop in Alabama, Actually he is threatening to expel US citizens who are Mexican who he doesn’t believe have valid birth certificates. Not because he believes they are forged, but because the babies were delivered by midwives at the border.... https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/us-is-denying-passports-to-americans-along-the-border-throwing-their-citizenship-into-question/2018/08/29/1d630e84-a0da-11e8-a3dd-2a1991f075d5_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/us-is-deny... ICE also detained an American citizen that was speaking Spanish. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2018/05/20/a-border-patrol-agent-detained-two-u-s-citizens-at-a-gas-station-after-hearing-them-speak-spanish/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2018/05/2... Not to mention that whole Obama’s is not a US citizen but he is a “secret Muslim” trying to spread Sharia law. but he's also not offering citizenship to low-income people from neighboring socialist-leaning countries who would probably vote for Democrats. If it were about socialism and not race, why is he so enamored by people from Norway?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Actually he is threatening to expel US citizens who are Mexican who he doesn’t believe have valid birth certificates. Not because he believes they are forged, but because the babies were delivered by midwives at the border.... According to your article the passports were denied for the same reasons during the Bush and Obama administrations. Because the midwives actually admitted to committing fraud. At that point the affected people will have to come in and sort things out. What's the alternative? Don't sort things out? It's a huge pain but you can blame the midwives for that. > ICE also detained an American citizen that was speaking Spanish. Law enforcement is constantly looking for a stupid pretext to check your papers. "Speaking Spanish" is a stupid pretext to check your papers. But you're claiming it's evidence of racism. If they had detained a white person for speaking Spanish, would that also be racist? If they had detained a Mexican person for "speeding" (but really for being Mexican), would that be less racist? The specific pretext isn't the issue. The issue is that they're using stupid pretexts to check papers. But that's a very broad problem with law enforcement in general. And notice what you're doing with it -- speaking Spanish is the cultural rather than racial characteristic. > Not to mention that whole Obama’s is not a US citizen but he is a “secret Muslim” trying to spread Sharia law. This is kind of my point. "Trump is a jackass" and "Trump is a racist" are not the same thing unless you're just defining racist to mean jackass, in which case everybody knows that already. > If it were about socialism and not race, why is he so enamored by people from Norway? Because they aren't immigrating here (in violation of the law) in numbers that could change the outcome of elections. Also because the people who immigrate legally are more likely to be affluent (and thus more conservative) than their home countries, the people who sneak across borders the opposite.
- scarface74 8y agoAccording to your article the passports were denied for the same reasons during the Bush and Obama administrations. Because the midwives actually admitted to committing fraud. At that point the affected people will have to come in and sort things out. What's the alternative? Don't sort things out? It’s that whole innocent until proven guilty. The government has to prove guilt on an individual basis. From the article. The same midwives who provided fraudulent birth certificates also delivered thousands of babies legally in the United States. Law enforcement is constantly looking for a stupid pretext to check your papers. "Speaking Spanish" is a stupid pretext to check your papers. You really believe that law enforcement looks for “stupid pretext” to stop blond haired blue eyed white people? This is kind of my point. "Trump is a jackass" and "Trump is a racist" are not the same thing unless you're just defining racist to mean jackass, in which case everybody knows that already. Was Reagan ever called a “secret Muslim” when he was sending weapons to Osama backed Mujihadeen and Iran during the Iran Contra scandal? Also, the people who immigrate legally are more likely to be more affluent (and thus more conservative) than their home countries. People who sneak across borders the opposite. Right because people from Norway wouldn’t support a large social safety net, government run health care, and free college education....