4 ms·
Do those countries make toddlers represent themselves in immigration hearings? https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/children-immigration-court-deportation-attorne
by monocasa 8y ago
Do those countries make toddlers represent themselves in immigration hearings?
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/children-immigration-court-deportation-attorney/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/children-immigration-court...
- jerf 8y agoI seriously, seriously, seriously doubt that if you examined all those countries with the same level of examination you've applied to the US (even if that is not all that much) that you'd find they're all just hunky dory. In fact I all but guarantee you'd find over half the policies aggressively racist, let alone all the other things you might think to fault immigration policies for. Note this is not an "everybody else does it so it's OK" argument, this is my not being particularly sympathetic to a lamppost argument. If the area under the lamppost is dirty, you don't have much logical basis to assume that everywhere else is clean, and then critique the area under the lamppost for its unique dirtiness.
- vkou 8y agoIf the area under my lamp-post is dirty, that's what I should care about. I don't care that there's some dirty lamp-post on the other side of the world. I don't live there. I don't have any power, or influence over that lamp-post. It's one thing when some government agency in Turkmenistan is behaving unethically. It's another thing to actively abet unethical behaviour next door.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoYou are right that, if it's my lamp-post, it's fine for me to say that it's not as clean as it should be, and we need to fix it. But that's different from what jerf said. He said it's not valid to assume that under my lamp-post is uniquely dirty. And he is also correct.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoI honestly do not care about those other countries. I'm not a citizen of those countries; I don't have the ability to influence what happens there. I am a citizen of the USA, and thus I am able to influence things here. I absolutely can and will criticize the US's lamppost for being dirty as fuck, regardless of the state of other lampposts.
- monocasa 8y agoI mean, can you point to one example of another country that we'd consider part of the free world that makes toddlers represent themselves in any sort of court proceeding? I can't exactly prove a negative here, and am willing to hear non theoretical arguments.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I mean, can you point to one example of another country that we'd consider part of the free world that makes toddlers represent themselves in any sort of court proceeding? Are you sure this isn't the general practice? The US isn't prohibiting them from having an attorney (or their parents etc.), it's just not paying for their attorney. It's the same as when a toddler sets fire to someone else's property. If there is a lawsuit the government doesn't pay for the defendant's lawyer, independent of how old they are. That's on the parents.
- monocasa 8y ago> Are you sure this isn't the general practice? I have yet to see examples to the contrary. > The US isn't prohibiting them from having an attorney (or their parents etc.), it's just not paying for their attorney. They just separated them from their parents, and expect a toddler in a detention center to somehow shit out an attorney. Meanwhile the government is represented by an attorney. > It's the same as when a toddler sets fire to someone else's property. If there is a lawsuit the government doesn't pay for the defendant's lawyer, independent of how old they are. That's on the parents. Can you even sue a toddler? Like, you can sue the parents sure, but can you think of another situation civil or criminal that has a toddler representing themselves?
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I have yet to see examples to the contrary. https://www.loc.gov/law/help/right-to-counsel/detained-migrants.php https://www.loc.gov/law/help/right-to-counsel/detained-migra... The United Kingdom appears to be the only country where legal counsel is provided by the government’s legal aid agency free of charge to all migrants in detention. Also remember that (like most of these countries) the US does have legal aid services available for this purpose in various cases. > They just separated them from their parents, and expect a toddler in a detention center to somehow shit out an attorney. How does anyone find an attorney? For young people their parent or guardian would typically do it. In the cases where they were separated from their parents (a stupid, short-lived policy that has been discontinued) the attorneys were often finding them. > Meanwhile the government is represented by an attorney. What would you propose they be represented by? > Can you even sue a toddler? Like, you can sue the parents sure, but can you think of another situation civil or criminal that has a toddler representing themselves? Why not? Typically there is no reason to because they typically have no assets and are not legally responsible for many of their actions. But suppose you have a toddler who is the legal owner of some inherited property where someone is injured. In practice they would have a parent or guardian deal with it (or hire an attorney), but that's also normally what happens with immigration. And the people who can't afford an attorney get shafted. But that's par for the course. Even in criminal cases the time and resources available to the public defender are totally inadequate.
- mc32 8y agoWould the people affected choose their home country’s immigration laws over the US’s (if that were a choice) in deciding their cases? I think the US would be favored by most.
- monocasa 8y agoI mean, how is a toddler even supposed to make that decision?
- mc32 8y agoThis is not new with thr current admin, even if advocates would like to make people believe this is new under Trump. However, these children are represented by attorneys at their side who know more than the patent(s). They are getting more rep than they would had their home country’s immigration laws applied.
- monocasa 8y ago> This is not new with thr current admin, even if advocates would like to make people believe this is new under Trump. I also protested Obama's immigration policies, but sure, paint the other side as hyper partisan. > However, these children are represented by attorneys at their side who know more than the patent(s). They are getting more rep than they would had their home country’s immigration laws applied. Literally straight from the above link: > In court, the Department of Homeland Security (“DHS”) is represented by a trained lawyer who argues for the child’s deportation. But no lawyer stands with the child. Every child is required to respond to the charges against him or her, and, in theory, afforded an opportunity to make legal arguments and present evidence on his or her own behalf. But in reality those rights are meaningless because children are not competent to exercise them. > Each child has attempted to find representation, including through pro bono legal service providers, but none of them have found anyone with the resources to take on their cases. Absent this Court’s intervention, these children were or will be forced to defend themselves pro se under the immigration laws—a legal regime that, as the courts have recognized, rivals the Internal Revenue Code in its complexity. So... no. They aren't unilaterally represented by attorneys.
- true_religion 8y agoSo I can see two outcomes: 1. The children are deported, thus go back to their home countries where they will be cared for. 2. The children are not deported, thus stay in the US where they will be cared for. There's no downside. They're toddlers. They were never going to be imprisoned or fined (hopefully, gosh if I got this one wrong I don't know what country we are living in). The thing is in the US, you the right to legal counsel is restricted to "criminal" cases. Thus in lots of court hearings, you won't have counsel, especially if you are someone who is involved but will face no 'negative' consequences in the courts' opinion. Child custody hearings have children "testify" on their own behalf, but they don't get personalized legal counsel; any support they do get isn't guaranteed to be someone with a law degree.
- monocasa 8y agoA lot of these children were separated from their parents while their parents were seeking asylum. So no, it's not a forgone conclusion that the child will be cared for in the other country. Hell, in some cases they're not even sure which country the child is from.
- true_religion 8y agoIf they cannot determine where a child is from, I am sure that the US government will take care of the child. If they can, and the asylum request is approved, then the child stays in the US. If they can, but the request is denied, then their home country is not an unsafe place, and surely the home country will want their citizen back. I feel like talking about asylum is an edge case in its self. Surely not the majority of immigrants are not legitimate asylm seekers. For most, they may not like their home countries (perhaps due to the low wages, or opportunity) but home is not a place of abuse where we must morally rescue them from.