3 ms·
The flaw is, imho, in the fact that we are talking about business models. If you look at thriving universities in Europe, in thriving countries (like Finland,
by znpy 8y ago
The flaw is, imho, in the fact that we are talking about business models.
If you look at thriving universities in Europe, in thriving countries (like Finland, Sweden and Norway) you might see that they are basically run at loss: this is because education is an investment, not an expense.
Education is supposed to be an investment for nations, not individuals (or, more realistically, parents of individuals).
- TheBeardKing 8y agoThe assumption being that it's the government's job to invest in individuals. I'm not here to argue either way, but at least half the country would disagree that it is.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beat 8y agoThe other half treats education as investing in society.
- vkou 8y ago> The assumption being that it's the government's job to invest in individuals. I'm not here to argue either way, but at least half the country would disagree that it is. Why is the government involved in teaching children how to read, write, do arithmetic, and sit in a chair for 8 hours a day, then? Absolute ideological opposition to government involvement in education - period - is a fringe opinion, that is at best, shared by ~5% of the country - not 50%. (Much of the 50% disagrees about the curriculum, but that's another story.)
- TheBeardKing 8y agoWe're obviously talking about higher education here. We all agree basic functioning citizens need 12 years of education. Educational attainment beyond that varies depending on occupation requirements and personal interest.
- vkou 8y agoGiven the problems that people without post-secondary degrees face, I don't think it's a stretch to say that productive, functioning citizens need 12 + ??? years of education. For every example you give of a successful college dropout, I can give an example of a successful person who only forced themselves to slog through 12 years of schooling for the sake of social signaling, and not running afoul of truancy laws.
- nhebb 8y agoIn the US, enrollment has been declining at smaller liberal arts colleges. These are private schools that rely primarily on high tuition costs and alumni donations to operate. Public universities have had steady enrollment, receive government funding, and are in no danger of shutting down.
- HeadsUpHigh 8y ago>In the US, enrollment has been declining at smaller liberal arts colleges. These are private schools that rely primarily on high tuition costs and alumni donations to operate. Does that surprise anyone? As an EU citizen I'm just dumbfounded that people have to pay so much money to get some minor that is totally worthless to the marketplace in order to get a more worthwhile major. Especially in liberal arts, like who in the world thinks getting a gender studies minor in order to enroll to some kind of teaching major is a sound idea, especially given the current wages of teachers? I understand the allure for lawyers though.
- wahern 8y agoIn the U.S. 4 year degrees revolve around a shared, core curriculum. This is the case at both small, liberal arts colleges and large universities. A biology major has to take multiple writing classes; a gender studies major has to take multiple math classes. Both will take core classes in history, economics, sociology or psychology, etc. Moreover, the way students are taught and graded can be different, especially compared to say, a German university. An American education emphasizes the process and discipline of learning. Seminars or seminar-style classes are common, even in the first two years. Basic facts and formulas can be learned on your own. If you don't care much for the process travel to Germany, sign up for the exams, and get a degree in a semester. It's a different, more traditional, approach. Whether its better or worse depends on your metrics and goals. Also, I've never heard of a minor being required. According to Google it's a thing, but also appears to be an exception rather than the norm. Anyhow, once you get past the distinctions between liberal arts, science, and engineering programs, employers couldn't care less about majors and minors, precisely because the primary indicator of a degree is that you've persevered through the core curriculum. You may hate writing/arithmetic but if you've made it through 3 college-level writing/math classes that says something about your discipline and follow-through, regardless of whether the material is relevant to a particular job position. Esoteric majors and minors is mostly a way for colleges to distinguish themselves; it's a sales strategy. I think the U.S. would do well to adopt European models of higher-education. But I don't think such schools would ever replace a traditional 4-year degree for the upper-middle class or wealthy, for both substantive and cultural reasons. I also don't think it will ever happen, period, because the European model of education goes hand-in-hand with government policy, corporate culture, and union structures. The U.S. is unlikely to mimic the latter three, so the more generalist educational model will dominate.