6 ms·
> Currently, humans risk becoming similar to domesticated animals. We have bred docile cows that produce enormous amounts of milk but are otherwise far inferior
by oblio 8y ago
> Currently, humans risk becoming similar to domesticated animals. We have bred docile cows that produce enormous amounts of milk but are otherwise far inferior to their wild ancestors. They are less agile, less curious, and less resourceful.
I have a problem with this premise. Anyone that knows history knows that humans were as tame, if not tamer, in the past. Plus uneducated.
Most of humanity has never been agile, curious and resourceful. Historically a handful of people were, and they tried to steer everyone around them.
I'd say we are less cow-like than we've ever been. A ton more people have access to education than they ever did. The only thing the new technologies (like the internet) are exposing is the depth of the veneer of education the vast majority of people had, and that depth was very shallow.
I'd say that in some regards this is actually better. Transparency tends to help and now a lot more people can see through the covers. It will just take time to adjust.
Nota bene: I still believe that most people, most of the time, are passive. Being active is a lot of work and truly active people will be always the outliers. It's just that we can increase the percentage of active people by making it easier for them to be active.
- Treegarden 8y agoAlso humanity in the past was far more violent and gruesome. So if being tame means not slaughtering each other it seems like a good thing. This book from Steven Pinker talks about this topic and its one of the best books I have read: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Better_Angels_of_Our_Nature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Better_Angels_of_Our_Natur...
- Balero 8y agoPersonally the idea of being tame revolts me. Maybe even more so than our violent and gruesome past. I also don't think they are linked. There is a definite difference to being civilised and being tame. MLK and Gandhi were civilised, and non-violent, but were certainly not tame.
- throwawayperson 8y agoBeing tame means won't have the desire to revolt against tyranny. You might can't imagine that, coz you probably didn't live under one. Currently in China, there are tons of people (personally I'd say most) prefer to live inside the "protection against malicious misinformation" of the great firewall. They have "everything they want" there, they listen to authoritative info and fend off doubts spontaneously.
- dang 8y agoPlease stop taking HN threads into nationalistic flamewar about China. That's not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- shadowxs76 8y agoOh please, piss off. Some of the best commentary I've personally seen about the very real dystopian nightmare slowly being built in China is right here at Hacker News, so if someone wants to take a discussion thread about technology helping tyranny into China territory, i'd call that an excellent fit. If the comments are informative and descriptive of ideas that are relevant to factual events (yes China really is authoritarian and using high technology to become ever more so in many ways) then it's hardly just nationalistic flamewar or insult.
- packet_nerd 8y ago> Also humanity in the past was far more violent and gruesome. Looks like an interesting book. I know that percentage wise, violence has been decreasing. But is it simply that modern governments are bigger, more powerful, and can better contain and direct violence? Or are modern people actually less violent as far as their culture and psychology? I wonder because even in modern times we've seen incredibly developed and cultured societies turn violent and gruesome very quickly.
- beat 8y agoIt's hard to completely generalize, because modernity is a pretty short timeframe and things are moving very quickly relative to the rest of history, but Pinker's premise (which is well defended) is that human progress is inexorably toward less violence, both in terms of warfare and criminal/interpersonal violence. That's in large part because violence is becoming a less effective means of social advancement. Having effective, more or less trustworthy police and courts goes a long way toward both making violent behavior risky, and reducing the need for vigilante justice/vengeance violence. And civil courts help resolve disputes without resorting to violence. Likewise, trade and economic stability have become so effective that it makes little sense for nations to engage in war with their neighbors anymore. War is bad for business!
- tormeh 8y agoI think it's just that people are safer and better fed now. There's no real need for most of us to use violence to preserve our way of life.
- Treegarden 8y agoStraight from the Wikipedia article: Pinker identifies five "historical forces" that have favored "our peaceable motives" and "have driven the multiple declines in violence." They are: The Leviathan – the rise of the modern nation-state and judiciary "with a monopoly on the legitimate use of force," which "can defuse the [individual] temptation of exploitative attack, inhibit the impulse for revenge, and circumvent ... self-serving biases." Commerce – the rise of "technological progress [allowing] the exchange of goods and services over longer distances and larger groups of trading partners," so that "other people become more valuable alive than dead" and "are less likely to become targets of demonization and dehumanization." Feminization – increasing respect for "the interests and values of women." Cosmopolitanism – the rise of forces such as literacy, mobility, and mass media, which "can prompt people to take the perspectives of people unlike themselves and to expand their circle of sympathy to embrace them." The Escalator of Reason – an "intensifying application of knowledge and rationality to human affairs," which "can force people to recognize the futility of cycles of violence, to ramp down the privileging of their own interests over others', and to reframe violence as a problem to be solved rather than a contest to be won."
- pvaldes 8y ago> Also humanity in the past was far more violent and gruesome They needed to kill humans one by one with blades and rocks and this was cumbersome and messy. At 3000 kills by minute we, definitely, are much more violent than they.
- evrydayhustling 8y ago> Most of humanity has never been agile, curious and resourceful. Historically a handful of people were, and they tried to steer everyone around them. I have a problem with this premise! My experience has been that when you look closely enough, most people are agile and curious within the sphere of their own action. What varies is the scale they believe they can act at, which can be a matter of internal motivation, social pressures and molding, or hard constraints. The history you are referring to is one where people with the spare time and education to write histories have consistently assumed that masses have low ambition due to missing internal drive. That perspective is blind to forces that make high ambitions impractical for many people. This article is about how technology can sometimes contribute to those forces. All that said, I agree with where you land here: the fix is for us to make tech that makes it easier for more people to be active.
- oblio 8y agoWell, my premise was summarized before: "most people are not active most of the time". If we look at examples of people who historically have had access to all the base resources they required, they weren't all active. Examples: Roman aristocracy, medieval feudal classes, modern day tycoon fortune inheritors. Only a small percentage were truly active most of the time. In my opinion it's not even healthy to be always active. It generally takes time away from down time with your friends and family.
- pjc50 8y agoI think you're going to have to define "active" here.
- oblio 8y agoResearching, working, helping your community, etc. Basically think of what the majority of people consider "fun" and/or "relaxing": watching sports, movies, TV series, listening to music, going to parties, hiking, reading a book, etc. I'd define "active" as not doing things most people consider "fun" and/or "relaxing".
- village-idiot 8y agoYou do realize that modern humans are weaker and have a smaller brain than their hunter gatherer ancestors, right? And not by a trivial amount, but by like 10% or so.
- frockington 8y agoMost of us no longer hunt and gather all day so it would make sense that we would not need to be as big.
- village-idiot 8y agoVery true, but there’s evidence that switching from hunting to farming actually changed us because of nutritional deficiencies, not just exercise changes. Example: hunter gatherers were not only stronger, they were taller and had wider jaws that fit all their teeth better. They also had fewer cavities than both farmers and modern humans. I personally think humans have lower tolerance for carbohydrates than most realize, and that we’re missing out on a lot of fat soluable compounds in our diets, such as K2. They also typically lived healthier, although not always longer. Obviously war, predation, and disease cut the life expectancy of hunter gatherers a lot. But if you exclude the unlucky, they actually remained active into remarkably old ages, seeing skeletons who showed signs of hunting into their 80s is not unheard of at all. Our aging might make it to their 80s much more regularly, killing off the sabertooths helped, but they’re hobled by mental and physical degeneration at distressingly high rates.
- AstralStorm 8y agoUnfortunately your assumptions are based on no data. Including living healthier lives. Malnutrition was very common until very recently even among hunter gatherers. Bad season? Sorry, half of your family starves and the other is sick. That said, early settled people had it even worse. They did get more exercise, but that is possible, easy in fact, to match, and results will likely be limited.
- 8y ago
- mannykannot 8y agoI am not sure what reading of history led you to conclude that people were tame in the past, but one thing to consider is that, as most history is written by the victors (or, at least, about them), the losers, victims, foot-soldiers and general populace can end up looking like nothing more than stage props in a costume drama.
- oblio 8y agoMost of history is actually about humans enduring routine unimaginable* suffering their whole lives and very brief outbursts (revolutions, wars, etc.). I think I have a pretty accurate reading of history... * Unimaginable to modern day people.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 8y ago>I have a problem with this premise. Anyone that knows history knows that humans were as tame, if not tamer, in the past. Plus uneducated. The past is full of revolutions, revolts, regional struggles, dethronings, and so on -- since time immemorial. Humans were anything than tame. >Most of humanity has never been agile, curious and resourceful. Historically a handful of people were, and they tried to steer everyone around them. That's the myth of the "sole inventor" and the "great leader". Most of progress have been a much more mass struggle...
- oblio 8y ago> Humans were anything than tame. If you'd put me in the living conditions lived their whole lives, I'd be waaay less tame then they were. Trust me, they were tame (in good part because they didn't know any better). And I'm not only talking about physical conditions, but about psychological degrading ones. They'd blow up only when they were literally starving (or their families were). Now we become violent for things which in the past were day-to-day life.
- naravara 8y ago>If you'd put me in the living conditions lived their whole lives, I'd be waaay less tame then they were. Oh please. This is exactly the same sort of claptrap Kanye West was on, and Ta-Nehisi Coates already pointed out how dumb and ahistorical it was: https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2018/05/im-not-black-im-kanye/559763/ https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2018/05/im...
- oblio 8y agoWell, maybe not me personally. But look at the recent violences in Chemnitz, Germany. The trigger is minor compared to stuff in the past. And you sent me a link to a 20k+ word article... TL;DR?
- coldtea 8y ago>Well, maybe not me personally. But look at the recent violences in Chemnitz, Germany. The trigger is minor compared to stuff in the past. What's at stake for participating is even more minor, so much more so that's there's no comparison.... Here's a (far from comprehensive) list of revolts in France, starting from the 13th century: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_civil_unrest_in_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_incidents_of_civil_unr... And even this is so lacking (it's not even 1/100 of the documented revolts) that it manages to miss the whole Paris Commune, a huge revolt that shook France and had tons of casualties...