4 ms·
There are three crossings near me that exhibit some different behaviours you'll see in the UK 1. There's a major crossroads (junction of a bypass). The natural
by tialaramex 8y ago
There are three crossings near me that exhibit some different behaviours you'll see in the UK
1. There's a major crossroads (junction of a bypass). The natural phase design means that vehicles will be stopped before each crossing in the phase anyway. So the buttons _almost_ do nothing. Why "almost" ? Well, in the middle of the night with almost no traffic, the phases stop being automatic, bypass traffic gets a green all the time. If something comes on the side road, the phases will happen, but you don't want to wait for that as a pedestrian, your buttons will cause all the phases (even the ones you don't care about for crossing motor traffic) to happen so that you can cross. In practice of course at this hour few pedestrians push the buttons anyway, they can see there's no traffic.
2. The high street nearby has an old-fashioned Pelican crossing, and the buttons work as expected. A Pelican is a familiar design, traffic lights control the motor traffic and red/green lamps are attached for pedestrians, facing them from the far side of the road, the pedestrian presses the button, a timer starts, and after some configured delay the traffic signals bring motor traffic to a halt, then you can cross.
3. But it also has a newer Puffin crossing. The Puffin crossing is superficially similar to a Pelican, and road vehicle operators need no extra training, but for a pedestrian the operation is improved in one immediately visible and one invisible way: Visibly the red/ green lamps are moved to the pedestrian's side of the road, positioned so that when looking at them the pedestrian can also see the road with oncoming traffic (in the UK this will usually be to their right, but in some cases it's the left and the Puffin is adjusted appropriately). This reduces the hazard of pedestrians stepping in front of traffic when they have a green light but a motorist hasn't slowed. Also, the timer now starts when the crossing is used, and inhibits further crossing activations. For a busy crossing this makes no difference, but at a quiet crossing it means if you arrive after a long lull it will activate immediately, since the traffic has not recently been interrupted. A big improvement.
Elsewhere in my city I've also noticed examples of the Pegasus and Toucan, which are similar to the Puffin except that they're intended to also accommodate horses (Pegasus) and bicycles (Toucan) where routes allow these in addition to pedestrians.
- sigwinch28 8y agoThe most notable difference between Pelican and Puffin crossings is the phases. Pelican crossings go through a flashing amber phase on their way from red to green, imitating the behaviour of Belisha beacons from Zebra crossings. Puffin crossings remove this behaviour, instead opting for the typical red -> red+amber -> green phase, using pedestrian sensors instead of solely a timer. This also means that the system can cancel the crossing sequence if the pedestrian pushes the wait button, but then leaves.
- dingaling 8y agoThe nearside Puffin crossing display can be obscured by crowds. The reason they are mounted low is cost: the same unit can be used for command and display. They therefore require looking down, whereas farside displays keep the head lifted which makes it easier to transition to looking at the road. In all directions. Which is why nearside displays aren't used at junctions. Puffin crossings are an excellent example of a system being redesigned to reduce cost and then having bogus UX 'justifications' pasted over it.
- tialaramex 8y agoHow are two mechanically separate components "the same unit" exactly ? The Puffin displays are replicable, which is how Pegasus crossings work (a person on a horse obviously can't reach down to the level of a pedestrian button, the crossing is functionally similar to a Puffin but adds a picture of a horse & rider, and is replicated higher up the pole)