4 ms·
Janer says the young boy would have projected his social needs on to the animals and imagined relationships with them. “When Pantoja says the fox laughed at him
by anigbrowl 8y ago
Janer says the young boy would have projected his social needs on to the animals and imagined relationships with them. “When Pantoja says the fox laughed at him, or that he had to tell off the snake, he gives us a version of the true reality, what he believes happened – or how, at least, he explained the reality to himself,” Janer told me. “Marcos’s mind was desperate for social acceptance,” he told me, “so instead of understanding the animals’ presence as incentivised by the food, he thought they were trying to make friends.”
I continue to be perplexed as to why otherwise intelligent people deny the possibility of personality and social relations among other species, or that of interspecies communication. Then again this is just the mildest example in this story of people's capacity for being awful.
- carapace 8y agoThat exact passage struck me too. The word "com-pan-ion" literally means sharing food together.
- taurath 8y agoThere’s generally a large pushback against over-anthropomorphization in the scientific community I think frequently to push back a bit on the public only focusing on the most charismatic animals, and in the general public especially when people are confronted with the meat industry. The problem is that field researchers who study almost species (especially mammals) tend to differentiate personalities and a lot of human like traits.
- anigbrowl 8y agoUnderstandable, but caution doesn't validate his own alternative claims. I was already in s skeptical mod from the mention by another person in the article of the 'alpha wolf', a ethological concept which has been discredited for a while now but which refuses to die. https://io9.gizmodo.com/why-everything-you-know-about-wolf-packs-is-wrong-502754629 https://io9.gizmodo.com/why-everything-you-know-about-wolf-p... has a good summary of the rise and fall of this animal behavior theory. Certainly over-anthropomorphization can lead people to make foolish assumptions, but the notion that animal behavior is fundamentally different from our own rather than existing on some spectrum of cognitive complexity is not really scientific either.
- dxhdr 8y agoScience has long established friendship as a distinctly human-human interaction consisting only of the purest non-incentivized intentions.
- stared 8y ago[citation needed] (unless it is written purely ironically)
- Stratoscope 8y agoSome scientists, perhaps. But it sure sounds to me like a "no true friend" argument. [1] Of course one could define "friendship" in a way that only human friendship qualifies, but that is certainly not the common definition. We have three dogs and three cats, and every day I see behavior and interactions among them that I can only describe as friendship. Yes, between the cats and the dogs too. I think anyone watching them would call them friends, at least by any everyday meaning of the word. [2] Scientists don't get to redefine a word that means something else in common discourse. That's not how language works. Next thing you know, they will say Pluto is not a planet! Oops, they did, some scientists anyway. But not the science team that sent New Horizons there and brought back better pictures and more information than we ever had before. They call it a planet. [3] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friendship#In_animals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friendship#In_animals [3] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/pluto-rsquo-s-secrets-revealed/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/pluto-rsquo-s-sec... (Full article is behind a paywall, but the subtitle has the relevant quote.)
- crooked-v 8y agoAnd yet scientific studies have shown that some animals will reliably prefer to help other animals even if it loses them a reward. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/05/rats-forsake-chocolate-save-drowning-companion http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/05/rats-forsake-chocolat...
- nkoren 8y agoYeah, I think that Rodríguez absolutely has the right of it here. Animal communication is "simple" in human terms, but is quite rich on its own terms. To anybody who spends quality time with animals in their own comfort zones, it is utterly damned obvious that many animals experience and are entirely competent at communicating love, friendship, curiosity, jealousy, covetousness, and many other thoughts/feelings -- and, also, that they are just as able to blur species boundaries as we are. There are varying levels of complexity to this: snakes are too simple-minded to have a sense of humour, for example, but foxes definitely do. Fox humour isn't the same as human humour, but when you anthropomorphize them, and they foxopomorphize you, there's enough overlap for an intersubjectively meaningful exchange to take place. I think that science's unwillingness to acknowledge this has multiple roots. The first is a religious relict of wanting to put Man at the centre of the universe. Descartes, deeply religious, believed that humans were the only beings endowed with a soul, and that therefore animals were necessarily mere automata. This became the default "scientific" dogma, to be considered true unless proven otherwise. But it really is just dogma, with no basis in either rationality or observation. The second is the scientific requirement for experimental controls and reproducibility, which is easiest to do in a laboratory. If animals really were automata, running on instinct, then that would be fine. But they're (mostly) social creatures, formed through interaction as much as we are. If your understanding of human psychology was formed wholly through the observation of humans who spent their lives trapped in Skinner boxes, you'd form some rigorously incorrect notions of what humans are capable of. Ultimately, there's no way to to get a proper understanding of humans in a non-subjective capacity. Same goes for animals.
- pharrington 8y ago"If your understanding of human psychology was formed wholly through the observation of humans who spent their lives trapped in Skinner boxes, you'd form some rigorously incorrect notions of what humans are capable of." My comment's a tangent, but I suspect that's a significant reason why social media is so ridiculously hard for people to healthily use.
- nkoren 8y agoInteresting. Yeah, there's something to unpack in that.
- PerfectElement 8y agoI think this is one of the consequences of Carnism[1]. For most people, it's a lot harder to eat or exploit someone with a personality and rich emotional life, than something that has no feelings or desires. This creates all sorts of cognitive distortions and biases. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnism