2 ms·
As I described below, all of this is part of Authorization, in principle an old-fashioned carbon impression sheet of your card could be used to justify a $5000
by tialaramex 8y ago
As I described below, all of this is part of Authorization, in principle an old-fashioned carbon impression sheet of your card could be used to justify a $5000 payment and it's up to you to contest that if it's bogus. Authorization protects the bank, not the customers.
But for the Authorization a PIN absolutely can be required for online card transactions using a mag stripe. And this was routinely done in countries which had PINs for debit cards years before EMV. The terminal calls the bank and says I have this card, and here's the PIN entered by the customer, is that OK?
Unlike the mag stripe you can't clone a card using the "wireless" EMV mode, the chip isn't just playing back a fixed data stream, it's an active component.
[ It might be instructive to expand here, so I shall ]
A part of an EMV transaction the terminal and card are supposed to pick random ("unpredictable") numbers each time. If this is done correctly it presents a significant security feature. For example, suppose tomorrow I plan to tell a jewellery store's payment terminal that your card, which I was able to access briefly today when you were in the same elevator as me, authorises purchase of a $500 watch, then I'll pawn the watch and keep the cash. Well, I need the cryptographically signed message from your card saying this is authorized. But, that message needs the unpredictable number that the jewellery store terminal will choose tomorrow, which I don't know yet, so I can't do it.
Now, in practice researchers found some terminals and cards are crap and e.g. the numbers they use aren't truly unpredictable. But that's an implementation flaw that can be fixed, just the same as if your bank has a habit of leaving the back door open and the vault unlocked. It's something your defence attorney should know if the bank accuses you of fraud for someone else's transaction, but it's not an inherent problem in "wireless" EMV.
- tjoff 8y agoThe whole point is that the attacker can opt to withdraw funds using a site/service/xxx that doesn't perform such authorization. I've only seen such authorizations be used on domestic sites, an attacker would probably even prefer to withdraw funds from a country other than that of the victim. Making the whole endeavor pointless.
- tialaramex 8y agoAbsent the authorization you can just unwind the transaction, since there's no evidence whatsoever that you authorized it. It will depend on how strong consumer protection is as to whether this actually leaves you financially whole afterwards or whether the bank is able to get away with just giving back the money for the single transaction. To the extent that Authorization isn't mandatory before the Payment step, sure, everything about payment cards is "pointless". Banks have decided they don't care about fraud and will just pass that cost on to you. shrug
- tjoff 8y agoYou can do that if the bank decides that you have not been negligent. Whether you have been negligent seems to be correlated with how much money was taken from you ;) Anyway, it is pretty immoral to rely on reimbursements - actively funding and making thievery profitable.