4 ms·
Is this an American phenomenon[1]? If I forget to click the pedestrian button, cars in the same direction as me will get green light, while I wait for red. Mo
by wodenokoto 8y ago
Is this an American phenomenon[1]?
If I forget to click the pedestrian button, cars in the same direction as me will get green light, while I wait for red.
Most elevators don't have a close button in Denmark. But it definitely worked in Japan.
I can't remember ever sitting in an office with a temperature control knob available.
[1] ... or am I just fooling myself on these accounts?
- Macha 8y agoYeah, the pedestrian section is clearly an optional part of the cycle at most traffic lights I interact with (Dublin). If no button is pressed, then some other part of the cycle is extended and the pedestrian light is skipped. This isn't the same as pressing the button indicating that traffic will be stopped in 20s or similar, but I don't know of anywhere traffic lights ever worked like that. You're still going to have to wait for the allocated "pedestrian" time, but it will never come without a button press
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dmurray 8y agoAgreed. All traffic light buttons do something in Dublin, as far as I can tell. Most lights are at junctions. If you don't press the button there, there will be no point in the cycle where you're guaranteed no cars will cross your path. If you do, there will. Some traffic lights are just for pedestrians crossing, away from a junction. Normally those work pretty quickly - traffic stops in 10 seconds, so long as the last stop was at least 30 seconds ago. In some countries, pedestrians can get a green light while cars are still allowed turn across them. I'm not sure if that's the case in New York, but it might explain some of the confusion.
- toast0 8y agoAt some low traffic crossings, the lights are programmed to tend to be green in the more trafficed direction, but will start to change immediately if there is an indication of demand in the other direction -- through a pedestrian button on a detector loop in the road surface. When there's higher traffic, they do more of the traditional cadence, but pressing the pedestrian button ensures the cycle will be long enough to cross the street.
- craftyguy 8y agoMaybe it's specific to a certain area/region of the US, but here in at least a few places in the pacific NW all three of those things work (ped lights enabled by pushing ped button, elevator doors do close, and the office temp control works).
- branweb 8y agoNot true. The article specifically mentions Seattle having non-functional pedestrian buttons, and I've encountered many myself around the city. In fact, I think the Seattle Times ran a story on it a while back. edit: found it - https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/do-pedestrian-push-to-walk-buttons-do-anything-heres-the-answer/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/do-...
- craftyguy 8y agoSeattle is in the PNW, but Seattle is not the PNW.
- branweb 8y agoTrue, but your original assertion (without the "in at least a few places" edit) was misleading.
- toast0 8y agoSeattle buttons do something. If you press and hold, they announce the intersection name, and when the walk sign is on, they tell you which street you're crossing. I haven't been in the city outside of peak times, but they may affect cycle timing when there is little traffic, and it makes sense to run a more adaptive schedule (but then again, there might not be such a time)
- bunderbunder 8y agoIt seems to vary by city in the US. I've been places where it seems to do nothing. I've been places where it starts a signal change. I've been places where it enables accessibility features, as described in the article. And I've been places where it does absolutely nothing to alter the light's timing, but it does control whether the pedestrian light will turn white or not. The last of these is my least favorite, because it seems to engender the most confusion.
- Nursie 8y agoElevators in the UK that I have used recently have working close buttons too. I think this all likely varies a lot.
- duxup 8y agoThe pedestrian button thing varies wildly in the US. I have several pedestrian crossings where the if you as a pedestrian don't hit the button... you'll never get a signal to cross and the traffic is not impacted. But if you do push it, it does give you time to cross and holds the cars longer. One place traffic never stops, until you hit the pedestrian crossing button, and then they have to stop. On the other hand in some pedestrian dense / slow traffic areas I know the buttons don't do anything as the pedestrian crossing lights just change with the lights, but only during high pedestrian traffic times. I think it has more to do with policy and how you want to time your lighting systems and it varies wildly in the US
- sidstling 8y agoI work for a Danish muniplacity and I can assure you that every side way button has a functional purpose. It’s just that it’s not always the same one, and it varies throughout the day. Some of the buttons are there solely for the visually impaired. Some of these will always play a beeping sound and then play it louder when you press them, others will only play the beeping sound if you press them. These buttons are generally placed in cities or at busy cross roads wherethere is never no-traffic sounds. Others tell the signals you want to cross. In some cases, the pedestrian lights will never turn green unless you press the button, this is typically in the suburbs or in the country on streeets that are busy in one direction. Others will shorten the traffic cycle of the lights. Here’s the thing though, most traffic lights are guided by data science to make traffic flow optimal. So often the pedestrian button is turned off during rush hours, where the signal is operating to maximize flow. Then during off hours, one direction may get prioritized because it has more traffic, and then the pedestrian button in the other direction gets turned on to shorten the cycle. Sometimes that setup alters multiple times during a day. Many of the buttons combine functionality. Aside from that they sometime get turned off for maintenance, maybe the button broke, maybe the traffic light got updated and the button needs to get changed. Maybe we’re testing a new traffic flow. Since 90% of them aren’t high priority, they can be turned off for quite a while, waiting to get fixed/updated. Hell, even the ones that are required for green lights aren’t necessarily fixed the same day, because the other 3 directions still work (we do fix these within a week though). Finally there are the decommissioned buttons. As you might imagine they can be there for quite some time. It’s ridiculously expensive to remove buttons from just one cross section, so we pool them together. Of course this means that they can sit there for years waiting to be removed. So it’s confusing. I know how they work, and I’ll still press the ones that are only there to give off sound. None of them are installed for the reasons stated in the article though. In sidewalks where people have trouble waiting, we install visible timers that tell you exactly when it’ll be green instead.
- Delfino 8y agoI am living in Thailand and the elevator close buttons definitely work here. If you don't press it the door can stay open for a very long time.
- coatmatter 8y agoI've seen this story pop up several times before in different guises based on dubious evidence of only one or two cities. Most buttons in Australia work - or rather, the lights won't work for pedestrians who think it's always automatic. And on my visit to a couple of places in America last year for the eclipse, I easily found some buttons that also worked - but most crossings had no buttons at all. The elevators I use definitely have buttons that are responsive - I can and have counted the difference in seconds thanks to articles like the above that seem to echo a certain untested dogma. I don't think most city councils care enough to install real infrastructure let alone placebo infrastructure.