10 ms·
I just don't understand why my card even has a magnetic stripe anymore. It's been years since I've seen any terminals that could actually accept it, it's all ch
by gambiting 8y ago
I just don't understand why my card even has a magnetic stripe anymore. It's been years since I've seen any terminals that could actually accept it, it's all chip and pin over here. If I could get a card without the strip I'd gladly do so.
- acdha 8y agoThe United States is still predominantly magstripe. We’ve had chip-and-no-pin for a few years but many large retailers haven’t enabled it, possibly because transactions are so much slower (usually 30-60 seconds) and less reliable.
- tomxor 8y ago> possibly because transactions are so much slower (usually 30-60 seconds) I don't know the details of the technological differences in transaction communication between the two, but in the UK chip and pin is noticeably and consistently faster to perform transactions in my experience, often to the the point that it's perceptibly instant... although it has been quite some years since i've used magnetic ones so that's from memory. I suppose one way to protect yourself if you are never going to use your card in the US, is by destroying the magnetic strip (magnetically).
- acdha 8y agoThe slow reads are entirely a technical failure by some of the large vendors. Some systems are as fast as you describe and most of the ones which I see being that slow are much faster for NFC, so I’m pretty sure it’s just that they were rushed into profuction to meet the deadline imposed by the card vendors.
- tomxor 8y agoMaybe it's just a difference in how relatively new the technology is to US retailers then, UK shops have had plenty of time to work out the kinks and learn what hardware to avoid.
- Someone1234 8y agoThe first generation of Chip&Pin in the UK were garbage too. Slow and often failed to read the chip, resulting in awkwardly cleaning the chip contacts. Most of the machines were replaced inside of the first year and things have improved substantially since then.
- tomxor 8y agoAhh yes I do remember a few instances of that now... I wonder what the introduction of the magnetic strip was like, looks like that technology arrived in 1969, anyone here experience that transition?
- acdha 8y agoLikely, yes, although it’s somewhat surprising that a decade or so of European experience couldn’t help American companies avoid problems.
- gamersp 8y agohttps://codepen.io/GamerSp https://codepen.io/GamerSp
- gsnedders 8y agoAFAIK, there's two big problems in the US: * many places moved from offline magstripe authorisation to online chip-and-pin authorisation (while still often using card terminals that use dialup connections, and connect per transaction) * many US banks have really slow authorisation servers (for whatever reasons!); I remember some sales staff being really surprised at my card going through in about a second (and that verification probably involved a network roundtrip to the UK!)
- bradknowles 8y agoThere's another problem -- many terminals in the US are just plain cheap-ass slow-as-hell rubbish.
- PeterisP 8y ago"UK chip and pin is noticeably and consistently faster to perform transactions" is not because chip&pin process is faster, but because the risk of counterfeit cards is lower and the system can be configured to not verify small transactions against the bank, saving a network roundtrip - the terminal just "talks" to the chip, and does the full verification with the bank later in offline mode, without requiring the customer to wait for the outcome. Doing the same with magstripe would be much more risky.
- tomxor 8y agoHmm, are you talking about the £30 limit? because other than having to manually enter a pin it doesn't seem significantly longer... no i haven't timed it, and I'm not saying that you're wrong, just that it still seems to be bellow a perceptibly significant amount of time. Or perhaps I just don't do enough shopping to have a broad enough range of samples.
- angus-prune 8y agoI get a Monzo notification on my phone whenever I make a payment. I often feel my phone buzz before the machine has even finished and allowed me to take my card back. I don't think the percieved speed is simply due to offline mode.
- smackfu 8y agoI think gas stations are the only place I still see swipe, or small merchants who have old terminals. I don’t see it as predominantly magstripe.
- acdha 8y agoEverywhere I go supports magstripe. An increasing percentage support chips but I still see terminals which don’t, or more commonly, where they have a sign telling you not to use it because it’s not enabled or broken. I’m assume there have been a lot of slacker IT departments caught out by these upgrades since it’s usually big chains which have problems.
- rootusrootus 8y agoTry swiping sometime. In my experience if you have a chip card and try to swipe it, the reader will reject the swipe and tell you to insert the card instead.
- bradknowles 8y agoAnd then the chip card reader part of the terminal isn't connected to the bank network yet, and you're really screwed. Just swipe it three or five or more times, and it might work anyway. Welcome to the 21st Century.
- gsich 8y agoYou can enter your card number manually.
- myself248 8y agoThis varies hugely by retailer, though. I'm convinced there's a level of optimization that some just aren't incentivized to do. When I'm at O'Reilly Auto Parts, the pinpad is beeping at me to remove my card almost the moment I've inserted it. It's shockingly fast. (Then their neolithic-age printer takes 8 more seconds to generate a receipt, but... baby steps!) I wish whoever set up their system could go show some others how it's done. Because yes, on average, most retailers have abominably slow processing for chip cards.
- markkanof 8y agoYes, in Portland Oregon we have a grocery store called New Seasons that implemented a chip reader system where as soon as you walk up to the checkout you can insert your card, it tells you to remove it immediately and then the clerk continues to ring up your groceries. This might just be the way it works in other parts of the world, but in the US this particular implementation was surprisingly smooth compared to the multi step dance that other retailers require. Don’t insert card until all purchases have been rung up, ok now insert card, do not remove card, move to new screen, but still do not remove card, ok, now remove card, now sign, etc.
- vertex-four 8y agoIn the rest of the world, the customer isn’t standing around waiting for someone else to bag their groceries, so there isn’t a parallelisation possible - you stick your card in once you’ve finished bagging everything.
- sizzle 8y agoI loved new seasons when I visited Portland! Are they only in Oregon? It was like a more neighborhood friendly version of whole foods.
- rootusrootus 8y agoI live in the U.S. and I have exactly one store that I go to which doesn't support the chip. Small store running on a shoestring, so I'm not terribly shocked. Everywhere else I go it's chip only, if you swipe the machine will bark at you and tell you to insert the card into the chip reader instead.
- jwr 8y agoWhen arriving from Europe to the US it feels like going back in time. To take an example, in Poland most card transactions are contactless and I don't think there are any terminals left that do not accept contactless payments. When Apple Pay was enabled, it was instantly available everywhere (and I do mean everywhere) and nobody even calls it "apple pay", it's just known as paying with your phone, which was possible with android phones for a long time already. Also, I don't think there are any places left where you swipe the magnetic stripe. If for some reason you don't use contactless, it's a chip transaction. I believe it's pretty much the same all across Europe?
- emmanuel_1234 8y agoCredit card with chips were introduced in France in 1992.
- ams6110 8y agoIn my experience (I'm in the US) the chip cards were noticably slower when they were first introduced, but in the last year or so that seems to have been mostly resolved. Gas pumps are the one big holdout that still does mag-stripe reads. I don't think I've seen a chip read gas pump anywhere yet.
- gabipurcaru 8y agoin parts of Europe you can use Revolut, where you can choose whether to enable or disable contactless payments, chip and pin, ATM withdrawals and online payments, depending on what you want to use the card for. You can even keep all of them off and only activate a specific feature for a few minutes when needed.
- gambiting 8y agoI can do all of these with my normal bank, but there is no way to request a stripe-less debit/credit card.
- ryanlol 8y agoJust remove the stripe or wipe it yourself.
- gambiting 8y agoAny tips on how to do so?
- LeonM 8y agoYou can stratch it off, or use a very powerful magnet to erase the strip. When scratching be careful not to damage the NFC antenna which loops around in the card.
- Tor3 8y agoIt doesn't need a 'very powerful magnet'. In fact I'm surprised how easy it is to make the magnetic strip unreadable. The way I (unintentionally) do it is simply to keep the cards together in the wallet. Their individual magnetic stripes destroy each other. All the cards are unreadable now, except for the newest card. And no, there aren't any other magnetic or electro-whatever device nearby.
- tjoff 8y agoActually, the prudent thing is to actively damage the NFC antenna. There is not much point in damaging the magnetic stripe but leaving wireless functionality... they are exactly the same thing only wireless works from a greater distance.
- NickNameNick 8y agoIt's all chip and pin where I live too, and has been for ages. Often enough, the chip or the reader is dirty and fails to read, the terminal will prompt you to swipe the card through the mag-reader instead. Usually, it will prompt you to try the card reader again, then back to the mag-reader for a final swipe before continuing.
- rocqua 8y agoIn the Netherlands, when we switched to a new chip system, most terminals blocked the mag-swipe with some cardboard sign instructing the user to use the chip instead. I'm pretty sure the swipe-style is aggresively deprecated by the banks. I talked to a vendor who had an older terminal that would not accept NFC, and he mentioned that within 2 years, he'd have to get a terminal that would process NFC payments.
- tialaramex 8y agoThe deprecation works by shifting fraud risk to the merchant. I know for a fact this was done in the US and UK, and I would assume the rough playbook was used everywhere, it's named "liability shift". The idea is, if there's fraud and the real account holder gets their money back (a chargeback in payment industry terms) somebody has to eat that loss. The liability shift rules say if you didn't do EMV, that's you. For a bank that decided they wouldn't issue EMV cards, they pay when there's fraud on their non-EMV cards - so the merchant still gets their money. But for a merchant if the customer has an EMV card but they swipe it, if that comes back as fraud they're not getting their money. If the terminals suck, and your business has very low fraud rates or your markup is so enormous you can eat plenty of fraud and not care, it could make sense to ignore liability shift. Especially at first when customers know they could go elsewhere. But as terminals improve, and everybody else is forcing them to use the chip anyway, offering swipe is pretty much a sign "Commit fraud here, ask us how". For NFC I don't know, it's hard to imagine them trying liability shift. "Use this less secure option or, we'll stick you with fraud costs for the uh, more secure option?" maybe they're just doing the usual thing where they raise fees for everybody who doesn't want to go along with their latest craze :/
- dhimes 8y agoI've never had my mag stripe skimmed. I've had three chips skimmed- in one year. I'm US based, but it happened once in Malaysia.
- astura 8y agoHow do you "swipe" the chip on a credit card? I thought that they are designed so replay attacks weren't possible?
- Crosseye_Jack 8y agoOne trick (which I believe has been fixed) is not so much a replay attack but a multiple transaction attack. A modified terminal makes multiple transactions on the card while the card is still in the terminal, coupled with another attack that modified what was presented on the screen of the terminal could turn a single $5 transaction to 3 $500 transactions. The video is 3 years old now but still worth a watch discussing the attacks they have seen on Chip and Pin - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ks0SOn8hjG8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ks0SOn8hjG8
- pjc50 8y agoHaving just travelled in the almost-cashless country of Norway, I found a surprising example: the Oslo airport fast train gates operate by magswiping a payment card. I suppose it's because contactless doesn't reliably work internationally.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- saidajigumi 8y agoIt's interesting to contrast that to Japan's standard "IC" card NFC system, with multiple vendors (Pasmo, Suica, etc.). Everything in that system is so blazing fast. Commute-hour Tokyo subways full of people moving as fast as they can without resorting to a full run, TAPTAPTAPTAPTAPTAPTAP... through the turnstiles, very low failure rates (I've never witnessed one), not really a noticeable delay, and it'll show you your balance if you can swivel your head fast enough as you're whipping through the gate. It makes a much more recently deployed system in my area of the US look like a total embarrassment: seconds per processed tap, a much higher tap failure rate (regularly see tap failures for myself and others), etc.
- Tor3 8y agoYes, that's as close to perfect as it can get. Just rush through the turnstiles (and btw the default position is open - nothing stops you as long as the card has cash, so there's no pausing at all), figure out where the train (or subway) is after that, not to mention not having to figure out tickets from the machine. The only decent way to travel, just go go go, no delay. And you can use the same card to buy a coffee from the vending machines in the station. But then again trains and a lot more really work in Japan. Supermarket? No waiting for payment (card or otherwise) - they're using double-buffering.
- sizzle 8y agoI thought chip and pin could be trivially captured/cloned due to some flaw in the underlying technology?
- tialaramex 8y agoThere are plenty of flaws in the underlying technology, and most especially in real world implementations, but I don't know that any of them result in the chip being cloned. Anybody? An example I know about with one of those flaws was the "Yes card" which MITMs a real (presumably stolen) card and arranges that the conversation goes like this: * Legitimate terminal "Hi, I'm a Legitimate terminal, who are you?" * Real card: "Hi, I'm Sizzle's Real Payment Card from Real Bank" * Legitimate terminal "OK, let's do an offline transaction. I want Sizzle to authorise payment of 24.50. They entered PIN 1234, is that OK?" MITM Yes card blocks this and tells the card instead: "OK, let's do an offline transaction. I want Sizzle to authorize payment of 24.50, but I can't be bothered with a PIN so let's skip that" * Real card: "OK, yes, payment of 24.50 sounds fine" (cryptographically signed message) So this way you don't need the correct PIN, since the card never realises you entered a PIN, and so the transaction OK simply never mentions the PIN at all. You don't clone the card though, you need a real card, you're just using something like a Confused Deputy attack where the card and terminal misunderstand the situation. A _smart_ backend at the bank could identify this fraud when the offline transactions are processed, hours or days later, but many did not, and even if they did spot it the fraudsters got away with their transaction meanwhile. The permanent "fix" for this was to roll out new cards and terminals, given this costs money it was probably not done widely or quickly.
- sizzle 8y agoI may be mistaken about the chip/pin capturing, thanks for the breakdown.