16 ms·
A Fighter Pilot’s Guide to Surviving on the Roads
- alex_hitchins 8y agoLooks like this is from 2013, but still a good read.
- xattt 8y agoThere’s still bikes and cars on the road in 2018!
- mitko 8y agoThis was eye opening (pun not intended) and make me a bit worried as a recreational cyclist - many of my clothes are dark and it seems worth investing in brighter ones. As a driver, I found that using BGE setting of the side mirrors (it's wider out, slightly overlapping with rearview mirror), coupled with keeping an eye on the road gives me a much better situational awareness, and prevents the need to turn my head in many cases - "Nope, there's a car in my blind spot, not changing lanes yet". It's a minor convenience but really helps with fatigue of the neck muscles, and keep my eyes forward, so I can react if anything happens in front of me. I've been driving BGE for nearly 10 years now, and I feel a lot safer that way. It takes some getting used to not seeing the side of the car, so if you consider doing it, I'd recommend getting used to it on a chill road, before getting on the highway. https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.dot.gov/files/blindzoneglaremirrormethod.pdf https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.dot.gov/files/blindzonegla...
- baud147258 8y ago>many of my clothes are dark I've taken so many risks like this when I was using a bike: dark grey coat: check, black pants: check, dark grey backpack: check, black shoes: check. And usually my light (only in the back) is barely visible because of using old batteries and forgetting to change them.
- komali2 8y ago>check out the middle cyclist >https://www.portsmouthctc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Fighter4.jpg https://www.portsmouthctc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/... That part of the article blew my mind. That cyclist is practically invisible. I consider myself an extraordinarily safe driver and I know I would not see that cyclist. Time to get a high viz vest for the motorcycle and bicycle rides.
- polaritron 8y agoPartly, the instinct is about feeling trashy, and having to replace worn-out old junk as it accumulates stains, scuff marks, battle damage. It feels wasteful to have to discard perfectly useful items, because they look worn out. We all know that black, dark items tend show the least amount of wear, and in the interest of efficient frugality, some of us gravitate toward that instinct. You look at a white t-shirt, and you know it's going to show pit stains by the end of the year. A black t-shirt might show some white accumulation inside the armpits, but not outside, and you really are only going to have to trash it, once some holes show up. Same with socks. So too with hi-viz stuff. You just don't want to buy something, and throw it out, the moment it gives a sense of unintended imperfection. It's more an equipment maintenance perspective, than a live, situational awareness point of view. The best equipment is the stuff you have, and the stuff you have is the stuff you keep. Being a little OCD, but that's what's going on under the hood, from my own perspective.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoEverything costs money. Everything has tradeoffs. Safety is no exception. It's all about management of risk. If you seek to mitigate all risk you'll find yourself with even more risk because your bank account is now empty. The internet is great at telling other people how to spend their money so of course everyone will tell you you need the "best" helmet and the "most" reflective jacket, etc, etc.
- def_true_false 8y agoIf you don't care about looks, you could just get some reflective tape (the kind used for trucks, e.g. V82). Use it on the bike and helmet and you'll probably be more visible than someone in a fancy jacket. Spending couple bucks on safety seems like a decent tradeoff.
- nsnick 8y agoSaying cyclists should wear bright clothing is blaming the victims of vehicle violence. https://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/stop-victim-blaming-cyclist-pedestrian-crashes/Content?oid=24570247 https://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/stop-victim-blaming-cy...
- hardlianotion 8y agoAnd still good advice.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoI've seen pedestrians cross the street without a walk light in a downpour where visibility is five feet at midnight on a poorly illuminated intersection while wearing all black. Cars have lights not just so they can see, but so others can see them. Pedestrians absolutely should have the same, or at least something approaching reflective clothing.
- dvdcxn 8y agoWe blame the drivers of cars without headlights on for night time collisions, why would cyclists be any different?
- isostatic 8y agoSure, and in the UK at least it's a requirement to have lights on when riding at night.
- rjsw 8y agoCan't remember the last time I saw a cyclist with lights. They seem to think that they don't need them if in a cycle lane, even when there is nothing separating it from the rest of the road.
- 8y ago
- isostatic 8y agoNone of those cyclists are riding in a particularly sensible position, it's patently unclear where they are going, are they in lane 1 or lane 2, or moving from one to another?
- mcguire 8y agoIn the NHTSA pdf? They're roughly in the middle of the lane.
- isostatic 8y agoIn the article, specifically the picture they appear in https://www.portsmouthctc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Fighter4.jpg https://www.portsmouthctc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/... The argument "it's the cyclist fault she got killed for not wearing bright colours" is practically the same as "it's the woman's fault she got raped for wearing a short skirt" Maybe cyclists should be forced to wear high vis clothes so car drivers can drive around without awareness. Maybe schoolkids in the UK should wear bullet proof vests so gun owners don't accidentally shoot them. Maybe women should be forced to wear burkas so men don't get tempted. These arguments are very similar logic. However if cyclists are to take some responsibility for their safety on the road, not riding at the edge of a lane is the first thing to do, not wearing a burka or a flak jacket.
- bacon_waffle 8y agoIt looks to me like they're in a perfectly sensible position - just outside the door zone as they approach some parallel-parked cars. Am I missing something?
- isostatic 8y agoThey are in the second lane, then they are too close to the left most lane. A vehicle (especially a large vehicle) passing up the inside could be very close. If the yellow rider were to move slightly to the left, the blue one would probably swerve towards the left lane, but there's no where to go. They are also encouraging in-lane overtaking, which might just about work for a motorbike or another bike, but anything wider would be a problem The yellow topped one is probably OK in lane position if the other cyclists weren't there (but why not another metre to the right). However he's very close to the blue one. The blue and stripy ones run the risk of being hemmed in by traffic from the rear
- chooseaname 8y agoI always use BGE. My dad basically nagged me into remembering it always. I tell people who have never done it, go find a parking lot with just a few cars in it and convince themselves that it works and that it is safer than twisting their head around to see backwards.
- noratonsto 8y agoA warning, do NOT use this mirror arrangement if you drive in a crowded city and share the road with scooters, motorcycles, bikes, and pedestrians. BGE is great if you drive on big roads and mainly share it with other cars. However if you drive in a city with tons of scooters, you know the ones that will swarm your car, then they will all be in your blind spot if you use this mirror arrangement.
- gomox 8y agoMy Ford car has smaller convex mirrors in the corners of the normal side mirrors and they are a godsend in busy city driving. I really miss them when driving other cars.
- Forbo 8y agoI'm surprised to see this is the first mention of convex mirrors. I get some of the stick-on variety for any car I'm driving, as it dramatically increases the viewing angle for my side mirrors. I get them for my friends to put on their mirrors, too. If a $6 item can help avoid any kind of collision, that's an insane ROI.
- Spooky23 8y agoI agree with you on the stick-on mirrors. My current car has convex mirrors built in, and I find them very distracting. The little $6 stick on is a superior product.
- jsight 8y agoI completely agree. Although, alternatively, you can keep BGE and just move your head a lot more when in the crowded city environment, if that isn't your primary driving environment. It isn't nearly as big of a problem to look sideways in the low urban speed environments, IMO.
- jtbayly 8y agoJust to be clear, you still have to look over before you do change lanes. It's just that you don't have to look as often to figure out that you can't change lanes yet.
- rsync 8y agoThis is in contrast to what the article from NHTSA says: "With this new setting, it is no longer necessary to turn and look into the blindzones." ... which is in contrast to what the original article quite emphatically says: "... move your head or you're dead ..." I like the novel mirror arrangement and will try it but I hope people will follow the advice of the fighter pilot, and not NHTSA, and continue to move their heads.
- ahmedalsudani 8y agoI tried the different angle a couple of years ago because it seemed like the smart thing to do—increase the number of things I see. I found that my blind spots were reduced but not eliminated. It’s scary to think that somebody on the road might stop looking over after adjusting their mirrors. One solution that I have more faith in is the little convex “blind-spot mirrors.” Those actually seem to cover everything in the blind spot and then some more (at least on the driver side).
- logfromblammo 8y agoIt seems to me like angling the mirror further outward could be done with mirrors (or cameras) installed inside the car. The advantage of the outside mirror is that you can see the side of the car. So if you prefer to drive with BGE mirrors, wouldn't you be better off leaving the outer mirrors so you can see along your side, and a bit to the rear, and install auxiliary outward-angled mirrors on the dashboard inside the car? I know in one of our cars that the B-column is absolutely huge, and even swiveling my head is not enough to check the left blind spot, because that B-column is fat enough to hide a car. I have to check an auxiliary convex mirror before changing lanes left. That's mounted on the wing mirror, but I would have preferred it to be on the dash, because it eats up a lot of space on the regular mirror, and is still rather small in its own right.
- rconti 8y agoIf you can replace your car's driver's side mirror with aspheric european mirror, do so. (Assuming you're in the US). I had the euro glass on my Golf, and the ability to see more than just a massive grille filling up your entire mirror glass on the driver's side is a godsend. I can actually see a car 2 lanes over moving into the same lane I'm trying to move into, using just my mirrors. I've used this mirror adjustment method forever, and it really does eliminate blind spots, especially given correct mirrors. It depends on the car, though -- our Tesla 3 has pretty bad blind spots in the peripheral area because the glass doesn't adjust far enough out, and they haven't started selling the car in Europe yet, so you can't get the correct glass for it.
- lazyant 8y agoI don't remember if it was 1/3 or 2/3 (a lot anyways) of motorcycle accidents were caused by another car driver, and mostly due that they didn't see the motorcycle so a high-visibility jacket (yellow/orange with reflective stripes) is a must imho.
- marssaxman 8y agoI'm not going to wear a dorky-looking yellow vest even if it does make me safer, but it is very useful to assume that I am always effectively invisible. If you expect that drivers will constantly cut you off, pull out in front of you, and even merge directly into your lane, motorcycles are nimble enough that you can generally see the problem coming and react in time to avoid catastrophe when it inevitably happens.
- dsego 8y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12422378 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12422378
- ruddct 8y agoInteresting read, up until this point. “[As a cyclist], look at the head of the driver that is approaching or has stopped. The head of the driver will naturally stop and centre upon you if you have been seen.“ Please, please do not rely on this. Correlation is not causation, a driver’s head might face your direction for lots of reasons (focusing on something behind/in front of you, spacing out, looking at their phone, etc). Friends and family have been bitten by this ‘trick’ before, thankfully not with deadly consequences. When someone’s head is facing you, it does not mean they see you. A little surprising to see this advice in an article that’s mostly about the eye being fallible.
- roymurdock 8y agoThe author speaks in stepwise, risk management terms rather than "if green then go" rules. This is just another piece of information that can help you reduce risk and make better judgements as a cyclist on the road, but by no means a hard rule (don't think the author meant to imply that it is)
- sandermvanvliet 8y agoOne of the campaigns here about truck drivers and the blind spot of trucks has focused on “if you see me, I see you” which, while not an absolute guarantee, still helps me as a cyclist to get some indication whether I would be visible in the first place. As sibling post mentions: lots of little things that can help you mitigate risks.
- jacquesm 8y agoI like the reverse better: "If you can't see me, I can't see you".
- goodcanadian 8y agoI understand your point, but I still think it is worthwhile advice. This trick saved me very recently when it was clear that a driver had not seen me (and my 4yo!) on my bike. I was able to start braking hard even before she pulled out and thus avoid the collision. So, while you are correct that just because someone looks at you, it doesn't mean they see you, it is also true that if someone doesn't look at you, it means they almost certainly didn't see you.
- toomanybeersies 8y ago> Remember, lights are just as much about being seen as being able to see I cannot emphasis this enough. It's terrible the amount of drivers who think "I can see fine, I don't need to put on my headlights". Whenever I'm driving on open roads (100 km/h areas) I'll always turn my headlights on. Like aeroplanes, I think that anything on the road should have lights on it for visibility.
- cube2222 8y agoIt's actually mandatory in most (if not all?) of the EU. You must have your headlights on at all times.
- ygra 8y agoMotorcycles maybe, cars have (by now) mandatory daytime running lights, but at least in Germany for older cars it's not mandatory to have lights on during daytime.
- _pmf_ 8y agoI remember that one country reverted its decision for mandatory daytime light for cars because it decreased visibility of motorbikes (for which daytime lights were mandatory).
- lloeki 8y agoThat would be France. The idea is indeed to increase visibility of the most vulnerable vehicles. Motorbike riders behave differently than car drivers, hence it is critically important to be able to distinguish them easily in traffic (we downright suck at evaluating movements of light sources compared to solid objects). This is also a factor as to why always-on daylights are mandatorily placed lower than headlights.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoWorse, some of the daytime running "lights" are only visible from about 5 m directly in front of the car - plus on most cars, the "daytime lights" setting only switches front lights, leaving the back entirely off. That's a cure worse than the disease.
- Tomte 8y agoRelevant Twitter thread: "You want to know something about how bullshit insane our brains are?" https://twitter.com/Foone/status/1014267515696922624 https://twitter.com/Foone/status/1014267515696922624
- Stratoscope 8y agoI usually avoid Twitter threads, but that thread is one of the most interesting things I've read. Recommended.
- aembleton 8y agoEasier to read here: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1014267515696922624.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1014267515696922624.html
- exDM69 8y agoNot too long ago, I was very close to having a "constant bearing, decreasing range" (CBDR) accident that the article is talking about. I failed to slow down adequately to a T-junction and almost drove straight in front of a truck, despite having looked in that direction twice before entering the intersection. I'm pretty sure my vision was (partially) occluded by the corner pillar and/or a snow pile on the side of the road and therefore tricking my brain exactly as the article describes. All it takes is a change in speed to avoid this accident. I now take extra caution in these situations, especially T-junctions or 4-way intersections without traffic lights.
- lloeki 8y ago> All it takes is a change in speed to avoid this accident. Together with moving your head slightly both ways to try to look from additional angles around both sides of the pillar. Although rarer, CBDR can occur even when reducing speed if the other vehicle also happens to reduce his speed at the same time, which can be surprisingly common on intersections where priority is unclear or there's a curve leading to it. Happened to me on a T junction on a mountain road, luckily we were at low speed and (surprise!) stopped face to face. As the article suggests: "Move your head — or you’re dead". The other vehicle speed can't vary as fast as you peeking left and right around the pillar.
- phaedrus 8y agoI drive a Honda Element. The A-pillars are huge and cover a ridiculous percent of the field of view. "Constant bearing, decreasing range" ought to be printed on the side mirrors, or perhaps it should have been named the "Honda CBDR". (Note: I love the car, this is just one of it's few less-than-perfect attributes.) On certain left-curving roads it's possible to drive 10 - 15 seconds being unable to see anything directly in front of you. I compensate by bobbing and weaving to look around the A-pillar at every intersection or when passing. Maybe it even makes me a safer driver because there's no illusion - I know there's a lot I can't see so drive accordingly.
- theluketaylor 8y agoMy biggest fear of driving a modern car is pedestrians and cyclists hiding in the think A pillar when turning. I am also doing the bob and weave like a prize boxer to make sure things don't escape my vision. I'd much rather run into another car than a pedestrian since at least vehicle collisions are a fair fight. I'm so much more comfortable when I drive my vintage car. The greenhouse is massive, so you can see everything without even turning your head. I also drive that car much more consciously since it requires real effort. The trade off is if I ever run into anything I'm under no illusions about the safety it provides (which is none) I can't wait for A pillars that are screens so they become invisible.
- lloeki 8y agoAs a former pilot wannabe I do apply a similar set of practices and they do work wonders. Some other tips I carried over from training: - Don't look at bright lights at night, look slightly off, for two reasons. First retina persistence will occur somewhere in your (larger) peripheral vision, rather than in the small hi-res patch of your retina that is critical to conscious sight. Second we are naturally driving towards where we look, and lights are especially alluring. This is also valid for obstacles (static or moving), don't look at them, look past or next to them, ideally away from the direction of their movement (which is, as hunters, counterintuitive and unnatural). This can save your life (and has for me). - Always perform pre-flight checklists, both metric, visual and tactile. This is about checking the usual fluid levels (brakes are obviously key) and tire pressure (don't be fooled, a slightly deflated tire can be invisible to the naked eye or touch yet still be dangerous) but also inspection of wipers, tires (tread and sidewalls) and wheels, brake discs, car underside, pedal feel, turning wheel behaviour. Look for evidence of leaking fluids, wiggles, wear, uneven surfaces. Don't hesitate to use touch. Pilots routinely manipulate parts of their planes such as flaps to check they're in no obvious non-working order. - Maintenance, maintenance, maintenance. A properly maintained car emits basically no unusual noise. I can't count the number of people who have undue noise in their cars. At the very least a noisy car is an inefficient one! Plus even if the noise is due to a harmless cause, it can cover other noises that hint at more serious problems. - Respect the flow. It is critical to act as if traffic is a fluid, and anything that disrupts the flow creates perturbations, which means more chaos (hence less predictability) and increased risk of collisions. Think of those beautiful fluid dynamics simulations and what happens visually when you disrupt the flow at the edge, in the middle, introduce a narrow point or a second inlet mid-stream. - Be humble: don't text (you're not looking at the road), don't phone (you're context-switching to a virtual space with the person you're talking to, not in the car, driving), don't drink (even a slight drink slashes reaction time by serious amounts, possibly by orders of magnitude). - If at all possible, take extra classes on a track to experience vehicle behaviour near, at, and above its limit in various situations. This will help you in recognising when you're approaching the limits outside of controlled conditions and backing off in the safe zone. Don't be fooled by the fact that taking such a class makes you magically able to recover from, say, an uncontrolled spin though: again, be humble. - Your body is constantly lying to you. As mentioned in the article, visual perception is a tricky thing, and other senses can be deceptively abused[0]. Some may appear with reduced frequency due to the vastly reduced amplitude of degrees of freedom in a car as well as visible cues compared to an airplane, but situations may happen where those axes are involved (cars do tilt along all axes!) or visual cues are lost (heavy rain, fog, night). Be aware of that, and combat that with failsafe cues and training. - The OODA loop[1] is a thing that works well when driving, leading to anticipation, but needs practice to be leveraged in emergency situations. So, practice it regularly in safe situations, and neural plasticity will carve the required neural pathways to operate efficiently under more stressful conditions. As with the helmet example, the ultimate goal is to avoid collisions altogether. You're driving several metric tons of metal at unnatural speeds. Unnatural as in: as low as 50km/h a brutal shock has a non-trivial chance of outright ripping your aorta to shreds, and driving an armor-clad, comfortable wheeled machine can't change that. As with most catastrophes, many dramatic events on the road are not due to a single root cause but death by a thousand cuts, some more aggravating than others. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensory_illusions_in_aviation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sensory_illusions_in_aviation [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OODA_loop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OODA_loop
- Jemm 8y agoThis advice should be part of driver's ed curriculum.
- crispyambulance 8y agoThis is sound advice. The only time I've made contact with a moving car as a cyclist was when I was going past an off-ramp. The weird thing was that I thought the driver "saw me". It was late morning, no problem with visibility. From my POV, she was looking right at me. In fact, she was looking "through" me. She simply was expecting other cars and a person on a bike was not what she was looking for. Human attention is very much selective. Check out this shocking video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJG698U2Mvo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJG698U2Mvo After that, I ride with a bright flashing headlight at all times, even daylight. It gives some measure of protection, I think.
- hammock 8y agoOff-ramps exist on separated-grade highways, which by definition exclude bicycle traffic. What were you doing on such a highway?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- crispyambulance 8y agoNot sure If I understand the exact traffic engineer definition of "off-ramp" but I was going straight on an urban street that the off-ramp exited onto. FWIW it was here..https://www.google.com/maps/@39.2686291,-76.6312124,3a,75y,186.8h,88.78t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s6agwYLfVYPRBz3eV8wSbVQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@39.2686291,-76.6312124,3a,75y,1...
- GavinMcG 8y agoWhen someone else is wrong by definition, consider that you're the one misunderstanding things. Yes, it's possible that they're using language wrong. But there are almost always more charitable interpretations.
- brewdad 8y agoHe wasn't. Also, in my state at least, bicycles are completely legal to ride on the shoulder of the interstate and similar divided highways with the exception of about 20 miles of urban highway. Very few cyclists do so since it is still a dangerous and unpleasant experience. Personally, I have done so once when I made a couple of wrong turns on unfamiliar backroads. A 2 mile ride along the highway got me back to a spot I knew rather than risk getting even more lost farther from home.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoTo mods: A complete aside, but I posted this yesterday (say 30 hours ago) not today. is this some reset for labour day or other deeply cunning ranking algorithm? Or maybe i fat fingered it ...
- craftyguy 8y agoHN's article submissions/promoting algorithm is shit. If I had to guess, they give priority to articles submitted by certain users (either based on fake internet points or ??).
- lifeisstillgood 8y agowell I submitted it - and i have not noticed any favouritism in the past :-) I suspect it's probably some mix of re-submitting affecting timestamps - I am not sure, which was why I asked. it's not terribly important. I think the problem to be solved however is hard, and i don't know of any obvious solutions, so perhaps "shit" is probably too harsh.
- craftyguy 8y agoIt is shit. Duplicate stories are arbitrarily allowed to be submitted (exact same article/url), while sometimes it actually works and prevents duplicates. Oftentimes you see submissions for an interesting article languish in the 'new' section, but then a user re-submits the exact same thing ('duplicate detection' algo at work, lol) and it's on the front page in minutes. Whether that user is a 'power user', besties with dang, lucky, or ???..
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoI think it would be more effort to write your vision of the submission process than what is probably there. The algos is presumably a straight up string compare with some url decoding, but any amount of idiotic GET key value pairs can screw that up. I find Occam's razor the best explanation for these kind of things - I suggest not taking it to heart too much.
- upofadown 8y ago>... when passing junctions, look at the head of the driver that is approaching or has stopped. That doesn't really work any more with the steeply sloped windows of contemporary aerodynamic vehicles. All you see is a reflection of the sky. If the vehicle has tinted rear windows you don't even have a chance to see a silhouette...
- barking 8y agoIn the past at a dangerous junction with limited visibilty owing to corners and high speed traffic I found myself looking one way then the other repeatedly before moving. Now I look to one side until I'm certain it's free I look the other way and if I see nothing, I go. It feels like I'm fighting my instincts but so far so good!
- seszett 8y agoIn this situation, I learnt (driving school in France) to first look to the left, and once it's free then look to the right. If it's free, go. I have to admit I don't remember the explanation I was given then but it made sense, and as far as I know everyone's taught to do that here. In a car or on a bike, it doesn't matter. You also do that at pedestrian crossings.
- scott_s 8y ago> Not convinced? Okay, go to a mirror and look repeatedly from your right eye to your left eye. Can you see your eyes moving? You cannot. Now have a friend or partner do the same thing while you watch them. You will see their eyes moving quite markedly. The reason you couldn’t see your own eyes move is because your brain shuts down the image for the instant that your eyes are moving. Experiments have shown that it is impossible to see even a flash of light if it occurs within a saccade. When you have your phone in selfie mode, the latency is low enough that it can feel like a mirror. When you move, you see yourself in the camera app move. But if you do the above experiment, you can definitely catch your eyes moving. Then you can shut the screen off and do the above experiment using the screen as a mirror and you cannot. It's a neat demonstration of the latency.
- btrettel 8y agoTransportation cyclist here. This is a great article, but it only indirectly touches upon one of the most effective tools a cyclist could have: an air horn. I have an Air Zound air horn and I feel much less safe riding without it. I'll often give a few toots before approaching an intersection to increase the chance that I am seen. And it has probably saved me from some major crashes when I lay down the horn on someone. Many drivers seem to automatically brake when I honk. The horn is also great for giving bad drivers feedback. Most people who drive poorly around cyclists seem oblivious. Some drivers unfortunately see horn use as hostility. I have dealt with a few road raging drivers who were very angry that I honked at them. I am pretty certain most of these drivers would be angry with or without the horn, so it doesn't much matter to me. The safety benefits also are far too large even if these folks would not tend to be angry either way.
- nickthemagicman 8y agoIf they're angry at you then they see you!
- btrettel 8y agoGreat point. I think I'll highlight that when recommending air horns in the future.
- nickthemagicman 8y agoI ride a motorcycle and it's the same thing. Them seeing you is top priority.
- adrianN 8y agoUnfortunately that is not enough to prevent murderous behavior. For example this angry gentleman https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBwk0tvLCxA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBwk0tvLCxA
- irrational 8y ago"see horn use as hostility" Of course they do. When people in cars honk at other people in cars, the majority of time it is a sign of hostility. They've been conditioned to perceive the use of a horn as a sign of hostility.
- sandworm101 8y agoTake the fighter pilot thing with a grain of salt. Some of this stuff belongs more in the sky than on the road. The mirrors thing is a good example. Fighter pilots seek to reduce head movements. During g and/or turns, turning your head can lead to disorientation, even nausia. (It is about the little canals in your ears.) That isnt an issue on the road. Dont try to reduce shoulder checks. The focus on being seen is also something to think about. Google "target fixation". At night, drunks tend to drive towards bright shiny things. Airstrips amd cockpits use this to hold a pilots attention. There is something to be said for staying hidden, or at least not relying totally upon cars seeing you. Better to stay where you cannot be hit in the first place, and actively avoid cars. That might mean not riding with traffic approaching from behind, or not trusting that if they see you they will avoid you.
- elchief 8y agoI've done the whole "where the F did that guy come from? I totally looked" more often recently Does it get worse with age?
- rconti 8y agoThe part about the eyes not focusing near the pillars makes so much sense. I've often griped about how hard it is to see out of modern cars with thick airbag-equipped pillars, but still wondered how I managed to "miss" something that clearly cannot completely hide in an A-pillar. (eg, because the pillar is diagonal, the pedestrian's head or feet or both will still be visible even if their midsection is obscured. I used to commute through an area with an endless sea of stop signs, which almost NEVER had cross traffic. My car had a rearview mirror that came down too far and tended to block part of my view forward and to the right, and sometimes pedestrians or cross traffic would 'hide' in the pillars. It's one of those things where, if there had been no stop signs, I would have been much more likely to notice cross traffic, but having to look at the sign and stop line takes your focus for that last 2-3 seconds as you slow to a stop, so even if you're "sure" you scanned for peds/cross traffic, maybe once every 6 months I would begin to proceed and then suddenly see the movement of a vehicle or person in my peripheral vision. Those pillars and the rearview mirror didn't block what i was looking for, but they must have cued my eyes to not look 'too close' to them. Interesting.