4 ms·
In the context of the Mossack Fonseca Panama Papers scandal, the Paradise Papers, the Bahama Leaks, Apple's double Dutch Irish sandwich tax evasion resulting in
by BLKNSLVR 8y ago
In the context of the Mossack Fonseca Panama Papers scandal, the Paradise Papers, the Bahama Leaks, Apple's double Dutch Irish sandwich tax evasion resulting in Billions of dollars kept offshore for a US company (as a single example of the worldwide problem of corporate tax avoidance), and the complete inability to track company ownership due to 'offshore shell companies', this new attack on encryption doesn't even rate in terms of its ability to make a difference to the problems they say they're trying to solve.
This is targeting individuals. It is phenomenally small-fry when you look at the kind of funds that terrorist group seem to have access to.
Commonwealth Bank, an Australian Bank, failed to report suspicious transactions totalling $77m over the course of a number of months (ref: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/aug/03/commonwealth-bank-accused-of-money-laundering-and-terrorism-financing-breaches https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/aug/03/commo...)
And this was in breach of existing laws; no new laws were needed to prevent this kind of thing, just enforcement.
Terrorism isn't funded by the little people sending encrypted messages. Terrorism is funded by large groups of people using shell companies to hide their ownership, often funnelling money from legitimate business using loopholes, finding edge-cases.
This is swatting a mosquito with a sledgehammer whilst ignoring the alligator that's already engulfed your leg up to the knee.
If they were serious, they'd be trying to solve the big problems before trimming the fringes.
Again, this is about nation-state power in conflict with multi-national technology corporate power. It's not about terrorism or pedophilia or people smuggling or money laundering, because these measures will have no effect on those things. These new surveillance measures will allow street-corner dealers and casual drug users to be prosecuted whilst the suppliers continue to plough their laundered money into investment portfolios - and isn't that what conservative governments like to see?
- metta2uall 8y agoThe issues with encryption technologies is a separate matter to the prosecution of large-scale criminality & the closure of white-collar loopholes - both of which of course we need much more of. Saying we're ignoring the alligator is quite an exaggeration though, and access to communications (with a court order) would be very useful to large-scale criminal cases, including in working up the chain. Many international paedophile rings have been successfully caught out.
- Silhouette 8y agoSaying we're ignoring the alligator is quite an exaggeration though, and access to communications (with a court order) would be very useful to large-scale criminal cases, including in working up the chain. It's a shame the relevant governments and agencies didn't think more about that before they acted as they have historically. To my mind, the issue of government access to encrypted communications has now become a moral dilemma that sits alongside the principle of not negotiating under threats or the fruit of the poisonous tree legal doctrine. Obviously and regrettably it will be harmful in some individual cases, but that may be the cost of not undermining the integrity of the whole system, and that in turn may be the greater good (or, if you prefer, the lesser of two evils).
- CryptoPunk 8y agoIf you look at the mortality figures over the last century, it's clear state terrorism and democide are far greater threats to the individual than terrorism by non-state actors. General lawlessness is also a major source of death, especially in less developed countries, but mitigating that only requires a functioning criminal justice system and a state with enough power to extend basic rule of law to all regions in the country. It has nothing to do with an over-abundance of privacy rights. A mass-surveillance apparatus gives unprecedented powers to the centralized authorities, by massively reducing the cost of exerting control over the population. Unless one assumes that the state can never be corrupted, this is an inherently dangerous situation.