7 ms·
And it will harm ocean wildlife more than it will help... https://www.kcet.org/redefine/6-reasons-that-floating-ocean-plastic-cleanup-gizmo-is-a-horrible-idea h
by ummonk 8y ago
And it will harm ocean wildlife more than it will help... https://www.kcet.org/redefine/6-reasons-that-floating-ocean-plastic-cleanup-gizmo-is-a-horrible-idea https://www.kcet.org/redefine/6-reasons-that-floating-ocean-...
- mirimir 8y agoIt seems that there's a key point of contention. That link claims: > But the vast majority of plastic in the ocean is made up of particles one centimeter and smaller, remnants of larger pieces broken up by ultraviolet light, the corrosive effects of seawater, and physical abuse from wave action and marine creatures. But the posted article claims instead: > "Research shows the majority of plastic by mass is currently in the larger debris," as noted on The Ocean Cleanup website. "By removing the plastic while most of it is still large, we prevent it from breaking down into dangerous microplastics" that can absorb toxic substances and travel up the food chain. So which is it? And even if the claim that "the majority of plastic by mass is currently in the larger debris" is wrong, because they didn't sample deeply enough, doesn't the argument that "removing the plastic while most of it is still large, we prevent it from breaking down into dangerous microplastics" remain valid? The risk of structural failures generating more debris, and problems with anti-fouling treatments, seem manageable through good maintenance. Or better design. But then, what to do with the debris collected? Recycling per se does seem hopeless. I mean, we aren't even recycling much regular plastic waste, because it's mixed and contaminated. But maybe just crack it down to simple hydrocarbons, and make sure to capture the metals and halogens.
- quotemstr 8y agoWhat would be wrong with just burying it? We're not hurting for landfill space.
- mirimir 8y agoWhy waste all those good petrochemicals?
- quotemstr 8y agoWho said anything about waste? The plastics will be there in the landfill, ready for future mining and cracking once it becomes cost effective to do it.
- mirimir 8y agoOK, fair enough. But why wait?
- quotemstr 8y agoBecause, right now, it's cheaper to get hydrocarbons out of the ground than to break down old plastics, and the price signal is an excellent pointer toward the best application of our scarce resources.
- mirimir 8y agoPrice signals tend to ignore externalities. I'm not arguing that there's a huge issue re cracking or burning plastic waste vs landfilling it and using more oil. You'd need to compare ecological and climate impacts of the alternatives, and that's more than I want to do here. And not to be boring, but ignoring externalities is why humanity will get seriously screwed through global climate change. There isn't any workable mechanism to price that, as far as I know. Carbon credits are a joke. So it bugs me when people go on about price signals. When there's substantial time lag, the price signal is too late to be useful.
- quotemstr 8y agoWhy are carbon credits a joke? Carbon pricing is an obvious Pigovian approach to reducing emissions and it's what we'll eventually end up using, in conjunction with CCS. What's the problem?
- mirimir 8y agoThe problem is that they'll be effective, if ever, two or three decades too late.
- manicdee 8y agoThe bulk of the mass is in larger pieces, but the number of tiny pieces vastly outnumbers the large pieces. Imagine it being like an extension of this set of plastic piece masses: (100, 80, 50, 25, 10, 5, 4, 4, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 2, 2, 2, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1) One large piece (say, a Troll doll) has more mass than the pieces is breaks down into, but those pieces are more numerous than the whole doll.
- mirimir 8y agoWell, Ocean Cleanup says "the majority of plastic by mass", so that seems to address your size distribution argument. I am guessing, however, that their evidence shows that "the majority of plastic by mass" in the top whatever meters is in large pieces, but the distribution of small pieces goes far deeper.
- mreome 8y agoThat is one of the criticisms of project's research. They only looked at the water column to a depth of 5m, while other studies have seen that the plastics disperse to depths of at least 100m.
- skrebbel 8y ago"amount of pieces" is a terrible way to measure garbage though.
- manicdee 8y agoDistribution of piece sizes is pertinent when selecting a technology for cleaning up the mess.
- rizzom5000 8y agoThese are all good points, but considering that humans are already ingesting microplastics found in seafood and rice, at least someone is trying to do something about the problem. Beach cleanup does not help solve this. It may already be too late due to the incredible amount of microplastics already in the Earth's major bodies of water and the fact that science doesn't know how much it will impact the ecosystem or create/exacerbate human medical problems.
- mreome 8y ago... at least someone is trying to do something about the problem ... I really can not fathom this sentiment, which seems to be the primary counter-argument to virtually all criticism of this project (as well as to criticisms of many other pie in the sky solutions to major issues). There are countless people who have devoted their lives to studying ocean eco-systems, safeguarding the nature, and understanding our impact on the environment. Many who have been trumpeting the problem of ocean plastics decades before it became a pop-issue. There are also millions of people, and billions of dollars worth of industry that is dependent on a healthy ocean eco-system. Do you really believe that nobody else is trying to take action on this issue? Or could it be that people who have devoted lifetimes to understanding the reality of this issue and the engineering requirements and impact of large scale ocean structures have done the risk assessment and realized that this kind of approach is not viable? The people who understand the problem have a solution, which is unfortunately the only viable one: The reduction of single use plastic products, more effective recycling and waste disposable programs, and a general reassessment of the volume of, and manner in which, we use plastics. But people want a magic pill that doesn't require them to accept that they are a part of the cause of ecological issues like this, and the only solution is for us, as a society, to change some of the aspects of our day-to-day lives. So they happily ignore the real solutions, click "Like" on posts that say their going to solve the world's problems, and berate entire fields worth of scientists, engineers, and ecologists for not "doing something about the problems".
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 8y ago
- stephengillie 8y agoThen what's the point?
- Mizza 8y agoThis is a bad article (as if being a listicle didn't give that away). Number 6 is "it's far more efficient, cheaper, and safer to keep the plastic out of the ocean in the first place", which is like saying that the best way to clean dog poop off of your carpet is to not have a dog. It's too late for that, investing in clean-up in _addition to_ prevention HAS to be a top priority for us. In fact, this is in the form of BECCS is the very basis of the Paris Climate Accords. Investing in prevention won't undo the damage that's been done, and a lot of environmental groups who only promote prevention (like those cited in your article) are doing more harm than good.
- mreome 8y agoThe article was not arguing for inaction, it was arguing that this particular solution is not viable and could cause more harm then good. Both due to negative environmental impacts and diverting funds and attention from more workable and effective solutions. Yes, we need to figure out how to clean up the plastics that are there, but more importantly, we need to stop adding more and more every day. ... which is like saying that the best way to clean dog poop off of your carpet is to not have a dog ... I would argue the analogy is more "the best way to clean dog poop off of your carpet is to train your dog not to shit on your carpet." Yeah, there is still a shit stain we have to clean up, but we can't rent a steam-cleaner every time he needs to take a crap, and if we try to clean it up with a vacuum, it's going to make everything much worse.
- jlmorton 8y ago> I would argue the analogy is more "the best way to clean dog poop off of your carpet is to train your dog not to shit on your carpet." Well, I would argue this analogy is also rather inapt. Much better would be training your 7.5 billion dogs not to shit on your carpet. Until most of those dogs are trained, it makes sense to search for tools to clean up the poop. We haven't yet extensively tested the vacuum cleaner, and it's not clear how effective it will be, or whether it might make the situation worse.
- mreome 8y ago