5 ms·
The Ocean Cleanup Is Starting
- toomuchtodo 8y agoStill need to implement effective waste management systems at its source, but progress is progress. > Roughly eight million tons of plastic enters the ocean every year. That’s according to a 2015 report, which also identified where the bulk of this trash originates. At the top of the list: China, the Philippines, and Indonesia. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2017/04/explore-garbage-wave/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2017/04/explore-...
- quotemstr 8y agoDo we need to address waste at the source? Sources are diffuse, innumerable, and spread among different jurisdictions with different levels of commitment to environmental stewardship. I'm skeptical of our ability to stem pollutants at the source. There's a certain attraction to centralized cleanup efforts substituting for this near-impossible task of enforcing source standards worldwide. While it's theoretically less efficient to pollute and then clean it up, this model may have the advantage of actually working.
- mreome 8y agoThe plastics are diffused, innumerable, and spread through-out the ecosystem in varying environmental conditions where solutions will have varying effectiveness and possible negative impacts on wildlife. I'm skeptical of our ability to implement a large-scale collection effort that will collect a meaningful percentage of the waste, with a further concern that a poorly implemented solution may in fact add to the waste and/or impact the environment in ways just as damaging as the pollutants it does remove. Yes, enforcing standards worldwide is a "near-impossible" task. But cleaning up waste at the scales we're talking about, after it's entered the ecosystem, is impossible. There is no magic bullet here, and the more people who ignore what has to be done to fix the problem, hoping projects like this will make it better, the worse it will get.
- quotemstr 8y ago> cleaning up waste at the scales we're talking about, after it's entered the ecosystem, is impossible. That's a very strong claim, especially attached to an article about cleanup mechanisms. Are you sure some kind of synthetic biology mechanism couldn't work? Waste removal (be it carbon or plastic) is an engineering problem; source regulation is a political problem, and political problems tend to remain unsolved until it is impossible that they remain unsolved.
- toomuchtodo 8y ago> Waste removal (be it carbon or plastic) is an engineering problem; source regulation is a political problem, and political problems tend to remain unsolved until it is impossible that they remain unsolved. Then move the plastic collection to the mouth of the 10 rivers in south east asia where the plastic is being emitted from.
- quotemstr 8y agoThat would be a good start.
- mreome 8y agoI would enthusiastically support research and testing on this solution. Many of the objections to clean-up in the open-ocean are not relevant here. The depths are very restricted, the ecosystems are more limited, the weather conditions less extreme and less variable, the plastics should be less broken down. The impacts and infrastructure would be similar to, and on the scale of, projects such as locks and dams. I would see this as a first step to source control. Looking at collected materials, it would become quickly obvious where the major sources of the plastics are, and they could start being addressed. There is a social issue here too though. I would expect this kind of project would be resisted in the same way that more local clean-up and source-control efforts in those regions are already resisted. Edit: There is also the issue that a sizable portion of the ocean plastics seem to be from discarded/lost fishing equipment.
- toast0 8y agoIt really depends on the cost benefit analysis. If we can convince the largest polluters to reduce their pollution levels to bellow what can be removed via beach cleanups (which are relatively low effort), eventually that gets a clean enough ocean. Framing the issue is important. Yes, the environment is all good, but what the polluting nations will gain from reducing their pollution needs to be highlighted. Less plastic in rivers probably requires less plastic on streets which probably requires better sanitary conditions in general which means healthier workers and higher productivity. Cleaner air means less breathing problems means healthier workers and higher productivity, etc. Eventually, people might notice the nicer environment and develop that as a cultural goal in itself, as the US eventually did after getting tired of rivers catching on fire, but emphasizing worker productivity is probably a quicker way to get developing countries on board. Something about healthy oceans = more protein from the sea should help a bit too.
- henrikberggren 8y agoA huge fan of Boyan and TOC!
- ummonk 8y agoAnd it will harm ocean wildlife more than it will help... https://www.kcet.org/redefine/6-reasons-that-floating-ocean-plastic-cleanup-gizmo-is-a-horrible-idea https://www.kcet.org/redefine/6-reasons-that-floating-ocean-...
- mirimir 8y agoIt seems that there's a key point of contention. That link claims: > But the vast majority of plastic in the ocean is made up of particles one centimeter and smaller, remnants of larger pieces broken up by ultraviolet light, the corrosive effects of seawater, and physical abuse from wave action and marine creatures. But the posted article claims instead: > "Research shows the majority of plastic by mass is currently in the larger debris," as noted on The Ocean Cleanup website. "By removing the plastic while most of it is still large, we prevent it from breaking down into dangerous microplastics" that can absorb toxic substances and travel up the food chain. So which is it? And even if the claim that "the majority of plastic by mass is currently in the larger debris" is wrong, because they didn't sample deeply enough, doesn't the argument that "removing the plastic while most of it is still large, we prevent it from breaking down into dangerous microplastics" remain valid? The risk of structural failures generating more debris, and problems with anti-fouling treatments, seem manageable through good maintenance. Or better design. But then, what to do with the debris collected? Recycling per se does seem hopeless. I mean, we aren't even recycling much regular plastic waste, because it's mixed and contaminated. But maybe just crack it down to simple hydrocarbons, and make sure to capture the metals and halogens.
- roberto 8y agoThis effort is just a stunt: http://www.deepseanews.com/2017/01/what-did-the-boyan-slat-and-the-ocean-cleanup-do-last-summer/ http://www.deepseanews.com/2017/01/what-did-the-boyan-slat-a...
- mrlinx 8y agothat's old, and already covered at length. check this if you're interested: https://www.theoceancleanup.com/updates/a-peculiar-survey/ https://www.theoceancleanup.com/updates/a-peculiar-survey/ https://www.theoceancleanup.com/updates/environmental-impact-assessment-available/ https://www.theoceancleanup.com/updates/environmental-impact...
- gammatrigono 8y agoThe Pacific Ocean has a way of destroying dreams that few today have experienced. I'm rooting for TOC to succeed, but I'm not optimistic.
- dwighttk 8y ago> the organization plans to continue operations with help from the proceeds of recycled plastic. That's not going to work. The proceeds from recycling the plastic aren't even going to pay for recycling the plastic.
- mreome 8y agoWorse, they will be paying to recycle (dispose of) it. Right now there are major issues and limitations in the processing of even the generally clean/sorted and re-usable plastics from residential collection. Some recycling facilities are being forced to simply dispose of even these materials as they would any other waste. (https://phys.org/news/2018-07-trash-piles-china-door-recycling.html https://phys.org/news/2018-07-trash-piles-china-door-recycli...) What they are collecting is partially broken down by ocean salts and UV light, and has absorbed contaminants (a lot of these plastics are actually from fishing equipment, but the post-consumer component largely enters the ocean via some exceptionally polluted river systems). These are going to be small and unmarked plastic pieces, you would need spectrographic analysis on each piece to determine the type of plastic before it could be recycled.
- skybrian 8y agoI think the idea might be to sell souvenirs to support the cause, not bulk plastic.
- mreome 8y agoThat would still be very difficult. You have to know what kind of plastic you have before you can work with it, some plastics off-gas dangerous vapors when cut for example, and they would need to test for chemical contamination before it could be distributed. Also, how many thousands of tones of souvenirs can someone sell? :P
- taysic 8y agoSometimes people are motivated are pay a premium if they feel the cause is good (it can be marketed on the product). In this case, how much would the difference be?
- 8y ago
- notnot 8y agoDoesn't plastic, especially white shopping-bag plastic, reflect more solar radiation than open ocean? Wouldn't covering a large portion of the earth with white plastic actually lower global temperatures? I saw a video where an open water reservoir was covered with floating plastic balls to reduce evaporation. Maybe a large plastic island would help fight global warming.
- whatshisface 8y agoThe Garbage Patch isn't a floating island, it's a region where microscopic particles of garbage are more common per cubic meter of water than usual.
- mreome 8y agoIn theory, yes. But it would also destroy all ocean life, with perhaps the very tiny exception of the ecosystems around deep-ocean thermal vents. But, as another post has explained that this isn't what the ocean-plastics are. They would be better described as a thin soup, or cloud, of tiny plastic particles dispersed over hundreds of thousands of square kilometers of ocean, down to depths of up to 100m.
- singularity2001 8y agotechnically true but still a horrible idea
- always_good 8y agoYou could've perfected this comment if you mentioned that you toss your own shopping bags into the ocean to fight global warming.
- newnewpdro 8y agoThis is a waste of time and resources. The most likely to succeed solution to the ocean plastic problem is genetic engineering. Develop a lifeform that lives in the sea and feeds on plastic, introduce it to the oceans.
- robbiep 8y agoThat’s great until it starts feeding on every plastic item in our modern world
- michelb 8y agoOr develop a lifeform that stops polluting and respects the environment it lives in. :)
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoIsn't one of the problems that this stuff already ends up in the food chain. If it just fell to the bottom of the ocean and was buried under sediment we probably wouldn't care that much.
- rottenjc 8y agoThey should do this in rivers, near the end before it goes in the oceans or seas. Getting partnerships with local and national governments to do this would be easier than asking for charity. This made me think of the trash often visible on a river shores because it is caught by tree branches. I wonder if beavers dams can be used for that to ?
- eddyg 8y agoKinda like the Mr. Trash Wheel in Baltimore? http://baltimorewaterfront.com/healthy-harbor/water-wheel/ http://baltimorewaterfront.com/healthy-harbor/water-wheel/
- Mizza 8y agoThere are a lot of comments in this thread shitting on this project for not doing their cleanup at the rivers, but failing to realize that that reason we've identified those rivers as the source of ocean plastic is because of The Ocean Cleanup project's paper in Nature Communications: https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15611 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15611
- clay_the_ripper 8y agoIt seems like a lot of comments are debating the relative merits of which solution will work, whether this is the right solution, pointing out this doesn’t address the entire problem et al. What about AND? work on reducing plastic waste AND try to get it out of the water. Deploy this solution, try it AND iterate on it. Do this AND the next idea AND the next. Keep trying things until you find the right solution. It seems to me that this project does a lot more good than harm, even if it doesn’t work, it paves the way for solutions that might. The amount of naysaying and nitpicking here is depressing. Is it perfect? No. Does it address every problem? No. Is it a start? Yes. How many times has the right solution been the first thing someone tried? Rarely. But you keep trying stuff until you find something that works. At least this guy is DOING something rather than endlessly debating how to fix it. It’s easy to be an armchair engineer saying you could dream up 10 better solutions. Well great, go do it then. Props to this kid and his organization for taking action on a problem to try and do some good in the world.
- Maxion 8y agoNot to mention that this project brings additional attention to the problem. The more attention there is the more likely it is that politicians will take up the matter and strive for a political solution to the source problem. And even if that doesn't happen, getting rid of even a small amount of pollutants from the ocean can't be a bad thing, can it?
- monk_e_boy 8y agoI live on a peninsula and our beaches are covered in plastic. Over the last couple of years people litter pick most weekends, but to me it is hopeless. There is so much. You could spend ten thousand man hours a day cleaning and on the next tide the beach would be full again. Its just crazy how much crap there is in the ocean. Imagine how much plastic is in one garbage truck, now chop it up into small, 5cm bits. Now spread it across a beach, try to pick that up. It takes all day. We need machines to help us.
- mikekchar 8y ago
- mockingbirdy 8y agoBoyan Slat was 19 years old when he started this project. He raised over $2 mio. for this project and worked with his university to make it happen. I think he's a great role model for young people. We need more young people like him who try to find solutions for the pressing problems of the 21st century. There are some people who dismiss the Millennials, but it's clear to see that many of them want to have a positive impact and prefer a meaningful life over hedonism. I hope the project works out, but even if it won't work, the signal he's sending is very empowering.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ensiferum 8y agoThe Forbes page wants me to accept their advertising cookies. When i click "no thanks" and select the "only required cookies" and hit apply the "preferences submission process" either jaks at ~90% or if it goes through then the site renders a white page. Anyone else experiencing the same?
- 0xbs 8y agoThis is most likely because of your ad blocker. The page tries to set opt-out cookies which are blocked by the ad blocker.