4 ms·
These are all outdated already. Serverless is a meaningless term. The real name is platform-as-a-service, which is decades old. Running individual functions wa
by manigandham 8y ago
These are all outdated already.
Serverless is a meaningless term. The real name is platform-as-a-service, which is decades old. Running individual functions was just taking that to an extreme but any complex app will have multiple functions working together so it's right back to the same thing.
Many "serverless" environments are in fact converting to running an arbitrary docker container for as long as it needs to run, effectively becoming the next-generation of PaaS where you container can be whatever size you need, while still not worrying about infrastructure and individual servers.
- a_silly_name 8y agoI'd appreciate it if others could chime in on this one. I'm mystified by the word 'serverless'. Why are we using this word? There are clearly, _quite clearly_ servers involved. The wacky bugs involved in these 'server-less' services... are going to come down to what's happening on the servers involved. EDIT: my question seems to have offended. Unfortunate, and unintentional!
- grzm 8y agoServerless refers to you administering the application and its resources but not the server directly. Yes, at some level servers are involved, but generally the organization deploying applications is not responsible for administering the hardware, the OS, other resources, often including the scaling of the server resources: they're only concerned with the administration of the application. One can argue that at some level the organization deploying the application is often still concerned with the underlying server and where that line is drawn, but many find it meaningful to make such a distinction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serverless_computing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serverless_computing
- a_silly_name 8y agoDoes make sense, but your description (and others) seems to match most vendors API out there today. It's not clear to me what 'serverless' means vs 'hosted / managed infrastructure', or even 'external API'. It doesn't seem like a technical term at all. Another commenter mentioned that it applies only to the price list, and that makes sense to me.
- collyw 8y agoThe pricing model is the only thing that seems to be serverless as far as I can tell.
- a_silly_name 8y agoI'm going with this for now, thank you! Serverless... pricing models. The pricing models are just silent.
- scarface74 8y agoWhy do people keep posting this as if they are educating the masses who think when you refer to “Serverless” people think your code is being run by a bunch of leprechauns. Everyone in the industry knows in context what Serverless means.
- a_silly_name 8y ago> Everyone in the industry knows in context what Serverless means. I don't. Divorced from the context of a very specific vendor offering, serverless could mean almost anything. There are many applications, services, and platforms out there that don't require customers to manage their own servers. Now if we're talking about Amazon or Google's specific things that have the marketing term 'serverless' applied... then many (but not everyone) can start getting specific (like in this posted article). EDIT: I think another interesting question might be why so many people react defensively when this misnomer is criticized
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- grzm 8y agoLikely because it's a pedantic, often futile discussion. Language and communication is descriptive, not prescriptive. Repeatedly trying to convince people that they're using words incorrectly when they are using them to effectively communicate gets very old. If you chose to use other words, by all means do so, but understand it may get in the way of communication, and that communication involves all parties. There are many words in all languages that when viewed from certain perspectives don't seem accurate. People drive on parkways and park in driveways. Going around in circles like this amounts to trolling.
- a_silly_name 8y agoYou're right about the way language works, but how to probe the usage of a neologism like this without discussing (criticizing) the word? 'trolling' makes it sound like critics are acting in bad faith. : (