3 ms·
My personal anecdote here. I recently started eating dinner only and shooting for a 16 hour fast daily with only coffee, tea or water during the day. I haven't
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
My personal anecdote here. I recently started eating dinner only and shooting for a 16 hour fast daily with only coffee, tea or water during the day.
I haven't noticed a real drop in energy, however I have noticed significant brain fog, lightheadedness and irritability in the afternoon. I also have significant feelings of hunger all day, to the point where it's distracting.
I realized I needed to be adding some kind of salt to my intake during the day to prevent the lightheadedness. The only zero calorie solution is basically adding basic electrolyte to my water, which means I end up drinking a weak salt brine most of the day which is not very pleasant.
I'm not sure if this is sustainable because it takes up so much of my mental energy. There doesn't seem to be much in the way of good resource for doing this kind of diet, so I'm excited to see what comes out in the next few years. Perhaps it's just a transition period and it will work out.
- mooreds 8y agoWhat timeframe do you mean by "recently"?
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI started the Dinner only schedule about two weeks ago. For July I was doing a once weekly 24 hour fast which was terrible in it's own way.
- ekianjo 8y agoTwo weeks is too recent. After a few months you would not notice a difference vs before.
- mooreds 8y agoAh. I had a coworker who did some intermittent fasting, but she said she was cranky for a few days and then got into a groove.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI don’t know if this relates but I switched to a low carb diet a month ago (no fasting) and the first 2-3 weeks were terrible. I felt noticeably more depressed and my wife noticed it too. She recommended stopping the diet but I kept on and added electrolyte water. After adding electrolytes, I feel as good as ever. I started working out more and have lost 15 lbs but plateaued since. I want to try the fasting diet described in the article with no breakfast and no lunch but I am not sure if I’ll be able to. Since I do not eat carbs at dinner, often I’ll feel hungry around 9pm and it feels like an eternity to breakfast if I don’t go to bed soon there after. I can’t imagine skipping breakfast AND lunch on this type of routine without adding back the carbs. Anyway, I guess my point is that it gets better as you follow whatever diet you embarked on.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jtr_47 8y agoMy personal experience is as follows: 1. Eat meals, breakfast, lunch and a light dinner - end at 4pm.. You begin your fasting after this - no eating or snacking after you have dinner. YOu should eat breakfast around 8am the next day - so between 4pm to 8am, this is when you are fasting.. that's why they call breakfast - BREAK the FAST. You can do this every day. Not sure if this is helping my stage 4 colon cancer, but it's doable :) Peace
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoIf I do that sort of eating schedule, I'm miserable. Absolutely miserable. I wind up so hungry in the evening that I can't help but to eat. I can't concentrate on things that aren't food. I tend to overeat and on occasion, binge on a lot of food at once. This is especially so when hormones are fluctuating (i'm female). I tend to gain weight eating like this. It truly isn't worth it. However, if I eat most of my food later in the day, I'm fine. I skip breakfast. I sometimes eat lunch or a snack - cold food, something like a piece of bread with cheese or something. If I'm a little hungry later, I might eat a few nuts. I eat a hearty dinner, and eat until I'm happily full. Sometimes I have an after dinner snack. I eat chocolate and candy sparingly as I want it. The main change with hormone fluctuations is that I tend to eat more snacks (but less food at dinner). I'm mostly vegetarian with a bit of fish. Unlike the schedule you describe, I'm not miserable this way. I don't think about food all day and I do not tend to overeat. I can control my weight pretty easily and generally always have being full to look forwards to. Warding off hunger until later is so much different than having to go without until tomorrow. I understand it probably works well for you: My mother is much the same way with her eating. But folks are wired a bit differently (including their insulin responses to different foods) and adjusting such things makes sense.
- extr 8y agoYou do a 16 hour fast, but only eat dinner? When are you eating your other food/meal? I do a similar length fast most weekdays, I just don't like eating soon after waking up so I only have water/black coffee until lunch. But I have a BIG lunch (1200-1600+ cal) and then something else around 7-8 or occasionally skip dinner. I think it's much easier to deal with not having eaten for awhile during the evening, you're usually doing something low-energy by then and if you start getting really hungry you can just go to sleep.
- AndrewKemendo 8y ago16 hours is the minimum. No other meal, but I may snack later in the evening depending on what was for dinner. Anywhere from 12-2AM until 5-7PM is my fast period. Yesterday for example, I didn't eat after 1 am but dinner was around 7PM so the fast was about 18 hours that day. Today I didn't eat after 1230 last night but dinner was at 5, so 16 1/2 hours. I'm the opposite actually, I geared my eating to be in the evening as I stay up late. I know I can distract myself with work or kids etc... during the day, but night is where I would naturally eat/graze anyway, so might as well just move my whole eating period to then.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoBlack coffee breaks your fasting cycle.
- firasd 8y agoI think for IF you'd want to be fat-adapted/low-carb. I don't know what IF practitioners recommend in general, but I don't think feeling hungry all day is 'doing it right'.