12 ms·
I hadn't realized until recently how India is so much like China regarding surveillance and social control. I guess that it reflects how biased against China I'
by mirimir 8y ago
I hadn't realized until recently how India is so much like China regarding surveillance and social control. I guess that it reflects how biased against China I've been.
When I've read about the Chinese government's concerns over social unrest, I've empathized with the dissidents. I mean, Tibet and Xinjiang are occupied nations! But I get that China is an extremely diverse country, overall, with lots of ethnic tension.
And conversely, when I've read about the Indian government's concerns over social unrest, I've empathized with the victims of the dissidents. Muslims persecuted by Hindus. Women persecuted by misogynists.
So damn, it's a hard problem. And worse, with increased migration driven by social chaos and war (and eventually, by global climate change), it's becoming an issue in many places. Including the US, where I happen to live.
- coldtea 8y ago>I mean, Tibet and Xinjiang are occupied nations! Would you say that for Puerto Rico? Or California and Texas for that matter? Or how about Hawaii? Or, heck, anything that's not an Indian reservation... Or does it only apply to China's neighbors, with which they had millennia of history with rulers and populations going back and forth? E.g. the Qing Chinese ruled Tiber as far back as the 17th century...
- jrockway 8y agoI'm not sure that's entirely true. The geography of Tibet has always made it difficult to rule from afar. Hence, stronger control enabled by new technology seem different than what existed in the past. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECch2g1_6PQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECch2g1_6PQ
- mirimir 8y agoYes, I would. I have friends in Mexico who think of the Southwest and California as occupied territory. And yeah, the Native Americans totally got screwed. You're correct in pointing out anti-Chinese bias. As you say, there's a long back-and-forth history. And Tibet wasn't such an idyllic place before the latest Chinese occupation. As I understand it, it was basically a theocracy. Maybe even repressive, but with effective programming.
- housingpost 8y agoCan any of the places in china even discuss independence in the open? Well, every place in the US can. They even can leave if they get enough votes. Go ahead and let me know when anyone in China gets to vote on anything.
- notashill144 8y agoThe last time US states tried to secede from the Union it resulted in one of the bloodiest wars in US history where they were forcefully reintegrated.
- coldtea 8y ago>Can any of the places in china even discuss independence in the open? Well, every place in the US can Only when there's no real prospect of it, and as long as such discussion remains a fringe activity that gets lost in the media noise. Oh, and as long as those discussing it are white, and not e.g. native american, or latinos, and such. There's a long history, from this: "In the mid-century, the "Cointelpro program" was a project conducted by the United States Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to surveil, infiltrate, discredit, and disrupt domestic political organizations which it classified as suspect or subversive. The police documented thousands of extensive carpetas (files) concerning individuals of all social groups and ages. Approximately 75,000 persons were listed as under political police surveillance. Historians and critics found that the massive surveillance apparatus was directed primarily against Puerto Rico's independence movement." (wikipedia) to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wounded_Knee_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wounded_Knee_Massacre that suggests that they can't really discuss it that openly. This didn't go down very well either: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederate_States_of_America https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederate_States_of_America
- mirimir 8y agoAnyone remember "U.S. Out of North America Now!"?
- chiph 8y agoSomething to consider is that Indian states were set up along linguistic and cultural boundaries. The national government takes a dim view of anything that would allow dissidents to get a strong foothold within the country.
- mirimir 8y agoTrue. And not just Indian states. Indian villages, from what I've read. Edit: Again, I'm doing my best to avoid being racist or whatever. It's just mind-boggling how diverse India is. It's like thousands of cultures have been shredded and displaced for thousands of years. And somehow remained incredibly distinct and segregated.
- throwaway6789 8y ago>And worse, with increased migration driven by social chaos and war (and eventually, by global climate change) What if US will also be affected badly by global climate change? Then these "uncivilized" people won't be coming to your country.
- mirimir 8y agoTrue enough, eventually. Watch out, Canada ;) But first, there will be maybe a billion coming north. And there will very likely be concentration camps. Edit: Also, please don't read my comment as being anti-immigrant. What concerns me is the likely authoritarian response from US governments. And I'm concerned both for them, and for me.
- naravara 8y ago>When I've read about the Chinese government's concerns over social unrest, I've empathized with the dissidents. I mean, Tibet and Xinjiang are occupied nations! But I get that China is an extremely diverse country, overall, with lots of ethnic tension. And conversely, when I've read about the Indian government's concerns over social unrest, I've empathized with the victims of the dissidents. Muslims persecuted by Hindus. Women persecuted by misogynists. Free press is a hell of a thing. It plays a big role in where your sympathies will end up.
- volgo 8y agoWhy do you view those as occupied nations? What about Hawaii, Alaska, Guam, and Puerto Rico?
- housingpost 8y agoWell the people in those places are allowed to openly talk about and pursue independence, unlike any place in China at all. Why don't you view Tibet as occupied?
- volgo 8y agoLol so the bar is asking for independence? Native Americans no longer advocate independence because they've been suppressed for for several generations, they're culture are effectively dead. Same thing will probably happen in China in 50-100 years
- mirimir 8y agoNot to mention that most of them died from diseases spread (mostly unintentionally, I admit) by invaders. Also, it's my understanding that China and Israel both justify their behavior from US history.
- int_19h 8y agoThe bar is whether those occupied consider themselves occupied. Referendums and similar allow to measure that. It's pretty clear that Tibet considers itself occupied. I know that some in Hawaii do, but do you think they're the majority?
- volgo 8y agoBarcelona
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- eklavya 8y agoYou have got to be kidding me. There is just no comparison between India and China in freedom of anything. I am sick of people painting India as some bad place where minorities and women are treated badly. Sure we have problems but this narrative of the persecution needs to stop. Give me one country where women are safe. Next compare per capita crime towards women with the top countries in the world and we can have a conversation. Incidents with minority get all the press. The ground reality is more two way. I remember the whole town being shut down for Muslim processions because who would risk angering the mob? My muslim brothers and sisters generally have a much better status and bonding in India than at least in the US. I am willing to answer, please ask away.
- mirimir 8y agoI get that China and India aren't comparable. China is far^N more locked down. But there are multiple references in the article about learning from China about surveillance and social control. So if I lived in India, I'd be worried. And damn, I live in the US, and I'm worried.
- eklavya 8y agoI was worried too but the whole net neutrality fight has been an eye opener. Our generation can be relied to rally upon when push comes to shove.
- freddie_mercury 8y agoAccording to the OECD, 37% of women in India report violence against them at some point in their lifetime. In Switzerland it is 10%. In Japan it is 15%.
- eklavya 8y agoCan you please share the link? I am on mobile.
- eklavya 8y agoAccording to https://www.wonderslist.com/10-countries-highest-rape-crime/ https://www.wonderslist.com/10-countries-highest-rape-crime/ India is after US and Sweden. I am using DuckDuckGo and this was the third link in search results on crime against women. I will look up the OECD stats as well.
- mirimir 8y agoOK, some belated edits. I didn't really mean to say "how India is so much like China regarding surveillance and social control". It's obviously not. What I was trying to say is how India is so much like China regarding the arguments for surveillance and social control. I mean, what would China look like now without so much surveillance and social control? Would it in fact look a lot like India? If so, The Chinese government has clearly gone too far. But maybe it would look more like total chaos. In which case their policies, though repugnant to the liberal West, might be prudent. I honestly have no clue. But it's not a possibility that can be rejected out of hand, I think.
- phobosdeimos 8y ago"I mean, what would China look like now without so much surveillance and social control" Chinese history offers a good hint. Whenever the central government was weak anarchy, war, pestilence and starvation plagued the land.
- 154789652 8y ago> Muslims persecuted by Hindus. Actually Hindus have been persecuted a lot by Muslims. In Kashmir all the Hindus were driven away[1]. Very few Hindus are left in Pakistan and Bangladesh whereas the proportion of Muslims in India is going up since independence. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exodus_of_Kashmiri_Hindus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exodus_of_Kashmiri_Hindus
- nojvek 8y agoAnd that is somewhat a good thing. Diversity of thoughts makes up for a good country. Shows up in the GDP. India is far ahead of both Pakistan and Bangladesh. Very few nations have done well after rampaging on an ethnic cleansing agenda.
- naeemtee 8y ago> And that is somewhat a good thing. Diversity of thoughts makes up for a good country. Shows up in the GDP. India is far ahead of both Pakistan and Bangladesh. This argument is ludicrous. India isn't ahead of Pakistan and Bangladesh because of "diversity of thought". That's so reductionist I'm frankly astounded.
- boomboomsubban 8y agoIt's wrong to force people from their homes, but over this same period the predominantly Hindu Indian army has killed tens of thousands of Kashmir Muslims. It's hard to see how saying "actually the Hindus are the persecuted" is a fair assessment.
- iamshs 8y agoAnd let’s not forget the 2002 anti-Muslim pogrom in Gujarat. Also, the Babri Mosque demolition. Indian Army has absolutely brutalized the local populace in Kashmir, and worse they are under state protection such that no criminal action can be taken against them due to a draconian law called AFSPA. Normal democratic rights of these citizens have been suspended there. And all people see is religious divide but no empathy towards the brutalized population.
- tluyben2 8y agoAs we seem to be comparing India and China as non natives of either; I visit both China and India a lot (over 10x a year for both, India Jaipur, Delhi and Mumbai) and although I know China is worse (as a surveillance/free country), India feels far worse. It is, for me, the worst country to travel to and work in. It feels like a bad police state; terrorists have won as they (the gov) locked things down and freedom of movement is restricted to the point I would not mind never going there again.
- vinay427 8y agoCan you provide some examples? The only ones I can recall for physical freedom are mostly by private entities, such as metal detectors at movie theaters and banks, though the armed military (?) outside airport entrances are obviously not. Fraud/corruption/money laundering prevention regulations are definitely an incredible hindrance to opening and keeping a bank account in India, however.
- tluyben2 8y agoThe metal detectors and bag inspections are everywhere; supermarkets, malls, hotels and every time you enter even if it is the hotel you stay in all the time for months. Most businesses have guards with guns (rifles often) outside the entrance as well as bag scanners and bag checkers/friskers. Small and big airports where you can be checked and scanned 3-4 times from entrance to flight. And flying into an airport they check again. And not by friendly people either (contrary to China strangely where border patrol often have a little friendly chat to practice their english; had my bag checked 0 times coming in). Cannot enter an airport before a few hours before your flight even if you have lounge access. Guard said ‘terrorism’ when I asked why (for the umpteenth time as they usually do not answer). And yes, my friends with businesses who live there complain about the corruption restrictions. But I think that part goes for China as well. Edit; as I hear from my friends, it all got really bad only like 5 years ago. I did not go then; I have been going for 3.
- intended 8y agoI think that tracked with the pakistani attack on mumbai, where they specifically targeted hotels and other soft targets. India has had a lot of terrorist attacks on its soil over the past 40 years. I know of at least 5 major attacks in mumbai alone. That said, after the TSA was created, flying in America became a pain.
- throw2016 8y agoThis seems to be a dissonance and blindness that allows some to more easily form negative opinions of others while seemingly blind to the surveillance and other situations closer home. This kind of dissonance lulls one into complacency and prevents effective dissent against growing surveillance states and blindness to other problematic issues like demonizing dissent and continuing discrimination against minorities. One can argue the Snowden revelations, secret courts, secret orders and processes exposed far greater magnitude of surveillance and threats to democracy at home - with no one held to account years later - with the scope and magnitude expanding unopposed. The complete lack of mainstream activism, protests, any efforts to hold people accountable or get people like Assange and Snowden back home makes comments against China untenable. Without that, commentary about China seems mere posturing and hypocrisy than borne out of any real concern about the issues at hand.
- n_t 8y ago>> I hadn't realized until recently how India is so much like China regarding surveillance and social control There is no comparison whatsoever. China has iron clench on its citizens, particularly over net. India has next to zero surveillance. >> Muslims persecuted by Hindus. Women persecuted by misogynists. This is patently BS! Please stop regurgitating this narrative! India has second largest Muslim population in the world, Hindus population has been steadily dropping while Muslims population has been increasing. There have been multiple muslim Presidents, Vice-Presidents, Chief Ministers. Infact, India's most of political parties have been accused of favoring Muslim population. India's most famous movie actors are Muslims, many cricketers (India's real religion) are muslims. Wipro and many other successful software companies are owned by Muslim. Had there been persecutions of any sort, there would have been hardly any such examples. So, please stop this BS! Most of such news are blown out of proportion by vested interests, particularly those who look for help from outside India. If you talk to an average Muslim, they would be much happier to live in India than in any of its neighboring states.
- BeetleB 8y ago>Hindus population has been steadily dropping while Muslims population has been increasing. There have been multiple muslim Presidents, Vice-Presidents, Chief Ministers. Infact, India's most of political parties have been accused of favoring Muslim population. India's most famous movie actors are Muslims, many cricketers (India's real religion) are muslims. Wipro and many other successful software companies are owned by Muslim. Had there been persecutions of any sort, there would have been hardly any such examples. In the US, the white population has been steadily dropping while the black population has been increasing. We have had one black president, and several black members in Congress. In fact, one of the two major political parties in the US is often accused of favoring black people. Many of the US's most famous actors and actresses are black. Many of the top sports personalities are black. Had there been any persecution of any sort, there would hardly be such examples. Whatever the situation is in India, I don't know. But your line of reasoning does not shed any light on the matter.
- nv-vn 8y agoTo be fair to the GP, none of those would really be possible in 1960s America or under Apartheid. I think there's some middle ground between both views of India here.