4 ms·
Ok, having finished both articles, a few thoughts from somebody who has been involved for years in the subsidized prediction service Long Bets: http://longbets.
by wpietri 8y ago
Ok, having finished both articles, a few thoughts from somebody who has been involved for years in the subsidized prediction service Long Bets: http://longbets.org/ http://longbets.org/
Broadly, I think he's right. Subsidized prediction contexts could provide real social benefit. It can force a lot of attention and thought around topics that don't get enough consideration. I would love to see, for example, a bunch of VCs covering the costs on a prediction market for the tech sector. Have a bunch of standard running questions, and let the VCs ask any question they want.
I think he is 100% correct that having well-defined bets is hugely important. We got our initial bets by careful, personal assistance to get people with contradictory opinions to agree on clear, testable criteria. We thought once we got going people would just do that on their own, and we were wrong. Sometimes it happens, but pretty rarely.
I wonder about the extent to which his emphasis on speed is about a particular kind of participant (e.g., sports gamblers and day traders). Most of the people I know who invest work at the months-to-years timescale, so I suspect there's an untapped cognitive surplus from people like that which could be applied to longer-term questions.
I also think his notion of subsidizing market makers (who are obliged to provide liquidity) is a good one. I used to work for a market-maker and it was not a bad business to be in. His no-fees market makes that trickier, but I don't think it's unresolvable.
One subsidy option that I'm surprised is not here: guarantee a minimum purse for people on the winning side of a question. Somebody is going to show up to try to get the free money. And then somebody smarter is going to say, "I'd bet I can get a piece of that." I know it wouldn't take much for me to place some bets on some current hot issues. E.g., blockchains, Bitcoin, Uber, scooters, VR, AR.
- skybrian 8y agoI think it might be less an emphasis on speed and more about whether you are interested in making money (or at least the logic of making money), and therefore compare bets with alternative investments. Serious gamblers are at least going to compare with alternative bets, and being able to place more bets over a year with the same bankroll is an advantage if you have an edge. More broadly, if you squint a bit, the stock market looks like a betting market that's subsidized by company profits. It would take quite a bit of subsidy to compete with that. I suppose cryptocoin shows that people will bet in unsubsidized markets, if part of the bet is whether they will later be subsidized and to what level. Edit: it seems the URL changed and we are responding to different articles.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> Serious gamblers are at least going to compare with alternative bets, and being able to place more bets over a year with the same bankroll is an advantage if you have an edge. This is only true under one of two assumptions: 1. Your edge on the long bet is numerically similar to your edge on the short bet, such that making more bets means getting more money overall. 2. You're looking to stabilize your earnings by placing a large number of bets, even at the cost of lower expected gain. There's no reason winning more bets automatically means more money. The longer bet might have longer odds.
- skybrian 8y agoIt certainly could be, but the longer bet needs to pay off more, to account for the money being locked up longer. Or to put it another way, to compare bets that pay off at different times, you would need to calculate the present value of each payoff using some sort of discount rate: https://www.investopedia.com/walkthrough/corporate-finance/3/time-value-money/present-value-discounting.aspx https://www.investopedia.com/walkthrough/corporate-finance/3...
- pinko 8y agoAnd a transparent betting market would do that math for you, and display it.