19 ms·
Nice list. Question: > 3. Charitability. [...] Assume they’re putting forward the strongest possible version of their argument, Wouldn't it be charitable to a
by FabHK 8y ago
Nice list. Question:
> 3. Charitability. [...] Assume they’re putting forward the strongest possible version of their argument,
Wouldn't it be charitable to assume that they're putting forward a sub-optimal version of their argument, ie not the strongest version? (Thus, their argument could be made stronger.)
- justinpombrio 8y agoYeah, this stuck me as poorly worded. But to follow the Charitability rule, it can be better interpreted as follows: Often, when someone puts forward an argument, there are multiple ways to interpret it. Some of these versions of their argument are strong than others. Assume that they were trying to say the strongest version. See also steelmanning: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man#Steelmanning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man#Steelmanning If you want to see examples of steelmanning, read http://slatestarcodex.com/ http://slatestarcodex.com/
- coldtea 8y ago>Wouldn't it be charitable to assume that they're putting forward a sub-optimal version of their argument, ie not the strongest version? (Thus, their argument could be made stronger.) What the parent means is that we should treat what they say as if they meant the "strongest possible version". So, parent doesn't mean "assume what they said was the strongest possible version" but "assume the strongest possible version of what they said".