5 ms·
Why is real estate around train stations more expensive if that's a place where people don't want to be? Maybe you should look at places where public transport
by adrianN 8y ago
Why is real estate around train stations more expensive if that's a place where people don't want to be? Maybe you should look at places where public transport works before claiming such nonsense.
- CamperBob2 8y agoDo you want to spend the rest of your life living next to a train station, and the rest of your career working next to a different one? Didn't think so.
- adrianN 8y agoI'd like to move closer to a train station, yes, but rent there is too expensive for my taste. Currently I have to walk 15 minutes to get to the nearest train station, or take the bus. I already work next to a train station. I only use the trains when the weather is really bad though, because I'm a little bit faster on my bike and I like the exercise. I honestly don't understand your point. What's so bad about living next to a train station? There are all kinds of shops there and the trains take me to basically anywhere in the city in less than 40 minutes. Would you rather live next to a highway?
- CamperBob2 8y agoEveryone can live near a road, if they wish to do so, and most people do. Not everyone can live near a train station. Seems like this should be obvious, but...
- EliRivers 8y ago... but you must be thinking in a different context or have a different set of assumptions to other people, given that it's presumably not obvious if you've had to say it. Here's an opportunity for everyone involved to expand their minds by trying to understand other people's assumptions, axioms and contexts.
- CamperBob2 8y agoThe context is reality. The assumptions are necessarily biased. And the axioms are those of Euclid ("There's only so much space next to the train station") and Pauli ("It's already full.").
- EliRivers 8y agoPerhaps we could build another rail station. This happens where I live. There's a new one being built on an existing line because the number of people living near it is enough to justify a new station. I think you will struggle to convince people here. Your style of argument alienates your audience. Given that any road could be a rail, any arguments about how everyone could have a road near them could presumably be met with the idea of having a rail near them. If you want axioms, I believe that everyone could live near a rail station. It's not physically impossible, despite being impractical and so forth. I find your arguments unconvincing and deliberately patronising, which does not help your case.
- CamperBob2 8y agoGiven that any road could be a rail, any arguments about how everyone could have a road near them could presumably be met with the idea of having a rail near them. Ridiculous and incoherent. Your style of argument alienates your audience. As does your insistence on mass behavior modification, I'm sure.
- CalRobert 8y agoUmm... yes... I built a whole tool to figure out the best combination of stations and it's been fairly popular.
- EliRivers 8y agoWhat counts as "next to"? I've lived within ten minutes walk of two or three different stations for the last thirty years, and I've worked within fifteen minutes walk of one for the last twenty years over a number of different jobs. When I'm considering where to live and where to work, I won't consider a house more than ten minutes away or a workplace more than fifteen, and have rejected houses and jobs on that basis in the past. I'm not alone.
- CamperBob2 8y agoWhen I'm considering where to live and where to work, I won't consider a house more than ten minutes away or a workplace more than fifteen, and have rejected houses and jobs on that basis in the past. I'm not alone. A cynic might say something like, "Fine. Enjoy Kowloon. Just don't make the rest of us endure it or pay for it," but I'll refrain on the grounds that it's more provocative and less respectful than I want to sound. But my counterargument would definitely be along those lines. At the end of the day, rail scales in only one dimension, while roads scale in two. That's important, IMO. Cities should not dictate the movement of people and goods; it should be the other way around.
- EliRivers 8y agoJust don't make the rest of us endure it or pay for it Pay for it? It is the city-dwellers who subsidise the low-density areas. As for "I would say this ... but I won't"; no, you just did, didn't you? Trying to hide behind a weird passive-aggressive "here's what I won't say" shield doesn't change anything; it's just passive-aggressive childishness and you know it. If you want to take the high road, then take it.