4 ms·
If you don't trust the abilities of other people, who do you think is currently driving cars? You are trusting everyone else on the road with your life every ti
by slg 8y ago
If you don't trust the abilities of other people, who do you think is currently driving cars? You are trusting everyone else on the road with your life every time you get in a car.
You ever look at other drivers when you are stuck in traffic? You will see people looking at their phones. You will see people eating. You will see people shaving. You will see people doing their makeup. You will see people reading books. You will see people with dogs on their laps. And that is just the people who might accidentally kill you due to carelessness. Vehicular suicide is more common than most people expect and there is no telling if you might be collateral damage in one of those collisions.
Self driving cars don't have to be perfect to be dramatically safer than human drivers.
- Stratoscope 8y agoComment deleted. I would have been happy to discuss the point in a calm and respectful manner. But I don't appreciate being accused of intellectual dishonesty and being told that what I said was "ridiculous". And "buff neck", really? What did that have to do with anything I said, except as a way to shut down the conversation?
- diab0lic 8y agoYou're being incredibly intellectually dishonest with yourself here. Suggesting that shaving makes you swivel your head and become more aware of traffic is akin to suggesting that shoulder checking during lane changes is going to give you a buff neck. It's ridiculous.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- semi-extrinsic 8y ago> Self driving cars don't have to be perfect to be dramatically safer than human drivers. This statement is technically correct, but it severely downplays how close to perfect the autonomous cars have to be to be significantly better than human-driven cars. If you look at European countries, current statistics are around 2 fatalities per billion km. The US is around twice that number. Either way it's actually a quite safe mode of transportation. In fact, if you compare it to travelling by train, the average over European train travel over the past decade is around 0.2 deaths per billion passenger km. Trains are driven by professionals, still accidents happen. In other words, the fatality rate for cars per billion passenger-kilometers is in the same order of magnitude as for trains driven by professional drivers. How much do you really expect autonomous cars to be able to improve on that?
- alexsb92 8y agoTechnically that's one order of magnitude difference between the the 2 fatalities per billion km and the 0.2 figure.
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoThe units are different though, 2 is per billion vehicle-km and the 0.2 is per billion people-km. The average number of people in a car is greater than 1.
- Reason077 8y agoGoing from 2 to 0.2 deaths per billion km (a 10x improvement in safety!) would be an enormous success for autonomous vehicles. Globally, that would save hundreds of thousands of lives every year. Often the lives of innocent passengers and pedestrians.
- semi-extrinsic 8y agoFirst of all, it's closer to 5x (you have to divide the car number by the average number of passengers in a vehicle). Second of all, I agree a 5x improvement would be impressive. But that's the level of a professional driver on a closed, dedicated track. I don't think autonomous vehicles will reach that level anytime soon.
- RaceWon 8y agoI was going to post earlier that IMO the level they should be aiming at is that of a brilliant racer, otherwise who needs them. There was a vid on here recently of the Porsche 919 beating the lap record at the Ring, and one of the comments was "I don't have the balls to drive that fast in a video game" such is the skill level of humans at the wheel-a few to be sure, but still and all there it is. Here's the vid btw. And it is ridiculous... "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQmSUHhP3ug" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQmSUHhP3ug"
- 8y ago