6 ms·
For some reason it jumped out at me that they considered time in religious services as a measurable component of how an ordinary person might spend their time.
by gumby 8y ago
For some reason it jumped out at me that they considered time in religious services as a measurable component of how an ordinary person might spend their time. I can see how it might be relevant to the topic at hand but it's quite uncommon for me to encounter a normative discussion of religious activity as an unremarkable thing.
Is it common (i.e. do I live in a bubble) or is it a marker of something about this article that I am missing? I pretty much only encounter mention of religion in the news headlines and am not sure I even know anyone who attends any kind of religious service more than two or three times a year.
It may be quite common and I might live in a bubble, but then is it mentioned routinely?
- mbrameld 8y agoIf there are churches near you why not drive by one or two any random Sunday morning around 10:30 or 11:00. Do it a few weekends in a row and see if your impression changes.
- gumby 8y agoThere is literally one at the corner of the next block and parking is never an issue on Sunday. I walk my dog past a few and apart from being well maintained they seem pretty deserted. The exception is the one downtown Palo Alto where Harold and Maude was filmed, but mainly I see wedding parties coming out on Saturdays.
- solresol 8y agoAnecdata: ACLF in Mountain View had so many people attending that they had to have volunteers direct traffic. (To be fair, that was about a decade ago, so it might have changed. And even now it just looks like an office block rather than a church, so there's no way you would pick up on it when walking past.)
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoI think it depends on where you are. I lived in Indiana the first 35 years of life, generally in towns with 3000-70,000 people. It was quite common for folks to go to church. Single? Want friends? and so on? You needed church. It was really, really common. To the point that folks weren't as willing to be openly athiest or customers at a retail place to assume that since employees were nice, they must all be good Christians. It was definitely mentioned, and wasn't uncommon for folks to ask where others went to church. I always got the impression that larger cities or different areas were more free with this sort of thing. I now live in Norway, and I know very few folks that spend a lot of time at church. There definitely aren't nearly as many of them here in town, and I think half the churches are as much of a tourist attraction as they are places for congregation. There is also more activities that aren't connected with any sort of religion here as well - organized volunteer work, for example, with no affiliation with religion.
- gumby 8y ago> I always got the impression that larger cities or different areas were more free with this sort of thing. Historically that's been one of the points of cities: if you don't like the rules where you live you go to a city where there are too many people for that sort of conformism. Of course some cities become large enough that they can have self-selected pockets similar to smaller conurbations. Interesting that the 70K town you lived in (not much bigger than Palo Alto) also exhibited this culture, though presumably less intensely.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jaggederest 8y agoBimodal distribution: Extended family all spend either 3+ days per week at church or zero days per year.
- gumby 8y agoInteresting. I may live in a self-selected group, though perhaps "bubble" is too strong a word.
- solresol 8y agoRoughly 20% of the USA will be at church this Sunday. In other countries it might be lower (e.g. about 10% of Australians will be at church this Sunday) but in western nations a general rule of thumb is that each week more people will be at church than will watch a game of professional sport live. What you are probably seeing is not really a filter bubble, but the personalisation of religion that's happened over the last generation or so. One of the Baptist distinctives ("religion is your own personal choice -- it's not dictated by your country or your community!") has become completely in-grained in our thinking. So religion just doesn't get discussed in public forums any more. As a fun exercise: ask 20 work colleagues (or fellow students or other random sample) about their religion. You'll be surprised at what you find, and it could lead to some of the most interesting conversations you'll have this year.
- gumby 8y ago> Roughly 20% of the USA will be at church this Sunday. ... a general rule of thumb is that each week more people will be at church than will watch a game of professional sport live. Interesting comparison: they are also mass participatory activities of the sort described in the article, with scope for discussion during (sport) and after (!!) in the case of religion. Quite different from watching at home. I went to a professional game this year and realised that it was the 8th one I'd attended (never watched one on TV). Now looking back I've probably attended about the same number (less than a dozen) formal abrahamic services my entire life as well (weddings, funerals, services, bar mitzvah). I'm 54; my parents, in their 80s, are probably at about the same number -- perhaps a few more funerals in recent years. Apart from one "crazy aunt" in India who would drag me along to the temple when we'd visit I pretty much don't know any people who profess to be attendees. Note I've always lived in low-religion regions of low-religion countries (Australia, Germany, USA and France) so it could be a self-selection issue. > ... personalisation of religion ... has become completely in-grained in our thinking. So religion just doesn't get discussed in public forums any more. It's interesting; I know the desire for this state of affairs runs prominently through the writing of most of the US government's founders and it seems like a good republican (i.e. non-arisocracy/monarchy ideal). But I can believe something could have been lost in the process. It seems like the only mass participatory activity Americans have in common any more is the useless TSA rituals :-(.