3 ms·
So far, Apple seems to be doing a good job of only doing their own hardware where they can turn that into a real advantage. They rightly gave up on the niche Po
by wtallis 8y ago
So far, Apple seems to be doing a good job of only doing their own hardware where they can turn that into a real advantage. They rightly gave up on the niche PowerPC architecture and switched to Intel CPUs. There are still tons of off-the-shelf components in Macs and even iOS devices, with lots of third-party IP in Apple's SoCs.
There aren't many examples of what looks like Apple doing their own hardware purely for the sake of being different and incompatible. Nothing stands out as a custom component that Apple would be better off replacing with a generic off-the-shelf part. And Apple isn't locking themselves into their own CPU architecture or anything like that; if they do end up falling behind with their mobile SoCs or something like that, it isn't hard for them to buy a different SoC with the same CPU instruction set.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThere are really two different kinds of vertical integration. One is where you actually integrate your products, making them less generic so they fit better together. So for example, if you design a CPU specifically to run Java bytecode then you make it more attractive to use that CPU (runs your Java code faster) and more attractive to use Java (runs faster on your Java CPU). The problem there is that it ties you down. You end up with an ecosystem designed around the integration -- compilers for making efficient Java bytecode for that CPU, operating systems that put Java in low level places because that CPU enables it, etc. Soon you have a house of cards and nothing can be changed or it all falls apart. When the market decides they want Rust and not Java then you can't sell your Java tools or your CPUs. The other type of "integration" is where you just buy the good suppliers so your competitors can't have them, or develop quality generic components in house. Then you have the advantage of a commodity CPU which is a little bit faster than average, but if someone else comes up with an even better one you can still switch to it (at the rather expensive cost of writing off your previous investment). The problem with that is your competitors can do the same thing and on average you're probably not going to be any better at it, so all you end up with is a series of bidding wars where you each buy up or recreate various pieces of the supply chain, and then internalize all the risk of an individual component under-performing the rest of the market. The potential upside is that you may end up owning something that turns out to be really important and can be used to conquer the market, but that upside is dampened by the fact that if it actually works you'll soon have antitrust lawyers from six different countries at your door. And it also tends to have a long-term destabilizing effect on the business, because temporarily having high margins and no competition simultaneously allows the company to become complacent and encourages third party investment into disrupting the market. It's a strategy designed to produce a trillion dollars in revenue for a year rather than a hundred billion dollars every year for a century, at a nontrivial risk of taking down the whole company without first conquering the market.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoA lot of this is really down to the principal-agent problem and human biases. Each person thinks they can do better than the whole rest of the world. So when you have a large company producing more profits than it can productively reinvest in its own line of business, rather than returning the money to the investors so they can choose what other business to invest in, the temptation is to expand into another market. Because if you're successful at one thing you should be successful at every other thing, right? So you get a huge conglomerate that looks good on paper, but unless the managers have better investment acumen than the stock market as a whole (or are very lucky) what they're really doing is burning the investors' money on below-market investments and hiding the below-market returns in the above-market returns from their primary line of business. It's also becoming increasingly difficult to dampen this because nobody actually owns these companies in the sense of being able to affect management. Even if I had a million dollars of AAPL shares, if I don't like what the management is doing, what can I do? I can vote, but I have ~0.000% of the shares. I can sell my shares, but that doesn't change their behavior. They're still outperforming the market (until they don't), even if the alternative would be even better performance, so no majority is inclined to oust them until after the damage is already done and proved. So what's the check on wasteful empire building? Or does the size of these companies prove that there isn't one.