4 ms·
> it's actually there for copyright protection Not really - you can't copyright facts. IANAL, but if you want to create a map based on another map's informati
by nostromo 16y ago
> it's actually there for copyright protection
Not really - you can't copyright facts. IANAL, but if you want to create a map based on another map's information, you're free to do so. Google Feist v. Rural for more info.
- eli 16y agoA map isn't an abstract collection of facts -- it's a picture drawn by a team of cartographers. You can definitely copyright that picture.
- nostromo 16y agoCorrect. You can't just photocopy the map, but you can recreate it. iSubwayMaps.com ran into copyright problems with the MTA in New York a while back. Instead of paying the MTA to use their official maps they just recreated the map themselves, using the official map as the only source. This, apparently, doesn't violate copyright law, even though the resulting maps are very similar.
- yellowbkpk 16y agoTwo things about this particular case that at the very least complicate (if not invalidate) your point: 1. When you copy a map, you usually don't make a Xerox (i.e. take the map tiles from Google Maps) -- you trace over it or recreate the underlaying data. Thus you're not copying the representation of the map but the abstract collection of facts that were used to generate the creative picture. 2. Is there any creative work being done when you use automated cartography (i.e. a set of human beings aren't hand-drawing the map based on your data from #1)? In the case of automated cartography I can see the cartographic style data being copyrightable but I don't think the actual tiled image representation of the map data is copyrightable. Of course, this is all (theoretically) a moot point because the Terms of Use prohibit automated use of Google Maps' data.
- Someone 16y agoBut the non-information that is the trap door makes the whole copyrightable. If the trap door shows up on your map, you cannot claim that your map is factual. You cannot claim your map is a 100% copy of mine, either, as that would be copyright infringement. IANAL, but I doubt that a judge would rule otherwise.
- jcl 16y agoThe parent cites a case (Feist v. Rural) where a judge ruled otherwise. Feist copied fictitious entries from Rural, but it was not considered copyright infringement.
- Someone 16y agoYes, I overlooked that, but I do not think that argumentation is applicable to this case. The Wikipedia page about that case states: "O'Connor states that copyright can only apply to the creative aspects of collection: the creative choice of what data to include or exclude, the order and style in which the information is presented, etc., but not on the information itself." and "the standard for creativity is extremely low" For a map, the creative aspects are way stronger than for a phone directory. Therefore, I still think that copying significant parts of a map would be infringement. Trap doors would help strengthen the case that copying took place.
- jcl 16y agoI trust you've also seen the Wikipedia article cited elsewhere in these comments, where copying fictitious map entries was also ruled non-infringing? A map is ostensibly a presentation of facts, and while there are creative decisions involved that can be copyrighted, trap streets are not among these decisions. In the U.S., at least, it's not enough to establish that copying took place, if facts are the only things being copied. And that's a good thing. If intentional factual errors were copyrightable, newspapers would fill their articles with misspellings and falsehoods in hopes that they could sue competing publications out of existence. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street#Legal_issues http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trap_street#Legal_issues
- rmc 16y agoThe actual images themselves are copyrighted images. However you can copyright a collection of facts, e.g. a phone book. It's the collation of facts that is copyrighted. How much of it you can copy before you get into copyright is up to a judge.
- barrkel 16y agoMind your country though - Wikipedia indicates the AA in the UK had to pay up 20 million GBP for copying government-created maps (Ordnance Survey).
- blasdel 16y agoIn the US the government isn't even allowed to hold copyright on its works — the taxpayers funded it, so all Government publishings must be public domain. In the UK and Commonwealth countries the Crown holds full copyright by default over all government works.
- flipbrad 16y agoThat's absolutely true. Rather than give up copyright, it's now very slowly turning to releasing stuff under open licence, the Open Government Licence (OGL): http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/information-management/uk-gov-licensing-framework.htm http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/information-management/uk...