6 ms·
>haha, the size of the Ethereum blockchain is making it centralized This is to be expected. Centralization and hierarchies are the fundamental ways to deal wit
by Barrin92 8y ago
>haha, the size of the Ethereum blockchain is making it centralized
This is to be expected. Centralization and hierarchies are the fundamental ways to deal with complexity, which is why all non-hierarchical systems are doomed if they grow too large. That's as true for physical or biological systems as it is for markets and currencies, which is why the whole decentralised crypto dream is a fool's errand.
- darawk 8y agoThat's why planned economies work so well, right?
- spookthesunset 8y agoObviously there is a happy gray between completely black and completely white.
- Barrin92 8y agocentrally planned economies do not work well, but the focus here lies on the word 'central', not 'planned'. All economies are planned to a significant degree, albeit in corporations (which internally do plan rather than rely on market mechanisms). The equivalent of cryptocurrencies in the economic sphere would be turning every company into an army of independent individual contractors whose only tool is the legal contract. This would lead to unmanageable complexity and overhead that would be unacceptable and very soon end in people naturally organizing in competent hierarchies, producing the dreaded institutions and middlemen that cryptocurrency tries to do away with. Read for this very question Coase's essay, The Nature of the Firm.
- darawk 8y agoI've read Coase. The equivalent of cryptocurrencies in the economic sphere would be exactly what cryptocurrencies are: partially decentralized. Firms form due to the transaction costs of decentralization. Mining pools form due to the transaction costs of decentralization.
- cryptobeanbaby 8y agoMining pools form due to the transaction costs of decentralization. Better explained as a result of the mining protocol being winner takes all, and is granted write access authority (for guessing a increasingly larger random number), that by pooling everyone's lottery tickets together and paying the pool operator, the agree to take a small sum of each successful guess from the pool (assuming the pool fairly pays out participants). "decentralized" except not.
- darawk 8y agoVariance is a transaction cost.
- colordrops 8y agoCrude statements like this paper over so much of the reasoning and detail around the purpose of blockchains. It's so much more than a single dimensional configuration slider between centralized and decentralized.
- Youden 8y agoI don't mean this as an attack or to be argumentative but could you elaborate on why it's so much more than a single dimensional configuration slider? A comment with a statement or assertion and no reasoning is very difficult to discuss.
- dlubarov 8y agoI think "centralization" is pretty ambiguous. Is Bitcoin centralized? Full nodes can be run on home PCs, so verification is decentralized, but only ASIC mining is profitable, so mining has become highly centralized. The Lightning Network adds additional roles, like payment hubs and watchtowers, with varying degrees of centralization. So we can't characterize Bitcoin as a whole as centralized or decentralized. We should talk about specific roles, and the various attacks that could be performed by coordinated members within each role. Like we could talk about the possibility of Bitmain coordinating a 51% double spend attack, or the possibility of a major LN hub bribing watchtowers to ignore foul play.
- colordrops 8y agoI could create a long list, but to start, it's not directly controlled by a single individual or organization. The mechanism used to assert leverage is different than typical centralized systems. It's not a contract or a special governmentally assigned right or physical intimidation that "centralizes" the network. It's simply computing resources. But unlike other centralized systems, anyone anywhere with enough of those resources could assert the same leverage on the network as anyone else. Furthermore, because of its distributed nature, even if someone had a majority of computing resources mining the network, the protocol is designed to disincentivize participants from cheating as it would destroy the value of the network. And they couldn't even tamper with the ledger, as public key cryptography is used to sign transactions, so they could only stop transactions from happening. It is also fully visible and transparent. This is fundamentally different from your typical centralized database sitting behind physical walls with physical security and governmental protection that a single entity could mutate and obfuscate at will.
- chrisco255 8y agoHow are markets centralized, exactly? If centralization and hierarchies were the answer to all complexity, then the feudal system would still be relevant. Markets are complex, organic things, with a lot of players.
- DSingularity 8y agoReally? funny to think we are anything but feudal. Markets may have large number of players but the number of players which matter are much less.
- chrisco255 8y agoI'm not even sure what you mean by that, but if you think we have anything remotely resembling a feudal economy, I invite you to do more research into history.