6 ms·
Who was sending these notices? Sounds like perjury to me.
by dotancohen 8y ago
Who was sending these notices? Sounds like perjury to me.
- Jerry2 8y ago>Who was sending these notices? There's lots of them. The most notorious one I had to deal with was Adrev. There are reports of people getting notices from AdRev for videos that don't even have any music in them. [1] [1] https://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/youtube/42xLenp36Co https://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/youtube/42xLe...
- yomly 8y agoIs this a new evolution of patent trolling? Except you don't even need a patent anymore...?
- digi_owl 8y agoCopyright trolling?
- yomly 8y agoOf course it already exists /sigh. Seems like this is a great way to do copyright trolling - it's highly scalable and exists within a walled garden which means it's a legal grey area for things like this, much like how free speech on YouTube/Reddit isn't really a thing.
- mirimir 8y agoThere's lots of information here: https://talent.adrev.net/about https://talent.adrev.net/about
- lozenge 8y agoIt isn't perjury. In the DMCA, It is illegal for me to send copyright notices about you infringing a work I don't own, but it is not illegal for me to send a copyright notice about a work I do own - say a film - even if the page doesn't actually contain any of that film. Apart from classical music, bird noises and ambient noises are common cases of inaccurate YouTube takedowns.
- gorbachev 8y agoThese are not DMCA notices, but YouTube's/Google's own copyright cop they implemented to pacify the big media companies. It's notorious for false positives and how impossible those false positives are to resolve.
- ObsoleteNerd 8y agoWelcome to the DMCA. It's as broken as copyright and causing quite serious stifling of young creators. It sometimes feels like it's used more for evil than for its legitimate purpose.
- ekianjo 8y agoSeems? More like its mainly used in this way nowadays. There is no risk in sending DMCA notices so of course its abused.
- dalore 8y agoWonder if we can return the favour? If someone sends us an obvious unfair takedown (like in the article) we can name and shame them. And also do the same tactics, go to their content and report it as violation of your content. Even if it doesn't they still have to respond and go through the same hoops. If a group of us formed and we did this to all of them and gunged up the system, google would be forced to improve it.
- jstarfish 8y ago> And also do the same tactics, go to their content and report it as violation of your content. This might work between rival game streamers or something but the law offices of Dewey, Cheatem & Howe likely do not have a YouTube channel for you to retaliate against.
- Timmah 8y agoBut you could find out who is legitimately using that copyright on YT and retaliate against them. For instance, if you use a clip of a Prince song that is taken down, and you determine that BMG music owns the Prince catalog, you could send automated infringement requests against PrinceVEVO or any official BMG uploads. Even better if you created a "burner" corporation. Ie P.O. box in Delaware and act on their behalf. They have to take you seriously because corporation, amirite?
- jobigoud 8y agoYouTube partners can upload a collection of files they claim rights on, and a YouTube bot will check any newly published video against anything in that database. It's all automated. They don't verify if the claimant actually has the rights, this is left to the "dispute" process. Sometimes multiple companies upload the same files. Sometimes the algorithm has false positives because the section of audio used is too short.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoSometimes they use your work in theirs, upload it and have YouTube flag your original as infringing. I have to wonder why anybody still uses YouTube. It can't be the community.
- komali2 8y agoI mean, what could compete, in terms of raw audience?
- binomialxenon 8y agoCentralization.
- TremendousJudge 8y agoit's the best video streaming platform. nothing comes close in terms on quality, speed, and amount of content
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]