3 ms·
> Therefore, the logic is to dig everything you might imagine you might need, ever. Therefore tunnels are always going to be super expensive and elaborate. Not
by jcranmer 8y ago
> Therefore, the logic is to dig everything you might imagine you might need, ever. Therefore tunnels are always going to be super expensive and elaborate.
Not everything you might imagine you might need, ever. But everything you can reasonably forecast to need in the next 50 years.
The thing about tunnels: tunnels aren't expensive, stations are (particularly the station mezzanines and the pedestrian circulation to reach them). A two-track subway line is only going to be ~30% more expensive than a one-track line, and a four-track line only ~50-60% more than a two-track line. And it doesn't take a genius to figure out which one you need: one-track lines are never a good idea, and four-track lines are only necessary for trunks in megacities. You can look at your demand and figure out if you're going to need to go to 8- or 10-car trains as your maximum train length. Not to mention that you also (as a city) have the ability to steer development to increase demand on your subway networks via tools like zoning.
Insisting that you have to build only to minimal, current demand scenarios is being penny-wise and pound-foolish.