7 ms·
The companies in question already had a history of operating illegally in San Francisco. I don't think it's fair to dismiss that as "picking and choosing". Dump
by LeoPanthera 8y ago
The companies in question already had a history of operating illegally in San Francisco. I don't think it's fair to dismiss that as "picking and choosing". Dumping those scooters over the city is effectively littering.
Business should be able to operate freely, but they should not be able to break the law until someone catches them.
- ckocagil 8y agoIf you think about it, Uber and Lyft literally built their businesses on breaking taxi laws of every city they operate in.
- Pyxl101 8y agoThey did not break the taxi laws of every city they operated in. The taxi laws of many cities only required a "medallion" for taxi-style car services that allowed passengers to "hail" the car on the street. So-called "black" cars where passengers arranged transportation in advance were governed differently, and required no licensing or a different and more permissive kind of licensing. Black car services were already widely available in many cities from lots of different companies, often independent owner/operators - it's just that no one had provided a service that worked across many different cities and was available conveniently as an app. I won't claim that Uber and Lyft broke no laws, because there are a lot of jurisdictions in the world, and I don't know the laws of all of them, but many cities regular taxies and black cars very differently. Edit: Why the downvotes? Am I wrong? Evidence would be appreciated.
- prepend 8y agoThose laws harmed consumers and would not be changed. Lots of just causes broke unjust laws.
- hannasanarion 8y agoUber drivers working 80 hours a week to survive because they have no workers rights like taxi drivers do would beg to differ.
- prepend 8y agoHave you ever driven a taxi? Worker’s rights are a joke. Talk to your cabbie in New York about worker’s rights. The cabs are owned by large firms. Cabbies are hired and fired all the time for arbitrary reasons. And the wages are really low for the driver. But the owner makes a bunch as does the investor that owns the medallion license.
- jonny_eh 8y agoWhat law did they break?
- dmix 8y agoWhatever law it may be it was most certainly not designed in the era of these scooters being a thing.
- trhway 8y agounfortunately the city itself - for example streets, sidewalks, etc. - also wasn't designed in the era of these scooters being a thing.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoUse of powered vehicles on sidewalks is illegal, as is blocking entrances with vehicles. The city accused Bird and Lime of doing both.
- baddox 8y agoIn that case, Toyota is currently breaking that law on my street.
- mc32 8y agoFor that to be analogous, it would have to be "Enterprise" or "Hertz" doing it. Not Toyota. If Hertz (Or CityCarShare) just went ahead and just put their cars willy-nilly anywhere they wanted, then you'd have a point.
- jerkstate 8y agoMaybe this would all be fixed if every Bird scooter had a license plate and you needed to be licensed to drive them? In contrast to Bird, Scoot hasn't attracted that much criticism in SF despite being a pretty similar service.
- prepend 8y ago
- Meekro 8y agoIf I'd started a scooter company before scooter companies were a thing, went to any city and asked for permission, they would have said "wtf? no." (assuming they answered my petition at all) and that would have been the end of it. The only reason we're here arguing about this is companies like Bird chose to ask for forgiveness rather than permission in the past.
- minikites 8y ago>ask for forgiveness rather than permission Do you genuinely think it's good for society when businesses do this?
- baddox 8y agoI don’t see how anyone could believe that it’s never good for society when businesses do this.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoJust like killing someone might be good for society sometimes. Doesn't mean you want to do this indiscriminately, or have this as standard practice.
- s0rce 8y agoIn all cases, no. In this case, yes. Improving the sad state of transportation options in the bay area is beneficial to all residents. Two wrongs don't make a right. Fine them for breaking the rules and then allow them to continue. Don't give their business to a competitor in an act of revenge against their breaking the rules.
- noobermin 8y agoYou're phrasing it as if it's "revenge" rather than the city looking out for its citizen's best interests. If this company has been willing to flaunt the rules, who's to say it won't again? That isn't "revenge," it seems more like using common sense.
- isoskeles 8y agoIt's not littering. You know this.
- LeoPanthera 8y agoHonestly I don't know. It feels like littering. If the company suddenly closed - what now? Presumably they're unusable without the backend.
- fyfy18 8y agoI wouldn’t worry too much about that. Here in London, most of the time when I see someone using an Ofo bike it’s some kids who clearly aren’t paying for them, but have found a way to unlock them.
- isoskeles 8y agoI think you do. I dislike the scooters for my own reasons, mainly the fact that people ride them on sidewalks. But this is not littering. You tell me if you see a scooter on the sidewalk if that strikes you as the same as people disposing of trash on the sidewalk: loose papers, cigarette butts, plastic bags, etc. I get what you're saying for the sake of argument, but littering is a disgusting act that makes most people feel like their city is unclean.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rorykoehler 8y agoActually they reduce pollution as they are greener than the modes of transport they replace (ICE cars).
- jsemrau 8y agoYou are absolutely right. Dockless mobility uses public space for the benefit of a private corporation. I cycle to work and there is not a single day where I see an OfO bike or Grab bike parked in the most annoying places. Maybe "society" is not ready for dockless and we need to create norms and rules of behavior (i.e., enforce that with fines)
- s0rce 8y agoWhile I agree that this is an issues, in my opinion it is exceedingly minor, especially in comparison to the amount of cars illegally stopped or parked that I see while biking. In fact I had to merge into traffic a few times to go around tonight. A few bikes haphazardly placed is nothing more than a mild nuisance. Never mind the homeless camps and other litter everywhere in the bay area.
- mavhc 8y agoCars, parked badly, you're on the right track..... homeless people = litter?, oh dear.
- s0rce 8y agoHomeless people are obviously not litter, and think its a bit of an unfair exaggeration to read my comment in that way, however, I do see how you could infer that. Regardless, in my experience the camps have tons of trash/litter around. It seems not that surprising as my house would have lots of trash if I didn't have garbage collection service. Just drive to some of the camps in Oakland/Berkeley.
- almost_usual 8y agoWonder how many of those illegally stopped cars are Ubers and Lyfts...
- s0rce 8y agoSome, I've posted about this before but in many areas of Oakland parking is so inexpensive/free that cars are parked basically indefinitely. If you then want to just run into the bank or pick up take out (and you are driving) your options are drive around for a long time to find a spot, stop in the bike lane or just leave your car in the middle of the road. As someone who drives and cycles routinely I understand the choice. In Berkeley parking is time limited and expensive and you can usual find a spot to run in quickly. I don't mind ubers quickly stopping to drop someone off on a non-separated bike lane as long as they don't cut people off and signal and merge safely. I'm happy to wait behind them or merge around just like a car would had they stopped in the main traffic lane. We can share the infrastructure, just don't leave your car in the bike lane!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wellyeah 8y agoLittering?!
- gojomo 8y agoIf companies broke specific laws, convict them in a court of law, and apply statutory penalties or reasonably-computed damages. This sort of retaliatory "shit list", constructed without due process, from which a company might only be able to extricate themselves by "kissing the ring" of local politicos/bureaucrats, is a recipe for inefficiency and corruption. I also don't think the "litter" charge against the initial scooter deployments is correct, anyway, for reasons I outlined in a prior thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17268697 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17268697