3 ms·
Musk seems to think that costs for tunneling are proportional to the square of the diameter (i.e., proportional to cross-section). If you assume that the cost i
by jcranmer 8y ago
Musk seems to think that costs for tunneling are proportional to the square of the diameter (i.e., proportional to cross-section). If you assume that the cost is dominated by the amount of spoil you need to excavate, that makes sense. But that's not the domination of the cost.
A tunnel bore is relatively cheap. Musk cites the costs of $1 billion/mi. subways, but that is a very malicious bait-and-switch. The tunneling cost for those subways come out to around $100-150M per track-mile of tunnel, and I suspect that includes the standard tunnel accoutrements: drainage, airflow, lighting, etc. Much of those accoutrements are invariant to the tunnel diameter, to a first approximation.
Tunnel-boring itself has some costs, but most of those don't scale as fast as cross-sectional area. Cutting head replacements and the ultimate spoil disposal are the only things I can think of that do. The TBM itself, and the tunnel shielding are going to scale linearly with circumference. Things like the power systems, spoil recovery, or manpower costs for manning the TBM are going to pretty much be invariant with size (assuming the size is generally the same magnitude).
All totaled, you'd expect the costs to scale somewhere around linearly with diameter/radius.