4 ms·
These sorts of transitions take a lot of time. There's a lot of infrastructure to build and a lot of infrastructure to decommission. In addition to the politi
by reaperducer 8y ago
These sorts of transitions take a lot of time. There's a lot of infrastructure to build and a lot of infrastructure to decommission.
In addition to the political problems, extensively noted by others here, there are also the social problems.
Power plants and the associated industries are full of low-skill/education workers. Some can be re-trained into other industries, but some cannot.
An example is happening right now in Arizona. With so many coal plants being shut down, the Navajo Nation and other nearby tribes are being devastated.
These are already people who were dirt poor, living in a place that few want to go. There's few opportunities for employment. The one industry they had was supplying coal to utilities as far away as California. They even built a pipeline to flush coal clear across the state to Nevada.
Now all those jobs are going away, and there's zero industry left.
They're trying to build solar farms, but companies like Southern California Edison aren't interested in buying the power because solar plants can be built closer to home, and don't need new transmission lines to be built.
So a bunch of left coast technocrats get to pat themselves on the backs for saving the environment, while further marginalizing the people who saved the environment for them for a thousand years.
- dahdum 8y agoI'm more cynical about California than most, but these policies are a positive force for environmental change and history has shown they aren't empty promises. Like all policy change, it will create winners and losers. While it's unfortunate Navajo Nation may be the latter, it shouldn't mean we stop moving forward.
- rm_-rf_slash 8y agoOr another way of putting it, the Navajo Nation may lose in the short term, but without these transitions, they and everybody else could end up losing much more over a far longer timescale. I do, however, believe that green power policy should include assistance to the people and communities affected negatively by decarbonization, as the pain to those folks is much higher than it is to wealthy Californians who merely pay slightly higher taxes to get the new energy production and efficiency measures installed.
- reaperducer 8y agoassistance to the people and communities affected negatively by decarbonization The utilities could just build the new power plants where the old ones were. Same result, without an overt handout.
- philipkglass 8y agoThe Navajo Nation has excellent solar resources. And new solar projects are being built on the reservation: https://tucson.com/business/tribally-owned-solar-power-plant-beats-skeptics-odds-on-navajo/article_9dcbd829-9134-552b-a305-242cdb673d0a.html https://tucson.com/business/tribally-owned-solar-power-plant... http://ktar.com/story/2189238/navajo-nation-kayenta-solar-renewable-energy-expansion/ http://ktar.com/story/2189238/navajo-nation-kayenta-solar-re... https://www.bizjournals.com/phoenix/news/2018/01/26/navajos-srp-to-double-solar-energy-plant-ink-big.html https://www.bizjournals.com/phoenix/news/2018/01/26/navajos-... You wouldn't be able to replace the annual energy output of the Navajo Generating Station just with solar farms built on former NGS land, of course, because coal can be turned into electricity in a much smaller area. But if you consider the 44,000 acre leased area of the Kayenta Mine that supplies NGS with coal, you could actually get more annual energy production from the same area by switching to solar.
- reaperducer 8y agoLike all policy change, it will create winners and losers Translation: It sucks to be poor. And an indian. Where did I park my Tesla?