5 ms·
> Interior Minister Horst Seehofer told reporters that Germany needed new tools to become a top player in cyber security and shore up European security and inde
by mschuster91 8y ago
> Interior Minister Horst Seehofer told reporters that Germany needed new tools to become a top player in cyber security and shore up European security and independence.
Good grace. The man is so horribly incompetent at everything he does and his party (CSU) are even worse. I don't trust this proposal even a bit.
In addition:
1) how on earth are they planning to fund and staff all of this? I worked for local government and it paid shit, and from what I hear state/fed government doesn't pay much more either, so no way to attract talent by pay.
2) Like many gov positions, this will be German nationals only (or EU nationals, not sure if German-citizens-only is still allowed under EU regulations?). Definitely no jobs for non-EU applicants.
3) Ever got a conviction for hacking or a (known) weed/other drug habit? Automatic no-go. Which is the reason why there is a severe lack of IT competency in government, no matter the level or agency.
4) Who in living hell wants to work that job? I'd expect to be kicked out of any political or hacktivist group if I were to work for our increasingly authoritarian government, let alone under Seehofer, and that with reason. That leaves as candidates only those with no other options left, and authoritarians at the best, Nazis at the worst. The police of Saxony showed on the weekend what is the result.
- mikejb 8y agoI've worked on projects for the German govt before, and I was never employed by them. Points 3 and 4, possibly also 2 are handled by hiring companies to do the work.
- mschuster91 8y agoSeehofer wants to create an entire agency. Makes sense given that this is national security matter, I can't believe he'll (be able to) outsource this. And the other points are still valid even if outsourced, as the requirements will be part of the outsourcing contract.
- atlasunshrugged 8y agoI don't know if it's not possible to outsource it, if you look to the U.S. an absolutely massive amount of work (intelligence and military ops) is outsourced to private contractors Ex source (sorry, old one, don't have time right now to find a more recent article I was thinking of for reference): https://www.salon.com/2007/06/01/intel_contractors/ https://www.salon.com/2007/06/01/intel_contractors/
- mschuster91 8y ago> I don't know if it's not possible to outsource it, if you look to the U.S. an absolutely massive amount of work (intelligence and military ops) is outsourced to private contractors And Snowden was one of the inevitable results. I mean, I'm happy the leak happened, but it is a perfect example of what can go wrong with outsourcing to the cheapest bidder. In total it would be better for the government to do in-house, but how else are you gonna shift citizen money into the hand of already ultra rich people... the only thing where outsourcing is profitable and worth it is for exclusively short term things (e.g. constructing buildings or developing a specific software), but long term stuff? Cut the profits of the company and hire the employees yourselves.
- mikejb 8y agoIt wasn't outsourced to the cheapest bidder; actually, limitations on govt salaries is one of the reasons to outsource: you can attract better talent with competitive offers. And plenty of whistleblowers at the CIA and NSA were direct gov employees, not contractors.
- mikejb 8y agoThese requirements don't need to be part of the outsourcing contract. Sure, there can and probably will be some restrictions, but the reasons why a government agency doesn't employ (even former) drug users don't necessarily apply to contractors hired by the government even for national security projects.