6 ms·
Over the past year, we discovered that the customer that never paid had the highest support load. Once we made the announcement about the price change, the same
by patio11 16y ago
Over the past year, we discovered that the customer that never paid had the highest support load. Once we made the announcement about the price change, the same applied to complaining about Chargify across multiple public channels. Those customers that were working on a hobby business, or just something they were not investing in significantly, seemed to have the time to tweet all day long, post multiple negative comments on every possible channel available, and shout the loudest.
This is exactly what I mean when I talk about pathological customers. You will get to deal with them, too, if you try to be the cheap option in your market.
- Vivtek 16y agoOh hell yes. I ran Despammed.com for years (free spam filtering) and never charged anything for it, not having figured out the ???-profit part. The majority of people were very supportive, and even provided donations that paid my mortgage more than once - but there were enough that were psychos demanding that I take them off my spam mailing list (???) or they'd never pay me again. Seriously. There are a lot of really stupid/weird people out in the world.
- elblanco 16y agoJust remember, 1/2 of the world gets by with an IQ under 100.
- mgrouchy 16y agoI think this is essentially true, we made this decision early when we came out of beta to not offer a free plan for exactly this reason. Non-paying customers end up taking up the lions share of your companies resources.
- bdfh42 16y agoCorrect - the only customers I have had to "sack" have been a couple on a "special low price" deal - they always made greater demands than the regular paying customers and their (non financial) contributions to the process were always inadequate and late.
- buro9 16y agoI think you're really pre-judging your customers in a bad way here. You don't have pathological customers, what you have is a large number of people who instead of paying hard currency for a service will trade time as their currency. What this means is that a good number of those who stay on the free side of the freemium model are in fact willing to pay. Just not with cash. What they're willing to do is to spend time to learn your service, to participate in your forums, and in any way that is required to get their free service. When you only expect, want, and cater for the customers who have hard currency you will of course piss off the time-as-a-currency crowd if you've already grabbed them. Then it should come as no surprise when those pissed off people use their time against you. I'm not saying that's a reasonable response. But it's certainly to be expected. The best thing to do is to work out how to use the time-as-a-currency crowd to your advantage. Instead of ditching them in a price-hike, ask them to do something for you. Maybe they have to participate in support forums to help others getting on board in return for the service? Maybe they have to just promote your service on their site? My point is simply that it's naive to ignore this very large set of customers, and even more naive to act in ways that will piss them off if you've already constructed a freemium model that attracted them.
- Poiesis 16y agoYou don't have pathological customers, what you have is a large number of people who instead of paying hard currency for a service will trade time as their currency. Look, I'm sure they're very nice people, but their extra time is not going to pay for your ramen. They cost more money and pay less money so they cost you money. You may decide that you would like to optimize for lower revenue, but most people would probably disagree.
- tptacek 16y agoIt seems to turn out that a lot of them aren't very nice people.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- damoncali 16y ago
- greyboy 16y agoWhile I haven't followed this situation intently, what I don't understand is: why do they have to provide so much support for free users? I always thought it is rather common to have free users limited to FAQs and articles/tutorials rather than access to 24/7 phone (and other) support. (please excuse my ignorance here, but I haven't seen this mentioned)
- jacquesm 16y agoAgreed, I don't think they 'owe' the free customers any support, in fact, charging for support would be a great way out of the problem it seems. On top of that your service should not need that much support to begin with.
- tptacek 16y agoAre you a Chargify customer? You have a lot of thoughts to share about how the service should work. For instance: why should Chargify not need that much support to begin with? Are you sure their business model isn't "get people to pay a premium for support"? Are you sure you're not just piling on here?
- jacquesm 16y ago> Are you a Chargify customer? Are you ? I didn't see a sign at the door that said that only chargify customers can speak. > For instance: why should Chargify not need that much support to begin with? Because every other payments service that I've ever used (and that's quite a few of them) didn't need that either. Download integration guide, spend a day figuring things out, test, fire & forget. > Are you sure their business model isn't "get people to pay a premium for support"? It could be. > Are you sure you're not just piling on here? Yes, I'm quite sure. For the record, I built 'webpay', one of the very first web payment services so I have a bit of knowledge in what goes in to a payment service and a bunch of people I know run an IPSP. When this whole thing blew I put up a bunch of things that were not too hot about how this was/is handled and that was before anybody else wrote as much as two lines about it. If you want to accuse me of 'piling on' then I'm sure you could find a better example to make your case.
- dminor 16y agoMaybe, but this section and the TechCrunch bitching really have no place in a supposed mea culpa.
- tptacek 16y agoSo you'd prefer ritualized penitence to insight about his business.
- dminor 16y agoThis is a complaint, not a business insight: "Those customers that were working on a hobby business, or just something they were not investing in significantly, seemed to have the time to tweet all day long, post multiple negative comments on every possible channel available, and shout the loudest." Same with the TechCrunch section. If you choose to make an apology, you might as well make it sound as sincere as possible.
- tptacek 16y agoIf you read all the comments on this thread, you'll see that virtually all of the negative reactions to Chargify's move appeal to some form of "you need free customers to market your business". Sorry, I can see why you wouldn't enjoy reading this stuff, but insight about Chargify's business is exactly what this is.
- dminor 16y agoNo, I enjoyed reading it, and most of it was fine. But if the point of his post is to say "I'm sorry" and do damage control, he shoots himself in the foot by whining about people complaining. If 99% of your users are on the free plan, and they're the ones complaining loudest, bashing them in your apology is possibly not the best plan to get you out of the mess. Pvg says it much better than me below.
- necrecious 16y agoI switched away from Freemium for my company yesterday. Should have done it a while back. Free users are harder to support, more vocal and less likely to upgrade. Even a token amount of money initially is probably enough to discourage the "pathological" customers and the sunk costs mindset might encourage spending more money with your service.
- jacquesm 16y agoHave you tried to make money on your free users in a different way?
- necrecious 16y agoThe easiest way to make money is to ask for it directly from the people it benefits. I suppose I could try selling user data or use advertising. Either require massive number of users and a lot of upfront time to get going.
- points 16y agoIt's not about "cheap option" at all. You get fanatical customers everywhere, and they can be good and bad. They've mainly been good in my experience though.
- patio11 16y agoPathological customers are, by definition, bad. I'm not using the term to mean "a synonym of non-paying customers, poor people, or people enthusiastic about the software." I have heard from many other software developers, and seen in my own life, that charging more money disproportionately chases them away. I had a major decrease in the number I dealt with just when I went from $25 to $30, while sales went up. It is amazing: charge $5 more, see people suddenly have less hard drive failures, virus infestations, and "bad days". (I called you a dishonest SOB thieving from poor defenseless women when I mistyped my password... because I'm having a bad day, you see.) And it wasn't 20% less, it was closer to 80% less.
- points 16y agoOK, my experience is much different. I would far far rather provide a free ad supported service than charge. If you give it away free as ad supported, users tend to be extremely grateful. Once they start paying, even a tiny amount, they start to be more resentful and demand far more.
- tptacek 16y agoDon't ask customers to pay "a tiny amount". Ask them to pay according to the business value you believe your service provides, scaled to your business objectives (ie: eating, hot showers, customer acquisition). What Patrick is saying over and over and over and over again is that you have to be willing to let the pathological customers go. One function of your pricing is to chase out the people who aren't driving your business, so you can concentrate on serving the people who derive the maximum value from your work. Asking for small change is just about the worst thing you can do; pathological customers can afford it, and will immediately feel entitlement.
- brc 16y agoMy maxim for this is : you want to find customers who value their time over their money. As soon as you run across a person who values their money more than their time, they'll use up your time and give you no money. And, while they might be nice folks, if you're running a business you have to politely find a way of letting them know you can't do business with them.