3 ms·
Actually, the decision per se isn't even about that. It's about whether the FCC, being the regulatory body responsible for this stuff, is able to decide for i
by ajross 8y ago
Actually, the decision per se isn't even about that. It's about whether the FCC, being the regulatory body responsible for this stuff, is able to decide for itself whether or not a "nearby" service provider counts as "competition" in an abstract sense.
The court held, basically, that the FCC's decision is reasonable enough to fit within its congressionally-mandaded charter, so making the decision is none of the legal system's business. If you don't like it vote in an administration which will staff the FCC with people who agree with you.
- rossdavidh 8y agoTruth. Really, I have to sympathize with the court on this, they're basically saying "The FCC knows more about communications technology and the economics associated with it than a judge does", which is undoubtedly true. Deciding this sort of thing is what the FCC is for. That doesn't mean they got it right, but short of creating a communication-technology centered appeals court, that's what we've got. The FCC is the correct (currently existing) government institution to be making that kind of decision. Just because they (arguably) made the wrong decision here, doesn't mean it makes sense to have appeals court judges deciding this, as the technology and economic background required to make that decision is not part of their training, nor something they could acquire in the course of a court case.