4 ms·

Was thinking the same. Then remembered that OpenBSD's rand(3) actually returns result from arc4random() now. Then went to check and it seemed like Perl doesn't

by dchest 8y ago

Was thinking the same. Then remembered that OpenBSD's rand(3) actually returns result from arc4random() now. Then went to check and it seemed like Perl doesn't actually use rand(3) from libc? At least Perl's srand(N) and then rand() returned deterministic results, which shouldn't happen if it was using rand(3)...

hoytech 8y ago
Yes good point. I was careful not to say that perl actually uses rand(3) because I think it may not for portability reasons. Also, I think this may have changed at some point so might be different depending on perl version.
- notaplumber 8y ago
  OpenBSD's carrying some local patches, Perl rand appears to be using the libc drand48(3) on OpenBSD, which uses arc4random_buf(3) internally, unless Perl srand is called, then it uses srand48_deterministic(3)? Not sure precisely as it's also using arc4random(3) directly to seed something. This is slightly different from how it's handled outside the Perl software ecosystem, as all the srand* functions effectively became nops on OpenBSD in favour of strong random numbers, and userland ports had to be patched to use the deterministic variants if needed. I guess that would be hard with things like CPAN. https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648ddbc62f0a74abf9e098d#diff-b1d655ef1da257a3f4c33327fb83bd0dR20776 https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648dd... https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648ddbc62f0a74abf9e098d#diff-6f239a14c0c4e792da78a0310d16d9a1R4652 https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648dd... https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648ddbc62f0a74abf9e098d#diff-9dc22d2e9511b13cd64378f8671179edR3133 https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648dd... Looks like upstream Perl also uses drand48 from FreeBSD, with its own internal RNG. But I guess this can be overridden with build options. I'd imagine something like pwgen would be better, but I doubt it matters here.
  - hoytech 8y ago
    Thank you for the details. I agree none of this probably matters much for their use-case.

by dchest 8y ago

hoytech 8y ago

Yes good point. I was careful not to say that perl actually uses rand(3) because I think it may not for portability reasons. Also, I think this may have changed at some point so might be different depending on perl version.

notaplumber 8y ago
OpenBSD's carrying some local patches, Perl rand appears to be using the libc drand48(3) on OpenBSD, which uses arc4random_buf(3) internally, unless Perl srand is called, then it uses srand48_deterministic(3)? Not sure precisely as it's also using arc4random(3) directly to seed something. This is slightly different from how it's handled outside the Perl software ecosystem, as all the srand* functions effectively became nops on OpenBSD in favour of strong random numbers, and userland ports had to be patched to use the deterministic variants if needed. I guess that would be hard with things like CPAN. https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648ddbc62f0a74abf9e098d#diff-b1d655ef1da257a3f4c33327fb83bd0dR20776 https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648dd... https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648ddbc62f0a74abf9e098d#diff-6f239a14c0c4e792da78a0310d16d9a1R4652 https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648dd... https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648ddbc62f0a74abf9e098d#diff-9dc22d2e9511b13cd64378f8671179edR3133 https://github.com/openbsd/src/commit/2e109fb9e8c0dc273648dd... Looks like upstream Perl also uses drand48 from FreeBSD, with its own internal RNG. But I guess this can be overridden with build options. I'd imagine something like pwgen would be better, but I doubt it matters here.
- hoytech 8y ago
  Thank you for the details. I agree none of this probably matters much for their use-case.