4 ms·
>Markets cannot incentivize conservation. This is not true. If you and I believe that the scarcity of a resource will rise tomorrow, we will try to buy it toda
by whatshisface 8y ago
>Markets cannot incentivize conservation.
This is not true. If you and I believe that the scarcity of a resource will rise tomorrow, we will try to buy it today so that we can sell it for a higher price after it becomes harder to get. All resource speculation (and boy, there is a lot,) is market-incentivised conservation.
- da_chicken 8y agoExcept you're requiring someone to choose to not make money today in order to maybe make more money tomorrow. If the seller thinks scarcity will rise tomorrow, they'll just raise prices today. Capitalist markets are traditionally both selfish and short-sighted. Market limits are how black markets are created. Eventually the market demands will raise prices high enough to incentivize illegal activity. See: elephants, rhinos, whales, etc.
- stale2002 8y ago> If the seller thinks scarcity will rise tomorrow, they'll just raise prices today Yes they will. And this increase in price will cause people to use less of it, because people don't like wasting money. Nothing is being made illegal, so there are no black markets.
- js8 8y ago> If you and I believe that the scarcity of a resource will rise tomorrow But I don't! If the resource is not to be used tomorrow, or any other day (that is, being conserved), then why should I believe it will be scarce? The problem is that you simply cannot assign a finite price on something that you're never going to use.
- shadofx 8y agoSome of our medical machines were invented under the assumption that Helium would be dirt cheap. Once the price of helium rises those machines will become absurdly expensive to operate, and people will start dying of treatable diseases. Not your stated problem, but still a thing to keep in mind.
- danmaz74 8y agoDon't worry, the market will sort that out too. The rich will have the machines, and only less worthy individuals will die. /s
- ISL 8y agoAs the price rises, helium recapture and liquefaction will become more common. As recapture and liquefaction becomes more common, the price of the necessary equipment will tend to drop. There is an experiment in our lab (ADMX, an axion search) for which it is already financially more expedient to re-liquify. In addition, new cooling technology is becoming more prevalent. Closed-cycle pulse-tube cryocoolers are becoming common throughout physics.
- phyzome 8y agoThat's a nice theory, but the investors are humans, so they don't tend to go for long-term speculation.
- ska 8y agoYou are both sort of right. Markets can contains incentives for conservation, but empirically have done a rather poor job of it. Part of the reason is undoubtedly the fact that the investors as a collection of economically-rational-actors models is incorrect, but there may be more to it as well.