3 ms·
> When you are gay or trans and a significant chunk of people find your mere existence revolting, when you are black and a significant chunk of people believe y
by philwelch 8y ago
> When you are gay or trans and a significant chunk of people find your mere existence revolting, when you are black and a significant chunk of people believe you are innately less intelligent and more prone to violence, when you are a woman and a significant chunk of people believe you have no business starting a career or working in tech or people don't believe you when you claim to have been sexually assaulted, it's hard to treat "politics" as an abstract debate where free-thinking intellectuals joust in the marketplace of ideas. In these contexts, you actually live "politics" - every day, from the moment you wake up to the moment you sleep. You can't opt out of it.
I've never seen any of these ideas openly expressed in the workplace, or for that matter, anywhere.
You know what's more dangerous than treating politics as an abstract debate? Treating it as a constant life-and-death struggle where enemies must be destroyed before they destroy you. The ideas you're talking about aren't even the ideas being expressed by anyone of importance: they're straw men arguments that propagandists falsely accuse people of perpetuating via "dog-whistles" so that you ignore and dismiss what they're actually saying.
- mike10010100 8y ago> I've never seen any of these ideas openly expressed in the workplace, or for that matter, anywhere. Probably because none of them apply to you. > The ideas you're talking about aren't even the ideas being expressed by anyone of importance You need only look at the president of the United States (or the GOP running for governor in Florida) to see that these ideas are expressed by a ton of people who have power.
- methodover 8y ago> I've never seen any of these ideas openly expressed in the workplace, or for that matter, anywhere. Animus against minorities is real. It's not made up. Just because you haven't seen it doesn't mean it isn't real. Is this animus experienced by every member of every minority for every waking moment? No, that was a bit of an exaggeration, sure. But the animus is definitely not zero, like you suggest. You might benefit from educating yourself about feminism, race relations, and gay rights.
- philwelch 8y agoI’m not saying that animus doesn’t exist. Overt animus shouldn’t be tolerated in the workplace and deserves social condemnation, but the existence of animus doesn’t automatically bless or justify any and every political ideology that markets itself as “anti-Xist”. I have personally experienced animus based on my sex, race, and sexuality before, but I don’t want to be in a politicized workplace just because the governing ideology is supposedly for my benefit.
- mike10010100 8y ago> the existence of animus doesn’t automatically bless or justify any and every political ideology that markets itself as “anti-Xist”. I'm confused. How does saying "LGBTQ people deserve respect just like everyone else" somehow bless or justify another political ideology?
- methodover 8y ago> I don’t want to be in a politicized workplace just because the governing ideology is supposedly for my benefit. Workplaces need to say openly and often that, for every minority that's traditionally experienced discrimination in this country, "<minority> are equal and will always be treated with dignity, will be afforded the same benefits, and animus against <minority> will never be tolerated." If this count as "politicizing" the workplace, then, well, I'd say politicize away.
- philwelch 8y agoI'm not arguing in favor of racial discrimination, so I'm not sure what straw man you think you're arguing against. I am noticing an implication on your part that animus against white people, or animus against men, is acceptable and welcome in the workplace. That's definitely a politicization I'm uncomfortable with.
- methodover 8y ago> I'm not arguing in favor of racial discrimination, so I'm not sure what straw man you think you're arguing against. Never said that you were. > I am noticing an implication on your part that animus against white people, or animus against men, is acceptable and welcome in the workplace. Sorry what? You read in something that wasn’t there. Perhaps you ought to read a bit more carefully.