4 ms·
> The involvement of bail bondsmen has a cost; the fact that the major direct cost is paid for by what amounts to a tax on the (potentially wrongly) arrested do
by philwelch 8y ago
> The involvement of bail bondsmen has a cost; the fact that the major direct cost is paid for by what amounts to a tax on the (potentially wrongly) arrested doesn't mean it isn't a cost.
Unless your county is run by a mafia of bail bondsmen or something, this doesn't turn out to be true.
By default, people who get arrested just stay in jail. If someone is able and willing to pay a bail bondsman, that means they would prefer to lose the bond amount than to remain in jail, which means that they're strictly better off. "Why not just release them of their own recognizance?", you might ask. Courts do that sometimes! We're only talking about the cases where the courts don't do that.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> By default, people who get arrested just stay in jail. In a money bail system, sure. But artificially creating a worse default doesn't make the relatively better condition good. Jail as pretrial default is imprisoning the accused, who are presumed innocent, which is a cost (both an economic cost and a liberty cost.) In a pretrial services model, pretrial detention is exceptional, not default.
- philwelch 8y agoPeople are often released of their own recognizance if the judge is confident that they will show up to court. And sure, maybe they should do that more often. Likewise, some people are straight up denied bail. But there’s a wide gray category of people you don’t necessarily trust to voluntarily show up to court, but who can be incentivized to do so through some mechanism short of just going to jail, and getting rid of that mechanism will just keep those people in jail. So what’s that mechanism? House arrest? Ankle bracelet? Hold one of their close family members hostage? I mean, all of those kind of suck, but if you think any of them might be better, you can offer them as an alternative to bail, and if anyone takes them, more power to them.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> People are often released of their own recognizance if the judge is confident that they will show up to court. And sure, maybe they should do that more often. Likewise, some people are straight up denied bail. But there’s a wide gray category of people you don’t necessarily trust to voluntarily show up to court, but who can be incentivized to do so through some mechanism short of just going to jail, and getting rid of that mechanism will just keep those people in jail. So what’s that mechanism? The mechanism in the new California law is a pretrial services system similar to the one that has for years been successfully used in Washington, D.C., in place of money bail. It's not just getting rid of a mechanism with no replacement.